
"Saturday Night Live" skit writers gotta love the American Civil Liberties Union. It so often behaves like a caricature of itself in its never-ending quest to make sure that as many children as possible have the right to be exposed to pornography.
That's what I saw Wednesday when the ACLU of Michigan raised a red flag about a do-not-spam list being considered by the Michigan Legislature. Watch this debate mushroom to the national level as Congress considers a similar proposal by Sen. Charles Schumer, D-NY, in the weeks ahead. The ACLU, in voicing its opposition, prefers to call the list a "database."
Ooooh. A database. Scary. Somebody's keeping records. That has privacy and free-speech implications.
Thankfully, members of Michigan's House Technology and Energy Committee seemed to roll their eyes at the ACLU hand-wringing. Sen. Nancy Cassis, R-Novi, was the committee voice of reason when she politely pointed out that the real privacy issue is that unsuspecting families are being exposed to unspeakable filth sent unsolicited by porn-peddling spammers.
If that isn't an invasion of privacy, I don't know what is.
Pornography -- and increasingly perverted, graphic and violent pornography -- is a huge part of the staggering spam problem, accounting for as much as 30 percent of all the unsolicited bulk e-mail sent over the Internet, according to stats gathered by Brightmail, a company that makes spam-blocking technology used by many of the nation's largest Internet providers.
"The right of any group to have free speech should never erode the right of an individual to reject what comes into their homes uninvited," said Cassis, who has tangled with the ACLU before over pornography controls on Internet computers at public libraries in Michigan.
The ACLU represents both right and left in the fight to preserve civil liberties. There is a proven track record on this score. Freedom of speech is absolute. Spam is a branch of free speech just as picketing is. This is well documented in law. Pornographic is also considered free speech. Like it or not, that is the way it is. Tax it to death, regulate it to the ends of the earth, build filters in software......all to naught. The sick puppies that subscribe to the porno sites encourage and accelerate the propagation of the industry as a whole. Perhaps the exposure of the users of the sites would be a better bet in the control of this industry, not the trampling of a sacred civil right such as free speech. Think things through and stop harassing organizions tht really help all of us in the final analysis....Think!!! Quit sounding like a jackass!!!!
Posted by: Elvin Jr. at May 2, 2003 01:45 PMYou make me sick defending the right of these twisted, evil sick scumbags to send porn. That is NOT free speech. And fools like you that try to link it to some consitutional right to assault innocent people with perversion ought to be ashamed to call themselves human.
Posted by: Ralph at May 2, 2003 03:07 PMElvin, you are so completely wrong.
Spam is advertising pure and simple. By it's very nature it does not discriminate nor can it on the basis of age.
Sending pornographic spam to children is wrong and illegal and those responsible should be sent to jail for life.
Maliciously and falsely yelling "Fire" in a crowded building is the reminder that free speech rights are not "absolute," and only the criminally insane would claim they were. The spammer expects us to both accept and pay for messages promoting fraudulent goods and services. Knowing these products are both undesired and unethical, the spammer masks its identity with a forged return address. In our efforts to restrict access to our email inbox to these thieves, we devise elaborate filtering methods that are no different than putting locks on the doors of our homes or barring the windows. Even with these precautions, the spammer employs methods to bypass the filters, as if to pick the locks and break into our private domains. What is our expected response when, in our bedrooms in the dead of night, we have discovered such a deviate that has broken into our home and announces a need to sell us pirated software, get rich pyramid schemes, or an irresistible new viagra substitute? Actually, the spammers have told us exactly what to do - "just hit the delete key" (i.e. - pull the trigger). Before I am willing to grant any message space in my email inbox to a spammer based on the concept of "freedom of speech" I want a list of everything these spammers have done to earn this privilege, and then I want to exercise my right to refuse access.
Posted by: Tracer at May 2, 2003 04:55 PMTracer: Incite to riot is another.
Gerry: Advertisement IS free speech...read your law books.
Ralph: Put your glasses on and read what I said....Porn is sick but it is protected and you can not do a thing about it. It has already been tried and failed before the Supreme Court of the U.S. Porn becomes a narrow path for local communities to walk and regulate. You people are not really up on your law are you?.....Think!!!!!
Elvin
Posted by: Elvin Jr. at May 2, 2003 07:34 PM"Ooooh. A database. Scary. Somebody's keeping records. That has privacy and free-speech implications."
Mike, I would expect better from you. Should we hold up the Detroit Free Press from publishing because of "Porno Ads?" Databases are kept and used for the benifit of a varity of people, and for all uses.....it's a free country remember? You, as a member of printed journalism, are a guardian of the Constitution of the United States.
What we have in this thread is small minded thinking toward a problem. I do not like porno and spam any more than the above readers and responders. They are not all wrong. The solutions proposed indicate limited thinking. The first thing people want to do is limit free speech.....how about we limit free religion and how about we limit freedom of the press?. Now I know that my case is worn with years of use.....but it has stood the test of time.
People: find some other way to limit spam and porno and still not intrude on the bill of rights and I'll be the first to lead the charge. If you do limit OUR civil rights, then you have a fight on the docket. Remember the bill of rights are part of our civil rights in the United States. I did not spend my time in the Marine Corps in defense of the constitution just to have the constitution pummeled by light weight minds. I wonder: has anyone here read the U.S. Constitution?? or studied it in various law classes??
Posted by: Elvin Jr. at May 2, 2003 08:18 PMThe constitution being pummeled because we want to ban spam? Good grief Elvin, what has happened to YOUR mind?
Free speech stops at my doorstep. Neither you nor the porn-pushing spammers nor the ACLU has a right to intude into my home unless you are invited in.
What is so hard to figure out about that?
A do-not-spam list is the single best solution yet proposed. If you are opposed to databases, you better go after Socal Security, your local DMV, your County Clerk, your Registrar of Deeds, your Voter Registration office because those are all data bases.
Get real and grow up.
You are a surprise, sir. You missread my e-mail.
Elvin
PS
I'm about 20 years older than you are and I build databases for a living on a MAC.(10.2.5)
PPS
Use the rules in mail, spam dies so fast that it is really amusing.
:-) Well... whay didn't you say your a Mac head! We're practically brothers and you are obviously much more astute than I gave you credit for!
The rules have helped a lot... but spammers are trickier and trickier. My Mac mail rules seem to be losing their effectiveness... but that's a discussion I have going over on my www.mac-mike.com blog.
Seriously... post anytime Elvin. Debate and passion on the issues is always welcome.
The issue is not whether pornography is protected. Larry Flynt took that to the supreme court and won 30 years ago.
The issue is whether anyone has the right to advertise porn to minors. Not even Flynt had the audacity to try that.
Anyone who defends advertising porn to children is scum pure and simple regardless of what brand of computer they happen to use.
The ACLU is responsible for much of decline of this society. It should be expected that they would oppose anything that would make it harder for people to receive obscene material... or kill babies... or stop families from disintegrating. You shouldn't be even giving them publicity.
Posted by: Ronny D at May 2, 2003 08:07 AM