
I have a friend, a Spanish journalist. She sent me this e-mail tonight:
Today I went to Barcelona's Opera House to watch Rossini's "Il viaggio a Reims". During the last aria, they started to project over theWhat does this mean? It's all spin. People believe what they want to believe. The world is so polarized right now that... I'm going to bed. I am very depressed. How do I convince my journalist friend there is another side? I'm afraid I can't. We have all made up our minds and facts are as we want them to be. Spin city, man. It's all spin. My friend has been spun.
decorations, some pictures of the last European conflicts: WWI,WWII, the
Russian Revolution, Hitler's concentration camps...Then we saw pictures of
Hitler, Mussolini and Franco talking to mass audiences, and finally, the
classic Vietnam picture of the naked girl with their back burning because
of Napalm. The very last picture was one of president Bush. And the music
was so beautiful and the lyrics so explicit that the emotional effect was
clear. The whole theatre stood up in a long applause. I couldn't believe
it in such a place (a very elitist one) but it shows how deeply and widely
Catalans feel against this war. The day before half a milion people
demonstrated in the streets against the war. Next wednesday there is a 15
minutes general strike scheduled and other protest activities...
It means that anti war liberals are emotionally manipulated and blind to facts.
Posted by: Chicago at March 23, 2003 09:01 PMIt must be very nice to be a West European these days.
After giving birth to the evils of the 20th Century, after being rescued and revived by the American republic that owes its existence to the flight from European oppression and bigotry, after being protected against totalitarian rule by 50 years of American lives, blood, and money, they've now managed to put aside enough of their legacy of hatred, racism, and nationalism to build a little umbrella of economic wellbeing. Unfortunately, it seems to have given them a bad case of moral arrogance, as well.
Of all people, you'd think that people who live on the continent that gave us Milosevic, Hitler, Stalin, Lenin, Bismarck, Franco, Mussolini, and centuries of absolute monarchies and militarist regimes would be the first to recognize two realities: 1) Totalitarian regimes have no right to exist, pose a threat to democracies, and must be eleminated; 2) A competent and energetic totalitarian regime cannot be destroyed from within. It can only be destroyed by external force and pressure.
Posted by: enloop at March 23, 2003 09:08 PMCome on. The email was just giving mike insight into the mood there. From the tone of the letter, she's probably very antiwar. But the slice of life details are very telling. No matter how you feel about the war, people have very strong opinions and the way we are all at each others throats is what I think mike was getting at.
Posted by: Farmington at March 23, 2003 09:11 PMOften people will not use a shard of intelligence - just their emotions - spin is all about "feeling" not about choosing to do the right thing. Spin is why I generally don't believe the news media.
Posted by: Philip Schlump at March 23, 2003 09:30 PMMike,
I can understand your feelings of confusion and depression. It's disconcerting when people you consider close friends have a different opinion on a n important subject. Unfortunately it's made even worse because of the extreme emotional nature of this war.
The important thing is to respect their opinion as they should respect yours. Nobody shares the same point of view, especially if they live in another culture and country. I know it may be hard, but keep an open mind and an open dialog.
-Dan
Posted by: Daniel at March 24, 2003 12:50 AMYou and your friend has a difference of opinion: she is no more spun than you are yourself simply because you disagree.
Posted by: David at March 24, 2003 06:22 AMum...it's not a difference of opinion. Sadam's troops are barbarians, just like the Nazi's. Do we shoot our prisoners? Kill our own people as a fear tactic? Pretend we're going to give up and then shoot the enemy? Use kids as human shields? As much as you might hate Bush, he and America are no Hitler. It just amazes me how people turn a blind eye to Sadam and think that Bush is an evil person. I guess it's finally happened...good is seen as evil and evil is seen as good... God help us all.
Posted by: Brian Peat at March 26, 2003 09:35 PMBrian, yes it is a difference of opinion. I doubt anyone would disagree about Saddam's character but the source of global disagreement is whether the US/coalition has the right or responsibility to go in and depose him.
I don't know if your comment about hating Bush was aimed at me, but I gave no indication of my stance on the war or Bush.
-Dan
Posted by: Daniel at March 27, 2003 01:07 PM
What does this post really mean?
Posted by: Barcelona at March 23, 2003 08:51 PM