« Children's prison liberated in Iraq? | Main | Reason 646492 why Saddam had to go »

April 09, 2003

Arab news sites view of Baghdad's fall

The dramatic and vivid images of the fall of Baghdad that many Americans woke up to see this morning were also viewed by the Arab world , but often with a much different reaction. While most U.S. and western media reports talked about the collapse of Saddam's regime and the emergence of a new Iraq, Web sites and chat rooms from many Arabic countries bristled with skepticism and - often - outright hostility.
As the statue of Saddam toppled in downtown Baghdad this morning, the chat room on the Jordan-based Al Bawaba Web site was being filled with over 150 postings like this

"I will never accept this pure Arab land to be polluted by the American filth?"
Most Arabic news sources accurately reported the occupation of downtown Baghdad, although the tone was markedly different than many of the western media accounts that often compared the live TV images to the collapse of the Berlin Wall.This commentary on the Web site of the Saudi-based Arab News was typical:
"Now it's obvious that the Iraqis aren't going to put up a credible fight, and it's equally clear that as a result the world has changed into pretty much what the Americans wanted it to be. The pride the Arabs felt in the initial stages of the invasion, before those legendary 'pockets of resistance' halting the advance of the world's only superpower were revealed as a myth, has been replaced by immense shame and humiliation. The images of US soldiers taking a picnic in the heart of Baghdad will haunt the Arab psyche for generations to come."
Humility, skepticism, disbelief and anger seemed to be the most common reactions in the Arab media.


in News | TrackBack (0)

Comments

It is a shame that people had to die. It seems that most of the Arab world will fail to remember that three men could have turned themselves over to another country, pretty much any other country, and prevented all this bloodshed. This has less to do with American power then the bloated egotism of Saddam and sons.

A Martyr? He destroyed Iraq! Forty palaces were built while hundreds of thousands died due to lack of food and medicine. They died while the regime bought weapons on the black market.

Posted by: Aggie at April 9, 2003 02:34 PM

So, let me understand properly. The Arab world is most concerned with other Arabs "winning" against the United States in military conflict - even if such a "victory" would have come at the cost of preserving a regime that 1) terrorized its citizens and raped Arab land for its own gain and 2) threatened other Arabs in the region with its lust for whatever regional hegemony its weapons could buy for it? If this interpretation of the Arab perspective is correct, we have one seriously irrational group of people on our hands to deal with in foreign affairs. What morons would have been happy with THAT outcome?? It would have been analagous to other Arians in the European regions to have been rooting for Hitler just so the Americans, British and Russions didn't defeat the Arians defending the Nazi regime!!!

Posted by: Jeopardy Racing at April 9, 2003 04:50 PM

I saw a shot of two men at the square where the statue of Saddam was toppled today and they were carrying a banner on which was printed "Human Shields" and was spray painted with "Go Home U.S. Wankers". It was only there for about 20 seconds or so and then they cut away. The commentator made no reference to it. Both sides are definately being spoonfed "sanitized" news. When will we hear the whole story?

Posted by: Bob at April 9, 2003 05:31 PM

Come on, Bob, if you're being "spoonfed" anything, it must be because you are too lazy to take time to investigate. Different reporters have differing views as to what is the "real story". That doesn't mean anybody is "sanitizing" the news. It's YOUR responsibility to read differing views and above all, consider the source, and what might be their motivation. Do you believe aljazeera or Fox News?
In case you didn't know, this is STILL the most free society with the most freedom of the press of any other in the history of civilization. When will you sniveling liberals realize that?

Posted by: DrBob at April 9, 2003 10:22 PM

Never assume. I am a registered Republican -- have been for 20 years. My father is one, too. He was also a newspaper editor that believed that facts should be reported completely and without spin. Now, the media can't have any story more than a few paragraphs long and they reflect the viewpoint of the media outlet. Editorialization is no longer limited to the editorial page. One can believe neither Al Jazeera nor Fox News. Neither is reporting the complete unspun truth.

Posted by: Bob at April 10, 2003 03:26 AM

We have to keep in mind that the seperationof church and state is a condition that exists in America....not the Middle East. If they're talking JiHad, then the participants go to heaven regardless of past digressions....no questions asked. If you compare that to the prospects of eating sand and stepping over camel droppings..it's a pretty good deal. In this country, we have very little to want to escape from. Who in America has a life so desperate that they would want to blow themselves up for a "cause"?? For as much as the Middle East countries hate each other ....they hate us more and that is the common thread that unites them. Life there is as it was in Biblical times and in contrast to Americans who want things at a 2 ghz. rate. There is no middle class....no manufacturing....my God...no WalMart?? They still have tribes for cryin out loud...we killed ours off years ago......biologically.

Posted by: Dug at April 11, 2003 12:13 PM

If the paradigm for resolving conflicts
manifest as in the recent Iraqi conflict, then the assertion that the world lacks credible a social theory calls for serious enterprise.Turning a blind eye to this project is akin to turning our intellectual faculties to middle ages.

Posted by: Shah J at April 19, 2003 11:43 AM

it is so shame killing little babeys to steal
oil shame on you US shame on you US.

Posted by: helen at April 26, 2003 05:34 PM

Having been to the US several times I suppose I should not be shocked at the startling ignorance of the rest of the world displayed on various websites over the past few months. Nonetheless it is very very scary. What gives you the idea that it is any of your business how people in the Middle East run their countries? What effective separation of church and state is there in the US when the president is a born-again Christian heavily influenced by the religious right? Do you not know that the Iraqi state (despite its obvious failings) was the most secular in the region? If we're talking about religious fanatics don't you think a country where abortion doctors are routinely murdered and Darwin is banned by a number of school boards demands scrutiny? The only intelligent contribution above is from Dr Bob who is at least paying attention. The fact is that the standard of foreign coverage and debate in the US media is pitiful, you need to realise this and do something about it instead of the usual embarassing 'patriotic' bleating about how you are the most free country in the history of the universe. There are plenty of intelligent Americans unfortunately they seem to be heavily ournumbered at present.

Posted by: Chris at May 27, 2003 11:55 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits