« Winning hearts and minds with the Phrasealator | Main | Geraldo-a-go-go »

March 31, 2003

Arnett firing debate

I'm down in Florida helping teach a seminar on journalism at the Poynter Institute and you can bet we're all hotly debating the firing of Peter Arnett, as are reporters all over the world. Some of my impressions: If Arnett had said this on MSNBC or an American TV outlet from the US, I doubt very much he'd be fired. We've heard stronger criticism of the war from other pundits, even elected members of Congress. And we've heard a lot of just the opposite - outright war boosterism from the retired generals all the US networks have hired as their military consultants.
The point is here, in the US, we have access to analysis and opinion from both sides and everything in between.
Arnett's problem is that he did an interview from Baghdad, not New York. And he did it on the Iraqi-run, Saddam Hussein-controlled government TV network where his remarks became fodder for propaganda. Iraqi TV doesn't carry other views. Arnett's opinion was not presented as one view of many. It was presented as fact by Iraqi TV and presented in an effort increase resistance by its people - resistance that will likely take the lives of soldiers from Arnett's home country.
I heard a Fox TV network anchor call him a traitor this morning. I think that is flat out wrong.
But Arnett sure made a bad decision. In a nation with a free press where diverse opinion and criticism is part of the free flow of information, his remarks, while over the top, would be only controversial. But in Iraq, Arnett has a very unique role as a US reporter and his comments became a weapon that Saddam's media manipulators are using to stir their people to kill US soldiers.
Bob Steele, Poyters ethics guru, says Arnett's dismissal was justified. "What he did was terribly unwise," said Steele. "Doing an interview with Iraqi-contolled TV professionally and ethically overstepped his role as a reporter and suppossedly objective reporter on the scene there."
Arnett's firing ends some great reporting that he has done over the past few weeks. But his opinionated analysis for Iraqi TV over the weekend means any future reporting would be suspect. To his credit, he apologized for this. But he indeed had to go.
Update: Then there's Geraldo... CNN is now reporting U.S. military officials say Fox News Channel correspondent Geraldo Rivera will be expelled from Iraq after violating the cardinal rule of war reporting Monday by giving away crucial details of future military operations during a live broadcast.


in News | TrackBack (0)

Comments

He did not even know who he was with. He was reporting (imbedded) with the 101st Airborn division but on several ocasions he stated that he was with the 82nd Airborn two distinctly different outfits and I'm sure raised a few remarks from the 101st soldiers. What a loser!

Posted by: RPL at March 31, 2003 11:43 AM

I am in "shock & awe" that in a time when TV networks who resort to paying people to engage in horrid acts to pacify a warped public would even flinch at Arnetts remarks. Uncle Sam musta stepped forward on this one.

Posted by: Dug at March 31, 2003 12:36 PM

A MAN SHOULD BE JUDGED ON THE SUM TOTAL OF HIS LIFE, AND NOT A "MOMEMNTARY LAPSE OF JUDGEMENT"
PETER ARNETTE IS A GREAT REPORTER, AND THAT'S THE WAY HE SHOULD BE LEFT, NIXON WAS A FINE PRESIDENT, IN SPITE OF WATERGATE, AND IF HISTORY DID NOT JUDGE JIMMY CARTER ON THE "SUM TOTAL, " HE WOULD BE THOUGHT OF AS A "BUMBLING IDIOT!" ARNETTE MESSED UP, NOW HE'S PAYING THE PRICE, BUT HE STILL IS A GREAT REPORTER.

Posted by: WARREN at April 1, 2003 09:38 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits