« Where are the Iraqi WMD? | Main | Drudge shows bodies »

March 23, 2003

The media technowar: Western vs Arab press

There's another war going on.
Arab television viewers are seeing a much different war than Western media viewers. And both sides are telling their viewers not to believe what they're being told by the other.
The same technology that allows western embedded reporters to show us the war with such immediacy is being used by Arab media to deliver live satellite images to its audiences.
Al-Jazeera television has shown terribly gory pictures of the bodies of alleged U.S. troops killed by the Iraqis. The video, though, was provided by Iraqi television - totally controlled by Saddam Hussein. An Iraqi-TV flag was clearly visible on the microphone held by an off-camera reporter who questioned four U.S. prisoners-of-war, two of them obviously wounded. Such exploitation of POW's, especially wounded ones, is a clear violation of the Geneva Convention .
The body shots are even worse. Western media seldom shows bodies, and never in close ups like Al-Jazeera has done. But in other parts of the world, this is not that unusual. There are very different journalistic standards in parts of the world where the media is government-controlled and there has been no tradition of a free and aggressive press. That includes virtually the entire Arab world, though the four-year-old Al-Jazeera network continues to insist it is independent and, indeed, has sometimes grated Arab governments, too.
But its decision Sunday to air the exploitive, inflammatory and stomach-turning shots of the dead Americans has crossed a clear journalistic line and repulsed the Western media.
"It looks like they were killed execution style," said Fox-TV's Tony Snow Sunday afternoon, who then went on to suggest that Al-Jazeera was being used as a propaganda tool of Iraq.
But on Arab TV, U.S. "embedded" reporters are being accused of being exactly the same thing for the coalition. And indeed, that mantra has been picked up on the streets of American cities where leaders of anti-war demonstrations, like the ones yesterday in San Francisco, blasted the embedded reporting and even urged demonstrators to "confront" the local TV reporters covering the protests.
The exact same live cameras focussed on the Baghdad skylike are used by both Arab and Western media. Coalition precision bombs have been carefully programmed not to disrupt that.
The U.S. says it wants the world to see what's happening and so will continue to make sure the bombs dropped on Baghdad don't take out the cameras or TV feedpoints that are used by both Arab and the Western press.
But the same images are being intrepreted very differently by the two sides. And through it all, as the BBC reports Iraq's controlled TV Sunday was showing file video of "Saddam Hussein ... seated at a table in the middle of a large hall, grinning and gesticulating, as hundreds of singers sung his praises with rapturous looks on their faces."
Technology, as good as it may be, doesn't always make the truth less elusive.
As the invasion approaches Baghad and the fighting intensifies, this promises to be the only war in which technology allows both sides to tell its stories, live, as it happens.
Discerning the truth, though, promises to be as confusing and frustrating as always.


in | TrackBack (0)

Comments

What became of the "human shields." Are they still in the news?

Posted by: Tracer at March 23, 2003 04:44 PM

They're coming back... many realizing thay'd been "had."
Read this:
http://www.upi.com/view.cfm?StoryID=20030321-023627-5923r

Posted by: Mike Wendland at March 23, 2003 04:58 PM

I don't trust a word out of the Arab press. Some of their newspapers claimed that we dropped an atom bomb on Baghdad!!!! Some of the arab press claimed Jews did the 9-11 attacks.

Posted by: Earl at March 23, 2003 05:10 PM

I think that as bad as our media is at some times, they at least try to be accurate. They make mistakes but a free press keeps us all free. That is obviously not the case in the Arab world. Thanks mike for making us think about what we're seeing. I guess after seeing the Arab press in action I will be more thankful for our media. Our reporters are dying to tell us the truth.

Posted by: drbob at March 23, 2003 05:18 PM

CNN showed Iraqi POWs the other day and just about everybody ran the picture of the two guys on their knees with a white flag.

Posted by: Gerry at March 23, 2003 07:34 PM

For God's sake, you dolt, it was a wide shot and raw, in the field, taken while it happened.
The Arab video was staged and the hurt and dazed soldiers were being literally interrogated. Two of them were obviously hurting form wounds without medical treatment!!!!!!!!!!i
Are you so stupidly ignorant that you don't see a difference????
God save us from people like you.
Go. Leave. Go over there. You have no right to live in this nation if you feel that way. You make me sick.

Posted by: ron blasic at March 23, 2003 08:09 PM

way to go ron..sad thing that there is so many like gerry out there that just dont have a clue what is going on.....too bad people just cant see the big picture instead of being so narrow minded

Posted by: john at March 23, 2003 08:19 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits