
Q:Still, Apple's market share seems stuck at about 5% in the U.S. and 3% worldwide.Cool stuff.
Jobs: So our market share is actually greater than BMW's -- greater than Mercedes -- in the car industry. And, yet, no one thinks BMW or Mercedes are going away, and no one thinks that they're at a tremendous disadvantage because that's their market share. Matter of fact, they're both highly desirable products and brands.
I would liken your roads and gas stations to the Internet and CD-R blanks. Software for computers is more akin to having to take you BMW in for "scheduled" maintenance. Nothing like paying $45 for an oil change :)
I think it's a valid argument to a degree. People point to market share all the time when they dog Apple. Now there is a fairly logical come back.
Posted by: Charlie Jones at December 16, 2003 11:09 AMThe point I think Jobs was trying to make was not to find a perfect analogy, but that the idea of "low" marketshare is somehow an anathema to success. It's not just BMW and Mercedes. Does Prada have 50% of the fashion market? Do 80% of women wear Jimmy Choo stilettos? What percentage of Americans shop at Banana Republic?
Jobs hits the point right on - it's not about marketshare, but whether Apple has the ability to continue innovating. Innovating means coming out with the next generation of PowerBooks and PowerMacs and iPods. Innovation means being able to create something like Mac OS X, or redefine the very core of an industry with something like the iTunes Music Store. As long as Apple has the financial viability to continue making great products, the company will do well. Just ask anyone who owns a set of Dewalt power tools, uses a Cross pen instead of Bic, or shaves with a Gilette Mach 3 razor instead of 49 cent disposables.
Of course it will be nicer if Apple had more marketshare. But consider that Apple in the late 80s and early 90s had as much as 20% marketshare. Yet that marketshare did very little good in terms of innovation, and Apple still find ways to lose a lot of money.
It's more important that Apple maintain its level of innovation. Dell, in raw dollar terms, spends more money on R&D than Apple does. Yet Apple gets far more innovation per dollar than Dell could possibly dream of. I mean, come on, would any of us be happy if Apple had three times the marketshare but "innovates" at the same rate as Dell?
Marketshare is like a drug - companies that pursue it blindly are doomed to consign themselves to "playing it safe," doomed to stagnate, and doomed to move slowly. Investors should focus on what kind of financials Apple needs to be able to fund that innovation, and not focus merely on numbers that look big but results little in the way of products consumers will love.
Just my opinion. By the way, the car analogy isn't bad, because Macs and PCs both can access the Internet (roads), powered by the same electricity (gas). The fact that they run different operating systems doesn't undermine the analogy - you couldn't take the engine controller computer for a BMW and plug it into Ford, either, but that doesn't stop people from buying BMWs or Fords because they are worried the car's electronics are wholly incompatible!
What matters - for both cars and computers - is how well they can get the job done for the people who use them. And for both driving and computing, I prefer BMWs and Macs over Fords and Dells.
Posted by: Paul at December 16, 2003 02:39 PMDon't get me wrong -- I love the Mac and find that I can do everything I want to do with a computer just fine, and have fun doing it. But, unlike the Mercedes and BMW drivers who know they can go down the same roads as Fords and Kias without thinking about it, we Mac users do sometimes have to seek alternate routes. For example, a Windows user doesn't have to worry that a major ISP may not support his/her platform. Yes, we can just about always find a solution, it's just not always as readily accessible as it is for Windows users. Even on the Internet, I'll run into "IE-optimized" sites that create problems for Safari (an online digital-photo-processing site only worked with IE). Of course, I can just launch IE, but it frustrates me to know that some commercial sites cater to the default standard -- IE -- and therefore lock me out of using my browser of choice. And now that MS no longer develops Mac IE, I have to wonder how much longer Mac IE 5.2 will work with IE-optimized sites.
Again, I'd never trade my Mac for a PC, but being in the minority means we can't take things for granted the way Windows users can. (Of course, we can take it pretty much for granted that a virus won't wipe out our hard drives or that our next OS install won't require an activation number...)
Posted by: scott at December 16, 2003 03:54 PM
Much as I love the Mac, this is an analogy that always breaks down for me. The difference is, Mercedes and BMW drivers can use the same roads and gas stations as Fords and Kias, whereas Mac users can't always use the same software and computer stores as Dell and HP users. This is getting better and tends not to be too much of an issue for most of us, but it's still relevant. (Of course, you could argue that our roads and gas stations are better anyway, but that's another story.)
Posted by: scott at December 16, 2003 09:49 AM