« Ultimate in connectivity | Main | 17-inch G4 PowerBook is a monster »

April 25, 2003

Michigan to recall controversial anti-piracy law

Enough is enough, says the sponsor of a controversial update to the Michigan penal code that has been roundly criticized by the tech community as unreasonable effort to stop Internet piracy.
He's now willing to recall the bill and rewrite parts of it. Among other things, critics of the March 31 update of Public Act 672 claim state legislators were pressured by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) into writing in new restrictions to the state's old telecommunications law that would prohibit people from having firewall protections on their home computers or from using things like Virtual Private Networks (VPNs), a popular way many workers use to connect from home to the computer system back at the office.
"That is not the intent at all," says State Rep. James Koetje, R-Walker, the sponsor of the update. "These people either haven't read the bill or have misunderstood it. All the new wording does is prohibit attempts to defraud or unlawful use of electronic devices."
Not so, says outfits like the Electronic Freedom Foundation, which claims that the language of the is "so broad that it could ban critical security and privacy tools online as well as restrict what machines you can connect to the cable, satellite, and Internet lines in your home."
The group says Michigan and six other states that have updated their laws in the same way have been heavily lobbied by the movie industry to use state laws to expand the reach of the federal Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) of 1968. This has created, in effect, "super-DMCA's," claims Fred von Lohmann, an attorney with the Electronic Freedom Foundation.
"These proposals dramatically expand the power of entertainment companies, ISPs, cable companies and others to control what you can and can't connect to the services that you pay for," he writes on the EFF site.
Koetke, meanwhile, conceded that the movie lobbyists weighed in on the updated Michigan law and offered lots of suggestions but "our law is not intended to make criminals out of people who have security or privacy features on their Internet connections."
The movie industry claims it loses $3 billion annually to piracy and that new privacy and file-swapping technologies make it even easier to steal and illegally distribute movies on the Internet by encoding or scrambling digital communications.
The outrage has been so strong over the new law that Koetje told me he thinks it needs to be brought back to the legislature and rewritten with much better clarification.
"We think we add language that makes it clear that what is being banned is theft of copyrighted information," he said. "This is not as scary or horrific as some people are saying. We need to make that clear so everyone will settle down."
(This is an expanded-for-my-blog version of my newspaper column for today)


in News | TrackBack (1)

Comments

Don't we all miss Napster ?

Posted by: dug at April 25, 2003 12:06 PM

Great news!
Let's hope other legislators take notice before crafting vague laws that can be later used by clever lawyers in ways they weren't intended.

Posted by: Daniel at April 25, 2003 02:19 PM

It took you long enough to write something about this law that went in to effect when, the beginning of this year?

If the legislature truly didn't intend the law to be interpreted as we do, then why didn't they write the law plainly in the first place?

Let's not forget that saying a politician will do something, and actually doing it are two different things. Until the law is repealed or ammended it remains an issue. Let's not let Koetje's words be nothing more than a smoke screen. We need the press to keep the light on this issue!

Posted by: Frank McPherson at April 26, 2003 11:35 AM

Gee Frank, you sure are crabby today.
The updates law took effect March 31 of this year.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at April 26, 2003 03:45 PM

Miss Napster? Heck no. DC, DC++, Kazaa, and WinMX are just so much better.

Posted by: JosiahQ at April 26, 2003 04:23 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits