« Troop support sites | Main | Busy war blogging »

March 26, 2003

What to believe, what not to believe

As the war begins its second week, I'm figuring out some rules on judging TV war news credibility. It's clear to me that the U.S. has leaked and planted a lot of disinformation to the army of retired general "expert" TV commentators and press briefers at the Pentagon, who then parrott those plants to the TV anchors.
The news anchors quickly embrace the leaks, restate the info as questions as they debrief the embedded reporters in the field, who then recycle and repeat it all, making it sound as if it is a fact. It's like that game we played as kids where you whisper something to someone and they try to repeat it to the person next to them and so on and so on down the line until the last person has a story that is wildly different or exaggerated from the first message.
War is confusing, Facts change. But here are the rules I'm going to use in filtering the TV news:

1) If it comes from "senior military analysists" it means it's from the high paid retired generals and colonels hired by the networks as commentators, who in turn are being fed by their old pals in the Pentagon. Think of these retirees as cheerleaders.
2) If it's a report attributed to "high ranking defense department officials" it means it's a calculated leak aimed at demoralizing Saddam's loyalists that we should probably consider more propaganda than fact.
3) When they attribute news to "intelligence sources" that means somebody is speculating, guessing. "Preliminary information" means something is a rumor. When a Pentagon reporter answers an anchor's question with "we don't have visualization on that from here," know that he's really saying that there hasn't been a hand-out printed new release given him in the media center.
4) When the TV people go to a hire-a-general to work the maps and start drawing troop concentration locations and blue arrows and move around little tanks, understand they are simply filling time, "thumb sucking" as it's called, and those maps and movement projections mean absolutely nothing. Do you think that the real war plan and real deployment positions would be given away with such precision?
5) If it's a negative story and we're told "US officials are checking into those reports" you can probably assume they're true.
6) If the Pentagon or Centcom official says "I can't confirm that but it would not surprise us" when responding to a question about something particularly terrible or dastardly that Iraq suppossedly did or is planning to do, understand that the official briefer is trying to keep a rumor going but not be officially linked to it so that when it turns out to be false he can deny complicity.
7) Always be skeptical of a question that comes from a reporter who sits in the front row at an official news conference. Those seats are usually assigned and go to the most friendly questioners.
8) And finally, when you see a briefing at Central Command in Qatar, notice all those big plasma TV screens in the background. They're all fake. They do nothing except serve as a "set" that looks impressive to run their PowerPoint presentations for the reporters. In fact, the briefing room there was designed to look like the set in the TV series JAG. Really.
My bottom line after week one: Don't believe guesses, projections, preliminary information or non-visualized information. And ask yourself this: When that Pentagon or White House reporter of anchor-in-Kuwait stands in front of a camera for an hour straight, answering questions and being debriefed by the anchors back in New York, how can he or she really know anything? If they're in front of a camera for an hour straight, you can be sure they don't have much time to work their sources and find out anything new.
That is all.


in News | TrackBack (2)

Comments

Exactly!!!! You just crystalized my thoughts exactly. At first I trusted everything I heard but its pretty clear that we are all being manipulated.

Posted by: Bill S. at March 26, 2003 08:49 AM

After recently read "War is a Force That Gives Us Meaning" by Chris Hedges, I feel your comments are right on target - the myth must show us as the good guys with God and right on our side simply saving the world against those evil supporters of Satin!

Posted by: Rick Harrison at March 26, 2003 08:52 AM

Pretty much on target, but I'm surprised at the undercurrent of astonishment and cynicism. As a former public affairs hack for the military, I can tell you the obligation to serve the mission takes precedence over the obligation to serve the media. This doesn't mean they speak nothing but lies; it does mean they will engage in spin. They are under no obligation to treat a news conference as a debriefing.

Meanwhile, the media aren't covering themselves with credit. I'd criticize typically outstanding news organizations -- like the BBC -- for running with blithely unsourced pieces. Tossed a softball query by the guy in the studio (Q: "Does the Pentagon believe these Iraqi fedayeen have thrown its war plan off track?" A: "Well, they can hardly think anything but that...") we're too often seeing a report that's little more than conjecture and supposition on the reporter's part.

War coverage reflects the problem of filling too much air and paper with too little news. That's why we see stateside media reporting on how they're being treated -- it takes up space. In the field, embeds and unilaterals see things through the end of a straw, and the honchos back in the studios and news rooms see the hundreds of primarily anecdotal reports fed back by those straws. No one is providing coherent reporting on the entire war effort.

Posted by: enloop at March 26, 2003 09:42 AM

So true, after having my 15 min. of fame with the press 8 years ago, I have learned that a person can only believe a third of what is being said and the rest is just to fill up space. I recommend highly to all those who watch or read anything about this war to set judgement aside, and wait till all the facts are in before opening your mouth and maybe saying something that is untrue. For it is through lies and confusion that wars are lost. God Bless you for your time and thoughts that you are willing to share with the world. Please use decernment and pray that God will give you the wisdom as you keep us updated.

Posted by: Toni L. at March 26, 2003 09:49 AM

That is the most excellent critiqe of the media coverage of this war I've seen yet. Sad, but true.

Posted by: Randy reiss at March 26, 2003 07:02 PM

I'm not an expert on military tactics. but I have studied military history and campainges. the way I see things the united states military has put it's self in aposition that if they incounter any organized resistance from the people of eraq they are in for aprotracted gurela war . They attacted with only one infantry division their armor is at least a week away teir supply lines are too long and they don't have the man power to safeguard them. the other troops in the field aren't equipted for aprotracted battle and will have to be resupplied by air . In my oppenion this could turn out to be a real mess like the one I was in in the sixties . let alone the fatique that sets in on combat troops that have been attacking for over a week with out releif or rest anyone that has ever been their knows what I mean apparently the people that planned this have never been their.

Posted by: Don Thomas at March 27, 2003 03:31 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits