« Tech elite dump television, landline phones for Net and wireless | Main | More info on Wardrivers Wi-Fi hacking bust »

November 24, 2003

The Death of Apple?

Thanks to Mac-Mike regular ToeKnee for passing along this piece written by IT analyst Rob Enderle. After attending the Comdex tech exhibition in Las Vegas last week, he's sounding the death knell for Apple, along with Sun and Novell.
The reason? He claims the future of technology will be based on the x86 WinTel platform. Enderle says everyone he talked to at Comdex said predicting Apple's demise was "like predicting that the sun would rise in the morning -- in other words, that it was a given."
Then again, he actually liked Comdex show, which has shrunk from 200,000 attendees to barely 50,000. Most of the reviews I read said the show was disappointing or irrelevant or worse.
in Apple | TrackBack (0)

Comments

The death knoll's been ringing since 1984 when Apple released the first Macintosh.

Tell Rob the demise is about to be 20 years late and counting.

Posted by: cgriego at November 24, 2003 01:38 PM

Good thing that Enderle's opinion isn't worth the paper it's printed on. He's an unabashed Microsoft apologist in the same league as Paul Thurrott.

There's no point in doing a point/counterpoint, because he didn't even make any arguments, save for the tired ol' "open source is the future" one that Linux geeks have been spouting for years. While Linux has gained share (measured in tenths of a percentage point) in recent years, it's virtually invisible on the desktop marketplace, and will likely remain so as long as it remains difficult to install and use. The best hope for Unix (in any form) on the desktop is Mac OS X.

Last time I checked, Microsoft wasn't even close to being a fan of open source and Linux. Yet, somehow, they will "survive" (not defined in Enderle's argument) in the "future" (no timeframe given), while other non-open source companies will supposedly perish. I wonder how that's supposed to happen?

These guys are talking out of their ass. Period.

Posted by: KW at November 24, 2003 01:49 PM

That's why I love Rob Enderle, alway makes me laugh...

Official Apple Death Knell:
"Rob Enderle has done it yet again: Mr. Enderle will be the first pundit to make the Apple Death Knell Counter for the third time."

Posted by: Paso at November 24, 2003 02:10 PM

Having come from a Linux/Unix Background, I see People embracing Macs in the Unix Computer.

Apple make a very robust, reliable and cheap top-end-system, and *real* Linux geeks, the ones who don't care about the software, have the choice between the Sony Vaio or a Mac. (Mac's run Linux too, remember).

Of all the People I know who use Linux on Laptops, about 1⁄3 use an iBook or PowerBook.
If anything, the Growth of Linux is /Promoting/ Macintoshes.

Posted by: Daniel Woods at November 24, 2003 04:05 PM

I've been using Macs since my computer 101 class in 1985. People have been telling me that Apple is going out of business ever since.

Posted by: Harry Hoode at November 24, 2003 04:29 PM

mac will endure forever

Posted by: david at November 24, 2003 05:08 PM

Enderle is a poster child of what those in the movie review business refer to as "quote whores." He's so desperate for attention, he'll give out soundbites left and right for the media to gobble up. There is no reason why this guy should be quoted so often other than the willingness to sell himself (and thus promote his consulting business) - journalists have to get their quotes from someplace.

Unfortunately, Enderle doesn't seem to use any brains to power the analysis he profers. He claims Apple is doomed to die because only standards will survive. If he'd take his head out of the sad, he'd know that most of OS X is standards based, and in fact, Microsoft has profited immensely by undermining standards (everything from HTML to CSS to Java). So the argument that Apple will die because it's not a "standard" sinks like the 100 lb. anchor right there.

Secondly, Enderle embarrassed himself by recently writing about Apple's ultimate demise. It was quite amusing to see this "knowledgeable" analyst suggest "helpfully" to Apple that the next release of OS X whould be code-named "Cheetah."

I find it highly probably that Mr. Enderle probably still doesn't know that Cheetah was the code-name for 10.0. It's not as if the information was a big secret. Rather, it reveals how little he knows about Apple and how little he continues to educate himself on all things Apple. That's a mistake that only a true quote whore would make.

Posted by: paul at November 24, 2003 07:33 PM

Just for those who like this kind of story... Here's a site that watches all of them.

http://www.macobserver.com/appledeathknell/index.shtml

Posted by: supportTEX at November 24, 2003 08:17 PM

This kind of "sky is falling" reporting pops up so frequently that it always amazes me when people pay any attention to it anymore. As has been mentioned above, Apple has been on its death bed practically since its incorporation.

Posted by: Michael Hanscom at November 25, 2003 01:49 PM

I don't think so. Even despite some of Apple's questionable moves over the years - their primary competitor - Microsoft - will insure that Apple remains viable.

Microsoft knows the government hammer that will come down on them when and if Apple ever goes under. MS will find a way to prop up the company - even if it means greater strategic partnerships. However, Jobs has brought a fresh look and new life to the company... so I think this conversation is meaningless in the end anyway.

Posted by: jra at December 1, 2003 04:28 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits