« All eyes on Apple's music play | Main | SARS blogs replacing War blogs »

April 23, 2003

Beware of Wi-Fi hype

I'm a big user and booster of WI-Fi.
But I also must say it is generating much more hype than it needs. I did a radio interview yesterday and the host asked me about all these franchise-like operations trying to get investors into Wi-Fi companies that install or create wireless networks.
It ain't gonna work.
Same as MacDonald's offering Wi-Fi and fries. Borders Books selling WI-Fi access. Or any of the other public places that think customers are going to bring their laptops and PDA's to their business and pay a fee to surf the Net as they shop, eat, whatever.
We go to MacDonalds to eat FAST FOOD. Not to leisurely read e-mail or check stock prices or shop eBay. And why would anyone bring a laptop to a book store? It's just silly how all these businesses think that by saying they have Wi-Fi they're going to tap into this huge audience of geeks wandering around with laptops desperately looking for a Net node. But what's even more foolish is they think we're so Internet-addicted that we'll pay them money to hook up in their stores and restaurants.
The fatal flaw of most of these Wi-Fi "hotspots" that are popping up around the country is the outrageous fees being charged... up to $10 an hour in some places, or $29.95 a month.
The only place Wi-Fi access fees will work is hotels, where it's worth $9.95 for 24 hour access NOT to be stuck with dial-in and the ridiculous telephone fees the robber barons who run our hotels charge. Maybe airports.
Wi-Fi hotspots have to be free or much, much cheaper than the various plans floating around now.
So after a few more months of hype, watch for stories saying WI-Fi is a bust.
It's not, of course. But the let's-create-a-trend-and-price-gouge-wireless-users efforts will fail and wiser heads will realize that Wi-Fi is inexpensive to install and a customer draw. Like air conditioning and comfortable chairs, it will be part of the ambiance and free.


in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I agree... It's silly to have net access at a book store or McDonalds. But since I own an Auto Repair shop, it might be a good idea for my customers to play on the net while I fix their cars. So long as I don't charge them to use my PCs! As it is now, many of my customers play with my computers while they wait anyway. They think it's really neat, and so do I.

Posted by: Geek at April 23, 2003 09:16 AM

I could never figure it out either but whenever I go to Borders or Starbucks I see the same people sitting their with their laptops. They don't appear to be buying much so WiFi might be a good way to get some $ from them.

Posted by: gerry at April 23, 2003 10:17 AM

There is a coffee house in Howell (say it with me "HOWELL"), The Uptown Coffee House that offers free wifi. I go there about twice a month, plunk down $3.50 for coffee and a pastry ($10.00 or more if the family is with me) and surf. Great for those HUGE Mac updates and emailing big files.

They haven't seen a lot of traffic because of it - though it seems to me that they haven't done a great deal of promoting it either, but they do see regulars like me coming back again and again.

I'm working on a local proprieter in downtown Brighton to create a free "WiFi Commons" down by the millpond. I think it might be a draw for foot traffic. If mesh technology turns out to be as good as they say, we could "unwire" the whole downtown area.

Mike, do you know of a listing of WiFi hospots in S.E. Michigan?

Posted by: Barry at April 23, 2003 09:21 PM

Good idea, Barry. I'd like to compile such a list. But we'd want to do free ones. Those price gougers need to be excluded. Keepo me informed on your Brighton idea. That's a terrific story.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at April 25, 2003 08:54 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits