
Mike:
As you correctly pointed out in your conversation on "Your Mac Life", Mac users _are_ perceived to be an arrogant bunch. My very own brother was recently in the market for a new computer, and he commented, "I won't buy a Mac. I hate Mac users. They're arrogant." I tried not to take that personally, but I conceded that he had a point.
(I resisted the urge to chortle when his shiny new Compaq was hit with a virus less than a week after he bought it, and he had to reinstall everything. True story).
The fact is, we do come across as a bunch of arrogant elitists. Perception is reality, and we all need to tone down the rhetoric a bit. Besides which, I have no problem with being in the minority if it helps keep hackers at bay.
Posted by: Rich at December 12, 2003 09:10 AMIn the past (not recently, though), I've been verbally attacked for being a Mac user. After engaging in brief discussion, I invariably found that the other person had little to no knowledge of Macs, and was simply parroting what was taken for "common wisdom."
So you tell me: who's arrogant?
Posted by: Rich at December 12, 2003 09:45 AMOSX is "just as insecure as Windows" Because it has ONE security that only affects a very small percentage of users, compared to Windows with massive security holes being reported every week, and viruses that wipe out entire businesses, forcing them to actually close their doors? Yeah, Riiiiight...
Posted by: Derek at December 12, 2003 10:09 AMThe "Switcher" spoof is hilarious. What else is hilarious is that PC Mag opinion piece by Lance Ulanoff' - it's hilarious that he gets paid for writing such garbage. What a 'steaming pile' that column is, and no, I don't say that because he's picking on me (boo hoo), I say that because any 7 year old can sit at a keyboard and type, "I know you are, but what am I?" There's nothing thought provoking about his piece. There is nothing inspiring. There is nothing informative. PC Magazine should be embarrassed they wasted the bandwidth uploading that thing to their servers....Ulanoff was right about one thing though - not very many people use Macs so why bother to attack them - it won't be noticed. Yep. That's just the way I like it too.
Posted by: Tim S. at December 12, 2003 11:55 AMI no longer say anything to my friends and family about my Mac. My husband knows and loves Mac, and that's all I care about. The rest of them, they put me down, some of them quite nastily, while defending their Win PC's. I don't need or deserve that stress. When they talk about their computer viruses and hanging programs, my husband and I just smile and nod our heads. Being in the minority is not necessarily a bad thing. We are looking forward to adding a new Mac next spring.
Posted by: Carol at December 12, 2003 12:11 PMI've seen almost all the anti-Mac parodies, and some are even funny... but this one isn't. Why? Because it doesn't make any sense. The guy behind it clearly doesn't understand his technology, and is masking his insecurity behind generalizations and falsehoods.
He claims that his Mac just "shuts off" for no reason. I have never seen this happen on any one of the thousands of Macs I have worked on. Ever. (Now the PC's on the other hand...)
He refers to applications as "executables" and is annoyed that Apple's Software Update fixes his OS for him (as if Windows' Update Mechanism, or the Messenger vulnerability is any better.)
He calls the Apple/Control key a "cloverleaf" and doesn't even know how to force a restart (Control-Option-Power.) Instead, he says he has to unplug the machine and take out the battery. He's applying Old World hacks to New World tools. He's not "thinking different."
Based on his script, it's sounds to me like he's an old-fashioned DOS guy, and he's just bitter that the entire world has moved to the user-friendliness of a GUI. Someone apparently forced him to use a Mac, and it made him feel like his intelligence has been wasted all these years; he can't be a smug DOS guy anymore, and now the bar is raised. No one cares about DOS anymore, now it's about letting the computer do it's thing so the user can be creative. And that pisses him off. Because he's not creative. All he's good at is DOS. And no one cares. I'm sure the horse trainers made fun of Henry Ford's contraption too.
He's not a Mac guy, he never will be, and he feels like he's been left out of the party.
Seriously, some of the Apple parodies have made me laugh in the past -- this one didn't. It would be funnier if it had any shred of truth to it -- this guy just doesn't get it.
Posted by: Josh at December 12, 2003 12:25 PMMike,
The "Another windows worm" link would be better served on your Tech-Knowlogy blog then here, don't you think? I think PC users need to know about it and not so much your Mac people, since you all seem to love to degrade windows as much as you can. The link is meant to inform window users...
If this OS X security flaw really is as serious as this writer makes it out to be, I think there would be a much more visible presence of it in on-line discussions at all the various Mac forums.
If anything, Mac users are NOT the *quiet* type.
Posted by: at December 13, 2003 12:24 AM(just in case anyone's wondering, I'm the one who made the comment above - I forgot to put my email)
Posted by: elendial at December 13, 2003 12:27 AM"And if humans ever became the dominant species then we will become insects and get stepped on by larger organisms."
Excellent analogy by NAG at the MacAddict forums:
http://www.macaddict.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=42107
Posted by: elendial at December 13, 2003 07:15 AMWhat is appaling to me is that Lance isn't just a journalist spouting his actual glee at a security flaw found in an operating system. He isn't just a journalist who printed an absurd theory about a single exploit in OS X meaning it is just as insecure as Windows.
He isn't just a journalist, but an *EDITOR* printing those ridiculous and insulting things. What a small and ignorant man he must be.
Posted by: Daniel at December 13, 2003 10:53 AMAUTHOR: cgriego
EMAIL: [email protected]
IP: 67.164.143.60
URL: http://www.invisionthings.com/
DATE: 12/13/2003 12:08:26 PM
I tracked down the source of the parody. It's at http://www.happynowhere.net/mac_parody.htm. It's also VERY funny :P
Posted by: Jesse at December 13, 2003 08:04 PMHere's the straight dope on the "security flaw" in the Mac OS. http://www.infowarrior.org/articles/2003-08.html
Posted by: at December 14, 2003 06:29 PMMaybe in OJ's search for the real killer, he'll unintentionally discover that virus that affects macs...hahaha
Posted by: Boz at December 15, 2003 11:10 AMI posted that "straight dope" link above. If you're interested, John Welch published what has the be the last and best word on the supposed "DHCP Vulnerability" in Panther here:
http://www.bynkii.com/networking/archives/000099.html
Posted by: Seth Dimbert at December 16, 2003 08:40 PMFirst of all, good old lance was WAY off when he pins the lack of security breaches on the Mac to their anemic user base. That's not the reason at all; the reason Windows is vastly more insecure than a Mac (or Linux) is because the user has something called root access. That means any user with an account on a Windows machine can make harmful changes to the OS, damaging, destroying, or harming other computers. I don't think I'll be reading PC magazine any more.
Ryan
Posted by: Ryan at December 21, 2003 03:11 PM
One by-product of my recent switch is a reduction in my computing vocabulary. Specifically, the words "reboot", "crash" and "hang" have been removed :) Really, my eMac stays on ALL the time. The only reason I reboot is after a system update.
The biggest difference I notice is that things just work. This is a difficult concept to get across. I'll be honest, I switched to OS X because I was bored. I didn't get excited until after a few days of using the Mac. I noticed things just worked. You have to experience it, plain and simple.
A great example of the "it just works", I have a Nokia 3650 cell phone, an eMac and a 12 inch iBook. All three stay perfectly in sync with each other. A combination of Bluetooth and iSync just makes it work. All my contacts and appointments are on all three devices. I gave my Palm to my 4 year old. He thinks it's pretty cool.
charlie
Posted by: Charlie Jones at December 12, 2003 08:31 AM