« A blog from Baghdad | Main | Sky News Internet offers live video of war »

March 20, 2003

Debka disinformation

Three BIG strikes against Debka, the Israeli military and intelligence news site that many have been following since 9/11.
1) Wednesday, about 8am EST, they reported the ground invasion had started. It hadn't, and didn't until noon today.
2) Also early Wednesday, Debka claimed Tariq Aziz had defected. He hadn't. In fact, at noon EST Wednesday, he was on Iraqi television denying he had fled Saddam. A Wall Street Journal reporter just called me and interviewed me about Debka's fall from credibility. She said Debka claims it really wasn't Aziz on TV yesterday, but a look-alike.
3) This morning, Debka claimed the "Surrender of two Iraqi divisions in Basra area of southeastern Iraq is in negotiation with US military officers." It hasn't happened.
It's hard to always be right on breaking news. But it's even harder when you're wrong.
If Debka's chagrined by the bogus stories, it sure isn't evident this afternoon. The latest claim: "DEBKAfile's military sources: Iraq may shoot missiles against Israel, Jordan, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia Thursday night after big US-UK air offensive begins."
Uh huh. Sure. Right. Then again, it may not. Or maybe it will.
Stop it already.


in News | TrackBack (1)

Comments

I've been following Debka for a long time now, and they're always self-promoting; "As first reported in Debka ..." However they never point out when they got it wrong which is far more often then when they get it right.

Posted by: jthornton at March 20, 2003 06:19 PM

1) Groundunits *did* move into Iraq as debka stated, this was later confirmed by the pentagon and could be seen on CNN. (Part of the demilitarized zone is Iraqi territory, and "forward positions" were taken in). Debka did *not* report engagements with Iraqi troops, just that forces moved into Iraqi territory.

2) Tariq Aziz may not have defected, this is true. His defection was not just reported by debka but also CNN etc. Debka stated that *their kurdish sources claimed to have captured Aziz*.
Nowhere did Debka state that the man seen on the press conferance was a double, merely that only reporters from trusted gulf states were allowed at the pressconferences.

3) That surrender is being negotiated does not mean it will actually happen.

Dekba may be part fact part rumour, but in your "big strikes" you don't even properly quote them...

The "iraq may fire missles" report is of the same kind we've seen on every newschannel and site for the past few months.

Debka does not make up stories. It has it's own sources for newsgathering. They may not always be 100% accurate (surthenly no source ever is) or 100% reliable.

The problem is more two things: most of all the other big media use the same sources (different ones from Debka) such as Reuters etc. This makes Debka stand out more. The second problem is the way Debka tends to present some rumours as if they are a bit more then just that, and that they'll probably be the last to admit they were wrong. Other newssources suffer from this same problem (maybe a bit less) but when they are wrong, almost everyone is wrong, because almost everyone relies on them, and almost everyone is wrong. It doesn't stand out as much..

Debka has proven in the past to sometimes be far ahead of the rest..

For example, Debka was definatly the first to report Umm Qasr has fallen. The Iraqies have been denying this for a while now..but guess what's on BBC World now?

Are you willing to take back your "bogus stories" claim? Or are you like Debka ;) and do you prefer to rather just forget your mistakes and move on

Posted by: Tijl at March 20, 2003 06:49 PM

Oops, filled in the wrong emailaddres (autofill forms etc.) In the unlikely case anyone cares...

Posted by: Tijl at March 20, 2003 06:52 PM

So debka is the "unofficial" mouth piece of the Israeli miltary.

You don't go there for truth.

You go there to contemplate what is behind what the Israeli militarists are saying.

Posted by: JoeRandom at March 20, 2003 06:52 PM

You have to take Debka for what it is, "beyond the news". Intelligence sometimes is just rumors. But then so is news. UKland news was also reporting the same land engagement as Debka.

Don't think that there weren't ground troops in Iraq before the President's announcement. But don't think that they will ever admit there were. Thats what special ops are about - Plausible deniability.

Whether Debka was correct about where they were, at this point we don't know.

Posted by: manis2society at March 20, 2003 07:31 PM

I quit reading debka a year ago when they reported that war in Iraq had already begun. They're totally unreliable, though sometimes they guess right.

Posted by: Joe at March 20, 2003 07:45 PM

Debka has indeed gotten a lot of things right and way before western media, too... they were the first to report Saudi reluctance to cooperate with US war on terror plans - at the same time that the US would have had us believe all was well with our Saudi allies. Debka had that one cold.
They were also right in identifying the gunman who went crazy at LAX in front of the El Al counter as an Hammas associate.
They were right and first on many of the Taliban stories.
But the Tarik Aziz and "it has started" stories yesterday and today's premature mass surrender hype (which probably will be true) has tarnished some of that success.
I'll still chgeck Debka...often. But I will be more skeptical.... although there's lots of time left in this war and they may outscoop every one else again.
Something else that has to be said... Debka is probably under much more censorship pressure than western reporters. I applaud them for keeping on.
See this story: http://news.com.com/2100-1028-993528.html?tag=fd_top

Posted by: Mike Wendland at March 20, 2003 08:00 PM

I consider Debka to be an above average source for Mid-East news, and have found they may lead US newspapers or TV by as much as 2 to 3 days. It's a far better source of info than the tripe that Drudge posts and I have the joy of not listening to his whining self promoting commentary.

Posted by: K. Elliott at March 24, 2003 03:04 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits