
I don't know about everyone else here, but I would *love* to see what this "curt" reply looks like (an abridged version w/omitted names, etc. will do!)
Posted by: elendial at December 11, 2003 09:35 AMMIke, don't you keep a PC around to evaluate software with? It would do more good for THE CAUSE if you evaluated the software, then criticized them for not having a Mac version. Peter Lewis and David Pogue do this kind of stealth Mac evangelism, but we need more.
Posted by: Brian at December 11, 2003 09:55 AMMike,
It's normal behaviour, nothing unusual I assure you,the way I see it is "pure passion" and better to have passion than not,thus enjoying what once was ordinary.
What's ineteresting is the people here at work who have bought Macs for the first time (lifetime PC users) won't stop talking about what they can do on an iMac and suddenly they want to know more with multitudes of questions.
Simply put, the Mac OS is an experience and the toughest thing is to convey that to a typical Windows user.
Posted by: Sam Hanna at December 11, 2003 10:16 AMI have to agree with Brian. As much fun as it is to call people on their apparent PC arrogance, it probably doesn't help. After all everyone is just trying to make the most for their time and money. You have to admit that pleasing the majority is often more appealing and (unfortunately often times more cost effective) than pleasing the minority which we Mac users know we are. But you all knew that already.
So it pays to show enthusiasm for the software vendor's product
by testing it out and saying afterwards how that would work so much nicer on a Mac and here is why.
Besides Mike, you are a Detroit Free Press reporter and while I'm happy as hell you are a switcher, I think you still have a responsibility to report in an unbiased way. I think you can do that while still shamelessly letting people know your perferences.
Otherwise, you run the risk of looking like those PC weenie reporters who dismiss the Mac without even lifting their heads to see what they are criticizing.
Mike,
I've enjoyed your site; however, calm down big boy because you're starting to think with the wrong head, i.e. too much passion.
I know what you're going through as I switched in 1999. You'll grow out of it... the unbridled youthful passion, that is.
Enjoy your Mac.
Regards and Merry Christmas.
Posted by: Doc at December 11, 2003 01:54 PMHey Mike,
A twist on Brian's suggestion -- Maybe you could review Windows-only software that has a Mac equivalent in terms of function. That way, you could say:
"Software Company X does not make a version of Program Y for Mac OS X, but Software Company A makes a Mac OS X version of Program B that does an even better job of accomplishing the same task."
(Sorry about all those variables!)
Posted by: scott at December 11, 2003 02:25 PMHi Mike:
The only recent viri associated with macs are the ones that cause you to become a mac cultist after just a few months (hours?) of owning or working with a mac. YOU have thusly been infected - welcome to the club!
(I not only refuse to use a program if pc only, I refuse to use mac os 9 anymore - I absolutley LOVE panther.)
Posted by: Linda at December 11, 2003 02:54 PMMike-
You're getting some good suggestions here, so there's not much I can add--except an observation. I think new "switchers" are naturally more excited when they discover a better way because the contrast with the other way is stronger. I've used nothing but Macs at home since 1985, so guess I've mellowed a bit, but I still love using 'em. The advice to maintain your objectivity as a journalist is very wise. But shining a light on the "better way" is a valuable service. Keep it up! Happy Holidays.
Posted by: Joe at December 11, 2003 03:58 PMMike,
I agree with Scott. What better way to sneak in the Mac's superiority than to compare a Mac product to an inferior (or at least aggravating) PC software? Final Cut Pro vs. Adobe Premiere would be a good example. MYOB vs. Quicken might be another. iMovie vs. any of the consumer PC NLEs would also be great, especially considering that the PC movie editing apps all cost money whereas iMovie is free (if you have a Mac).
And how about stuff like Konfabulator (http://www.konfabulator.com/ and http://www.widgetgallery.com/) which has no equivalent on the PC side, as far as I'm aware of? Longhorn's Sidebar has already been trumped with OS X shareware!
Posted by: paul at December 11, 2003 07:17 PMIt's called arrogance, Mike.
Posted by: Bob at December 11, 2003 08:51 PMAs a former non Mac user, starting with a Commodore 64 in 1983, and going through many DOS/Windoze boxes, I switched to a Mac permanently three years ago, and I've never regretted it! I know what you mean about it being a cult, and how it is difficult to describe the Mac experience to a non-believer! I do believe that you should continue testing Windoze software, as others have said, if only to show others that there is indeed a better way.
Happy Holidays!
Posted by: Karl Groeger at December 12, 2003 12:54 AMI take it that "Bob" is a PC user. Cause as a Mac user myself, my experience is that PC users by far display more arrogance than any so-called member of the Mac "cult." For the simple pleasure and pride that we Mac users take in going the different road and enjoying a system that just works, we get hounded by haughty PC owners who somehow always seem to feel threatened by the Mac minority. Perhaps arrogance isn't the best word - maybe bigotry is a better term.
I, for one, am proud to be a Mac user, and that certainly isn't arrogance in my mind!
Posted by: nat at December 12, 2003 07:35 AMSpeaking as a sometimes tech-reviewing journalist, I find it easier to look at stuff that works on the Mac, and then see if there's a Windows equivalent. Salling Clicker is a good one - there's a Win equivalent (does just the same things, slightly pricier) called Jeyo.
Or else comparisons of stuff on the two platforms - iMovie vs MovieMaker, etc. Or simply stuff that's totally cross-platform, such as tabbed browsing (which most people haven't heard of; to many people the idea of opening a fresh browser window to follow a link yet keep what they're reading is radical and untried).
It gets easier. PR people, well, they're not to know, poor lambs.
Charles
Posted by: Charles at December 12, 2003 09:51 AMJust a brief clarification for some readers. Mike is a columnist; as such, he's paid to give his opinions. He doesn't need to be unbiased. He doesn't need to be impartial. Columnists are not reporters; they're paid to write about whatever is on their mind, as long as they do it in an intellectually-rigorous and entertaining way. (Admittedly, many columnists never satisfy either goal!)
So Mike doesn't have to apologize for being a bit of a cultist.
Now, having said that... It certainly isn't a bad thing for a columnist to be fair. Nor would the Mac world be hurt by a few more technology writers like David Pogue, who do write compellingly and persuasively for elegant computing solutions.
Posted by: Richard Levangie at December 12, 2003 09:53 AMMike,
After a particularly grating encounter with one of the many Microsoft shills -- excuse me, resellers -- out there the other day, I was tempted to be rude myself.
The truth is, though, that the Apple concept of the PC -- Steve Jobs' concept, really -- is fundamentally different from Microsoft's. Apple began by designing elegant tools for individual craftsmen. Microsoft began by designing cheap workflow management for office assembly-lines.
These days, of course, there's considerable overlap, as Apple tries to broaden its appeal to the enterprise market (i.e., to survive), and Microsoft tries to assimilate the consumer market. Still, the original concepts are still at the heart of both platforms, and to my mind, at least, make the Mac clearly preferable if you have to buy a PC with your own money.
As for Mac evangelism, a good carpenter understands the difference between a Stanley tuning fork framing hammer and a Chinese tackhammer with a cast-iron head in the 99-cent bin at Wall Mart. The temp in the accounting department doesn't need to, nor does the CEO of his firm. There's just not much point in explaining the joys of the Mac to these folks. It's not their thing.
Which is not to say that we shouldn't help the Apple sell as many Macs as we can -- it's in our interest, after all. You write about your pleasure in using one; I tell the Microsoft shill -- politely -- that he's mistaken about the limitations of the Mac in the enterprise environment, and that my clients aren't interested in replacing their Macs with Wintel machines as a condition of doing business with him. As Scarlett said, tomorrow is another day.
Posted by: William Timberman at December 12, 2003 02:51 PMMike,
I'm very happy to hear that someone with some sort of public weight in the computer arena speaks out if favor of the Macintosh. You shouldn't feel as if you are some crazed Mac zealot. I am an engineer with 25 years experience who uses the Mac in both my professional and personal life (both from my home), but I am forced to use a Wintel PC at work simply because of the lack of applications for the Mac in my profession. I've lost count of the times that nice applications were released that would make my work better, only to find that it was written exclusively for the Wintel platform. When contacted, the publisher would typically reply (and in some cases arrogantly reply) that the Macintosh platform was not worth the attention.
One of the reasons the Macintosh is not doing really well in the professional arena is due to the bias of developers. It amazes me that they will spend an extraordinary amount of time to make their application useable in several flavors of Windows - each requiring as much time to develop as it would be to include the Macintosh OS X platform. Several developers almost choke when I ask about the availability of their product on the Mac platform. One would think that these people believe that the Mac "has cooties" or something as ridiculous. Parametric Technology Corp. comes to mind when I think of this. They make a parametric 3-D modelling program that would absolutely sing in the Macintosh environment. Unforturnately, when I attempted to discuss this with a PTC sales rep, he scoffed at the idea. Sadly, this scenario is repeated far too often. An open-minded view of the Macintosh platform would show that it is indeed worthy of pursuing.
Stick to your guns and insist that the developers include the Mac. Giving people choices is what will ultimately be beneficial to all. One item I have heard several times is that Macintosh users are snobs and unreasonably expect higher quality in both hardware and software. That may well be one item that some of these developers fear. I have been forced to use software written exclusively for the Wintel platform and have found some of them to be ghastly. Poorly written, illogical menus, unintuitive processes that would not likely be found acceptable with those who use the Macintosh. At first, it may sound snobbish, but such high expectations force those who develop to improve their products or lose business. Higher expectations leads to better products and a better quality of life. Isn't this a good portion of what the capitalistic society supports?
Well, I better get off my soapbox now, as I'm sure you have many things to do. Just a long-winded "attaboy" and a request that you continue to push. Those of use in the Macintosh community (who know that computing can be much better than it is now) really appreciate your efforts.
Sincerely,
Stephen
Sr. Manufacturing Engineer
I notice "bob" didn't have the courage or the conviction to leave his real email address either. Big surprise from a peanut gallery critic with nothing intelligent to say.
Posted by: Daniel at December 13, 2003 11:31 AMThat's great, Mike. Bite the hand that feeds you. You think journalists conspire against PR pros? It works both ways, my friend. We need you to be objective, not overzealous and slanted towards one particular OS. I love Mac, too, Mike; just like I love Windows and Linux...all technology. FOCUS!!!
Posted by: Dino Baskovic at December 15, 2003 09:47 AM
I'm not sure what it is either, Mike. I can't say I've ever been so attached to a set of technologies as I have been with Macs over the last decade. Sure Apple has it's problems, yet I'm not even sure it's completely their doing. Fortunately I work in an industry (multimedia) that keeps me near the front of the technology curve. I think Apple has the best shot at making an eventual "digital utopia" where computers, music, film, etc., no long is tied to a computer but genuinely improves our lives in new and exciting ways.
Posted by: Howard Wright at December 11, 2003 09:29 AM