
There's a slow and growing backlash about "embeds," journalists attached, embedded, with U.S. military units. For while they have provided compelling video and reports and unprecedented close-up views of the war, questions about the objectivity and, indeed, the accuracy of their reporting are emerging.
The problem is they report what the troops see and have it all filtered through the military "bubble" they are living in.
Another type of on-scene reporter offers the potential of giving us a much more telling view of this war. They're called "unilaterals," because they travel on their own, without military protection.
It's very, very dangerous. Two of them have already been killed. But because unilaterals can see the war from a nonmilitary perspective, they can move among Iraqi civilians and hear their point of view, assess the damage and casualties on the Iraqi side and gauge how well humanitarian aid is moving. ABC News Nightline reporter John Donvan is a unilateral and has a terrific piece online explaining just how risky it is out there for unilaterals. As an example of what kind of story they can produce, consider the trip he and his crew took on their own to Safwan, the southern Iraqi town where residents danced in the streets last week as a U.S. Marine tore down a poster of Saddam Hussein:
... on the day we were there - with no U.S. troops in sight - the atmosphere was very different. We learned that just because the townsfolk don't like Saddam, it doesn't mean they like the Americans for trying to take him out.Donovan also saw civilian injuries, tells us the tragic costs of "collateral" damage and makes us realize that we need reports from people embedded with the people of Iraq, too. Bottom line, though, because it is so dangerous, most of the unilateral news crews have retreated back to Kuwait.
The people were friendly to us at first, but then things got a little tense. They were angry at America, and said U.S. forces had shot at people in the town. They were also angry because they needed food, water and medicine and the aid promised by President Bush had not appeared.
I realized that these people - after years of hearing anti-American propaganda and suffering under economic sanctions - had no reason in their personal experience to see Americans as the good guys. They asked us why the United States was taking over Iraq, and whether the Americans would stay in Iraq for ever.
They saw the U.S.-led invasion as a takeover, not liberation.
By the time we left, children were banging on our car windows, demanding money and food. They had already stolen some radios, a telephone and a camera from our cars. They weren't dancing in the streets.
How long before we get to see unilateral in quotes, like "embedded", or "embeds"?
Posted by: Brian(TX via MI) at March 26, 2003 01:58 AM
Mike:
Posted by: at March 25, 2003 01:58 PMYou state that the "embeds" info is "filtered" by the military. No way! If you listen to what the military "lets" through you couldn't say that. Last night an NBC "embed" stated that their spearhead was running low on supplies and fuel. How stupid the military was to let this type of info get out to the world and this would surely shoot down any thought that the news was being censored.