« Why 64-bit processing will rock your world | Main | Microsoft testing newsbot »

November 18, 2003

Apple's announcements

I just finished a briefing on today's announcements with Apple's Tom Boger, Apple's Director of Desktop Art; Brian Schmidt, program manager for the Professional Applications Group; and Brian Meaney, a program designer for Final Cut Pro.
New today is a dual 1.8GHZ G5 machine, Pantherized and G5 optimized updates of Final Cut Pro and other Pro applications and a new $2,499 20-inch iMac. The updates are free downloads from the Apple Web site. The new G5 and iMac are available online and at Apple retail stores today.
The 20-inch iMac - the result of strong consumer demand for more screen real estate - should be a good seller for the upcoming holiday season. Apple made the dual-processor 1.8 G5 in response for similar demand from a lot of G3 and early G4 users, said Boger.
And, depending on the exact app, the upgraded Pro software can bring about as much as 55% speed improvements over dual processor G4's, said Schmidt and Meaney.
The more I look into the specs, though, the more I'm wondering if the G5 1.8GHz is the machine for me. While I like the 160GB hard drive, the Nvidia GeForce FX 5200 Ultra video card with 64MB DDR SDRAM is not my first choice. The better ATI Radeon 9600 is $50 more and the much better ATI Radeon 9800 Pro takes it to 128MB of video memory while adding $350 to the pricetag.
And many of the reports I've seen on the G5 say 512MB of RAM isn't enough for power users who do a lot of video editing and desktop publishing work. To take it to 1GB is another $250. To go to 2GB is $1050. Add all that together and the G5 is still a lot of money.
Then again, maybe I can get buy with everything as is with a RAM bump to 1GB. Decisions. Decisions.
in Hardware | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Buy the RAM from someone other than Apple and you'll save hundreds of dollars... Apple's RAM is way over priced. Check out http://www.dealram.com/ for some good prices.

Posted by: Derek at November 18, 2003 01:05 PM

Actually, ramseeker.com is the place to go. Apple salespeople recommend it (provided you are comfortable installing your own RAM) and, since it's a meta-site that provides prices from across the web, it's a real time- and money-saver.

Posted by: Seth Dimbert at November 18, 2003 01:23 PM

Mike:

Everyone's telling you the same thing, but it bears repeating: Don't buy RAM from Apple, and you'll save a fortune. Here's a price from crucial.com:

512MB DDR PC3200
$93.99 (USD)

That makes it much more palatable, no? At the very least, it should make your decision quite a bit easier on your pocketbook. Under the crucial.com scenario, your RAM speed bump will cost you under $300 versus the $1,050 you quote in your article.

I agree with previous posters that configuring your system online with Apple's RAM prices makes the machine seem much more expensive than it really is. When you consider that reliable companies such as crucial.com offer a warranty on their RAM, there's no need to pay Apple's ridiculous prices.

Posted by: Rich at November 18, 2003 03:09 PM

The dual 1.8 GHz G5 is a great move on Apple's part.

However, the 20" iMac - while spectacular - is a bit of a disappointment. For a $2199 machine, it should be loaded, but not only does it have a subpar graphics card (it should have at least a 64 MB Radeon 9600), it only ships with a measly 256 MB of RAM and DOESN'T include an 802.11g Airport Extreme card.

I mean, come on, do they really expect consumers to pay even more to add these things on to a $2200 consumer machine that isn't any faster than the much cheaper 17" model?

Here's what Apple should have done with the 20" iMac:

1.42 Ghz G4 (instead of 1.25 Ghz)
512 MB RAM (instead of 256 MB)
Airport Extreme included (instead of "ready")
64 MB Radeon 9600 (instead of the GeForce FX 5200 Ultra)

With this configuration, the 20" iMac would be sufficiently differentiated from the 17" iMac and furthermore, it would sell like hotcakes. I suspect there are very few people who are willing to pay a $400 premium just for a bigger screen.

The dual 1.8 Ghz G5 will no doubt sell like hotcakes, though.

Posted by: Paul at November 18, 2003 03:33 PM

Adding to what the others wrote-- a note-- no matter what RAM you buy, it seems that Macs have gotten more picky than they used to be. If you experience any freezes or wierd problems, pop out that extra RAM chip to see if the trouble clears up - I have had two clients in recent months have trouble with third-party supposedly-certified RAM.

I expect you're getting some sort of Apple certification by buying through them-- expensive, but perhaps less likely to cause any problems. If it's for a mission-critical time-is-money workstation, just get the Apple stuff and think of it as a fixed cost, not additional hardware.

T

Posted by: Toeknee at November 18, 2003 03:44 PM

Hi Mike,
Shouldn't a "Technology Columnist" have the fastest baddest Mac available?? It's only a few bucks more......

seeya
dxtr

"Never ask what sort of computer a guy drives. If he's a Mac user, he'll tell you. If not, why embarrass him?" - Tom Clancy

Posted by: dxtr at November 18, 2003 11:38 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits