« Wardrivers nailed by FBI for cracking into Wi-Fi network? | Main | Wi-fi Webcam busts family pooch on forbidden carpet »

November 11, 2003

Mac OS 9.0 users are still out there

I'm teaching at a seminar down in Florida and one of the participants was having some trouble getting a Palm to sync on his PowerBook. What amazed me was all he uses is the Mac 9.0 operating system. I know, there are still PC people who use Windows ME or WIndows 98, too. But with all the hype and hoopla over Jaguar and Panther and OS X, and all the apps that have been optimized for them, I'm surprised that someone hasn't updated yet. I suppose some run specialized programs that only work with 9. But just how big is the 9.0 user base? Maybe newer isn't always better for some.
in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I'm a mac-using student at the University of Michigan, and at my part time job I help many researchers and professors who are using Mac OS 9. It's archaic and frustrating, but there are still many research oriented programs out there that haven't made the transition to OS X. Despite the hype (and great software/hardware), the mac is still a small percentage of the market. Not to mention many people are still unwilling to make the leap to something new even if they only use their computers for web browsing and e-mail.

Posted by: Adam at November 11, 2003 11:38 AM

i think there are people that just don't care. they want the web and email... they couldn't care less weather it's os9 or X, windows 98 or xp. i live in a co-op with 7 other people... 6 of them don't care. as long as they can browse the web and get email and occasionally write a text document.

luddites.

they don't know what they are missing but they don't care either. now, what i don't understand are the folks that use the computer every day for more than the basics and who stick with os9. even folks who are using apps available on x still stick with 9. yuck. i suppose one factor is money. not just the cost of X, but upgrading apps to work with X. of course classic is much better these days... so i don't know.

Posted by: denny at November 11, 2003 11:46 AM

I have some clients still on OS 9, and I keep my old Beige G3 on OS 9.2.2 because Jaguar would not run on it. I have now updated it to a G4 chip, and I use it for auxillary processing of PDFs in Acrobat Distiller and other such processor intensive things. Plus, the ATI Xclaim TV I use will not run in OS X.

Finely tuned, OS 9 is very stable. My clients who do not want to switch are usually just scared to learn something new. Panther is now finally something I can strongly recommend to them, unless they depend on older software packages which for some reason will not run in Classic (few and far between, but out there).

Posted by: ToeKnee at November 11, 2003 12:32 PM

I'm an educational computing consultant, and assure you that in K-12 the penetration of OS X is nearly zero. Schools often use their computers for 5-10 years; there's little hope up running OS X on those LC III's.

Sadly, when forced to adopt OS X when they buy new computers, they usually choose Windows instead. After all, they WILL still have 9, and ALREADY have some Windows - so why learn and support a third OS?

Posted by: Scott Schuckert at November 11, 2003 12:35 PM

It costs a LOT to move to OS X. New versions of the OS, Appleworks, MS Office. And for best performace, more RAM, how about a bigger HD ? Sheesh! What's the rush?

Posted by: John C at November 11, 2003 01:07 PM

I know that the high school I just graduated from uses OS9 on every machine accept the Technology directors machine and the main yearbook machine. To update our older iBooks would take a heavy investment in ram and a new build of our custom ASR which takes a lot of time and testing. Until OS9 is completely disavowed by apple support its makes sense to use for now.

Posted by: Jordan Weiss at November 11, 2003 01:28 PM

I am a long-time Mac user (since 1984) and still use OS 9. Why? My PowerMac 8500 w/400mhz upgrade card runs 9 beautifully. The programs I use all work well. I see no need to spend time/money transferring to a new system. I read a lot about incompatibilities and other issues with OS X and don't need the hassles right now. Some day I'll switch (since Apple's trying to starve 9 to death), but I'm in no hurry.

Posted by: Brian at November 11, 2003 02:01 PM

Why is it so surprising that people still boot into OS 9 or earlier? One of the great things about Apple computers is the ability to still be using them for years after Apple support for them fades. They are quality computers and regularly garnish more than their pee-cee counterparts do on eBay. I agree that change is inevitable. But, does everyone have to be so darned happy-go-lucky about every new ort that Apple sends down the pike?

Posted by: fred freem at November 11, 2003 02:08 PM

Although I use (and love!) OS X at home, I'm stuck with OS9 at work for various reasons, but the most important is the cost of upgrading. Our systems (four of them) were purchased shortly before the introduction of OS X, and with the economy being what it is, we won't be able to upgrade any time soon.

For us, upgrading means replacing basically the entire Adobe publishing suite, Microsoft Office, and other miscellaneous applications (Toast, etc.), and the cost is just too high. When you figure in the cost of new or upgraded hardware, RAM, etc., it quickly becomes an issue of economics. The fact is, OS 9 works just fine (as do the applications we use), and there's no compelling need for us to upgrade. I can't make the business case that we need to buy new hardware and software based on the minor productivity gains offered by OS X.

Our company is struggling to remain competitive in a very difficult environment. Sorry to say, but OS X just isn't in the cards now, or the forseeable future.

Posted by: Rich at November 11, 2003 02:29 PM

I've been a Mac user since my Apple IIgs in the mid 80's. I've purchased several machines since then, for myself and my two daughters. The most recent is a dual 535 mh G4. We also have a Powerbook G3 Bronze keyboard (with a large new hard drive and lots of RAM), and a G3 AllinOne since updated to G4, with lots of RAM and a large external hard drive. I have added Firewire connectivety to both older machines, and USB to the AiO. As I understand it, only the dual 535 G4 will run any form of OS X.

Except for the iTunes Store, I can do everything I want to do (from email and Microsoft Office to Photoshop)on OS9.

I see no reason to junk two terrific older computers (both of which have been upgraded to the max), and spend a small fortune upgrading both operating system and applications software, just to keep Steve Jobs happy. Let him look to his airplane and his $$ for personal satisfaction.

Is OS 9 dead? Not as far as I'm concerned.

Posted by: bob at November 11, 2003 02:38 PM

one word: Quark

until just recentlty Quark was only available for OS 9, and since Quark is the staple/bane of the publishing business, the computer lab i used to run at school needed to run OS 9. Scream all you want about how Indesign is better, Quark is still the main app. Money is really the big issue with OS X. Do you fork it over or not.

Thankfully Quark for OS X came out, which means more Quark to deal with, but at least its OS X.

Posted by: Andrew Lubchansky at November 11, 2003 03:05 PM

Believe it or not, some people don't realize that both operating systems are on there mac. i met someone once who was using their mac with OS9. The reason they were uing it was because the computer started up in it and they didn't know OS X was on there! They thought they still had to buy it OSX. I showed them how you can switch between operating systems, and they were shocked to see it running OSX.
Remember, just because someone uses a mac it doesn't mean they are computer literate. Next time you see someone using OS9, ask them if they know OS X is installed.

Posted by: Eddy Lucas at November 11, 2003 03:32 PM

Bob,

Every computer you mentioned in your post (Except for the Apple IIgs :>) can run Mac OS X. But you are right in saying that it would cost a small fortune to upgrade the OS AND your applications to take advantage of all that horsepower.

In fact, it is the cost of buying native applications that is holding people back from making the transition. I tell my customers (who are primarily schools) that unless they have a compelling reason to move to OS X they should not. Especially if all they are going to do is run their applications in the Classic environment.

Unless they are willing to spend their money to upgrade their applications when they move to OS X then all they are going to end up with slower performance and greater administration difficulties.

Posted by: Todd at November 11, 2003 03:47 PM

I'm a film editor in LA using Final Cut Pro for DVD documentaries. We swing back and forth between X and 9 all the time. FCP on X is better optimized for rendering, and more efficiently uses dual processors. But, on slower machines, X just gumms up the works. Unless you have a dual, it doesn't always make sense on pre-2003 machines. Also, as much as I love X (I use it at home) and as much as FCP keeps progressing, IT IS NOT AS STABLE ON X AS IT IS ON 9. More often than I like, FCP on X would crash. Bing, bam and it's gone. No explanation, just poof. Granted, we've tracked down likely suspects, but the overall effect is still "FCP crashes on X". My autosave is now set to 8 minutes, so every 8 minutes, I must pause for 2 1/2 more (50MB project). It might not seem like much, but trust me, it can get annoying. Especially when you know that a crash could be around the corner.

On a side note, FCP on X handles audio scrubbing differently, no matter what the window size (which does affect the scrub) the audio is choppy. In 9 it is much more understandable. It may seem to be small, but when you're fast scanning a 80 min documentary, or going through 3 110 minute commentaries for content, you don't want to watch it all real time.

On the flip side, I'm trying to convince the COO (wife) to upgrade to Panther. Any ideas?

ps. for the gear heads:

Primary Machine
Dual 1GHZ, OS X 10.28
FCP 3.0.4
Project file 47.5 MB
Total Media 600GB (9 Silver Lacie FW)
Total Output
1 75min Feature doc
3 90 min commentaries
1 20 min doc
1 10 min deleted scenes doc.

Posted by: Daniel at November 11, 2003 04:12 PM

I think it comes down to what you do with the computer and when you might need a new one. Others here have mentioned price, which is a big deal for those that have to justify the cost. And those costs can be significant compared with the minimal amount of gain in many spots. Sure OSX has and is getting some great software, but until those programs are absolutely necessary, many will wait to upgrade.

Mac OSX up until recently has been alot about snazz, sizzle and the cool-factor. Not necessities in a production environment. That will slowly change. Now that many new programs like Office and creative software from Adobe and Macromedia require OSX, those users will upgrade when the time is right.

If you figure a Mac has a maximum life of 5-7 productive years (my estimate!), OS9 users still have about five to go before they need to buy a new machine and see what they've been missing.

My Macs: Powerbook G4 15" (w/ 10.3), PowerMac 9500 (9.1), Grape iMac G3 (10.3), Powerbook G4 12" (wife's, 10.3), and my trusty, dusty Mac Classic II and Centris 650 (System 6 and 8 respectively).

Posted by: Howard at November 11, 2003 07:18 PM

People staying with OS 9 are like people that stay with Windows, they think the new stuff is just a little bit better than the old but that they will run into similar problems. They just need to use it for a while to understand how much better it is now than it ever has been before.

Posted by: Carlos at November 11, 2003 08:17 PM

my fastest machine is my b&w 450. sure, it runs x, but the speed simply doesn't compare to 9. also, as has been previously noted, i'm not thrilled at throwing more cash bill gate's way to go to office x. i have put 10.2.8 on the machine, btw, just to start getting a feel for it. perhaps if santa leaves that dualie g5 under my tree this year...

Posted by: Mr. Bingley at November 12, 2003 08:28 AM

daniel...
you might consider the upgrade to fcp 4... in my opinion it's far more stable. using it with a 12"pb and 10.2 and now 10.3 i've had only 1-2 quits... granted, i'm not working on any projects the size of yours. the largest a 90 minute documentary with a full lacie 120 gb drive.

on my system i'd characterize it as rock solid. fcp 3 definitely was not. i had 1-2 quits at least every 4-5 days of working.

Posted by: denny at November 12, 2003 11:11 AM

Denny...
It's good to hear of it's stability. Your experience gives me something to look forward to. As someone who drives Avids as well, I've been reading up on the features and drooling over the editing enhancements. (Ahhh, a real audio mixer!, multi-channel out!) The editor's guild magazine just ran a review of FCP 4 being used on NBC's Scrubs for the third (current) season. This is a big deal for Apple and FCP4 - 22 episode, full production run. If that's not in the trenches, I don't know what is. Plus the powerbook editing makes me excited. How does it work screen-size wise for you on the 12? From my playing at the Apple store it looks like the only gain you get from a 15" is a longer timeline (horizontal), the video size (vertical) remains the same. the 12" is much more portable IMHO.

I'm going to install 4 on my mac at home, I just need to clean out the drives first. An added advantage/disadvantage to working on someone else's computer is that your home system becomes messier than a sock drawer - I may even zero and start over!

thx

Posted by: daniel at November 12, 2003 07:47 PM

While Mac OS X may be wonderful to some, it is not wonderful to all.

Don't assume that just because a person still uses OS 9 that they are illiterate or stubborn. Many people who convert to X that think it’s the greatest thing ever treat Mac OS 9 users like they are Bill Gates. They don't realize that they themselves were avid Mac OS 9 fans before OS X, if OS 9 is so terrible and unstable, why did they use it, or earlier versions, they make it sound like OS 9 is worse that Windows 3.1. And if a person says one negative thing about OS X, they are shunned. I know. It’s happened to me plenty of times. Now, don't get me wrong, I like Mac OS X, and all the main programs that I use are available for OS X, but I still use OS 9. Why? It's not because of cost to upgrade, I have it installed already, its not because my scanner doesn't work in X, (which it doesn't).

The main reason is this, now; before you all condemn me to a fiery grave, hear me out. The reason I will not switch is because Mac OS 9 works far better on my Mac than OS X. It is faster, and a lot more stable. With Mac OS 9 I go months without any major problems. So I occasionally rebuild my desktop, so what, that’s my choice, and I'd like to be able to do it in X. My applications rarely ever crash or cause problems in Mac OS 9, and yes, that even applies to the Microsoft apps. I can be more productive in Mac OS 9 because I take advantage of several of its features that Apple took out of X. (Why fix it if it isn't broken Apple?)

What am I referring to? Well, for one thing, the contextual menus support, which I believe OS X seriously lacks in. I routinely use labels, window shade, and the feature of dragging my windows to the bottom of the screen and turning them into pop up windows. Yes, I realize that those things have been replaced with supposedly superior products. Panther has labels, Unsanity has Window shade X, and I can minimize my open windows in the Dock and use Expose. But its still not the same, the Dock to me is a nuisance at best, looking at icons that grow smaller as more items are added, having to use a magnify technique just to see what those icons are is annoying and a waste of time. I like the Apple Menu in OS 9, and I like the Application menu as well. I know I can buy shareware that adds these features back in. But why should we pay for things that should have never been took out?

The Dock, and all of the new OS X features could still have been added, and used by all, and coexist with the features and menus of OS 9. Why fix what isn't broken, we shouldn't have to pay extra for the features that make using the Mac OS productive, and simple. With OS X, Apple seems to have taken away a lot of what made Apple special, the user friendliness.

Yes, I know that a lot of what I say is being fixed, and I believe that Apple will make OS X better, but that will take time, OS X is still not as mature as it needs to be, it took over 18 years to get as good as OS 9 was, and is, Apple can't expect OS X to be mature in only 3 major versions. Apple has done a wonderful job with OS X on a lot of fronts, and by the time were using 10.5, it will probably be so wonderful that what Panther is today will seem like DOS is now. Like I said, I like OS X even now.

Now, I’m not just X bashing, my problems aren't all with the lack of built in features. As I said, OS 9 runs better on my machine that OS X does. OS X is terribly slow, taking 40 to 60 seconds to open simple apps, 5 to 10 seconds to close a window, and even longer to install an update to software. It takes 5 to 10 minutes for me to able to actively use my desktop in Mac OS X after booting into X or logging into my account. X is very unstable for me, sure, when apps crash, they don't take the rest of the system with them for some, but with me, the usually do. It’s a variety of applications, from Apple products to shareware, to even Macromedia.

Surprisingly, I've never had trouble with any Microsoft products in Mac OS X. But TextEdit, Preview, and iTunes have given me a lot of troubles. I boot into X maybe for two days every two months or so usually to just update my system, play around, or review OS X only software for macCompanion magazine, and in that time, I usually have the entire system freeze on me, causing me to have to restart. When I am able to work, common tasks are so slow that I lose my train of thought waiting for them to happen. I've had to reinstall Mac OS X from version 10.0 to now over 50 times easily, and that’s made me wary of even installing an application for fear that something might screw up.

Unstable, very slow, and extremely quirky are some of my main reasons for not switching to Mac OS X from OS 9.

Another is that X is a resource hog, which probably accounts for the slowdown.

Now, I've tried every utility software that I can, I've had people come over and try to alleviate these problems all to know avail.

Here's what I have:

Power Macintosh G3 300mhz B&W Rev. A
448 MB of RAM

Yet X runs a great deal better on some slower iMacs with less RAM that I know than it does on my Mac.

Like I said, I do Like Mac OS X, and all the main apps I use are available for X, but X runs terrible on my machine, making it a nuisance and a problem.

You could say that my problem is Hardware, but before you start saying, "just buy a newer Mac", realize that even though I know that a Mac is cheap in the long run, for the short term, I'm not rich, and can't afford a new Mac.

So the basics are this, you are surprised that people still use OS 9 because your experience with X has bee so positive, but not everyone has the same experience as you, for me, OS 9 works better on my Mac that OS X, but I'm not alone. X works better for you perhaps, there’s nothing wrong with that, I’m not surprised people use OS X, I have no problem with them, nor do I find their intelligence lacking, yet many assume OS 9 users are idiots when they don't know the circumstance. If I could use OS X efficiently, I would, but I can't.

I am not new to the OS X interface, so that’s not a problem.

Another thing is that while I would switch to X if I could, I'm not hurting one bit by staying with OS 9, everything I need to do can still be done beautifully in OS 9, Graphics, web design, and anything else I wish. Bottom line is that OS 9 works for me, so I'm in no hurry to switch. If it didn’t, well, I'd still be stuck with it because the way that OS X does work on my machine is so bad that I can't use it constantly.

I am more productive in OS 9 than I am in OS X on my Mac. OS X runs so badly on my Mac that I'm more productive using Windows 98 and XP than X.

Don't be surprised that people still use OS 9, there reasons are just as valid as yours is to not use OS 9.

Have fun!

Posted by: Derek at November 12, 2003 08:52 PM

I read somewhere [credible source] that only 20% of the Mac base runs some version of OS X.

Posted by: Mark at November 12, 2003 10:19 PM

The smart money is on OS 9, it is fast, stable and I dont have to pay apple a hundred and thity bucks for the privilage of being a beta tester. Apple knows damn well that a vast majority of their user base is not jumping.

I cringe when I read about the problems people have every time they get an upgrade for OS 10. A major reason I use a Mac is to avoid that kind of hassle. I am a busy guy and don't want to play with my computer all day just to get it to work right.

Secondly, OS 10 needs a very powerful computer and ons of ram to get a snappy finder response and this does not come cheap. Another major cost is new software and all the shareware applications needed to customize the operating system and make it user friendly.

Mr Jobs should look at ways to get people on board in a way that makes sense but instead they continue to nickel and dime their very loyal customer base. I guess rewarding long term users is out of the question as is making an affordable MP3 player. Apple is all about their margins not about market share and that will bite them in the ass sooner or later.

Posted by: Gman at November 13, 2003 06:20 PM

Gman-
I would hardly say the smart money is on OS 9. It is a platform for which there is no major hardware or software development-- the latest Macs will not run it, and the OS will not be updated for newer technologies such as USB 2.0. I ran OS X on a G3 400Mhz Powerbook just fine (hardly a powerful computer by today's standards), and I've heard tell of it running OK on original iMacs.

I understand your basic point of view, but the strength of your opinion is way off base. OS X is not a beta version, and it's not prone to problems. In contrast, a Mac user since 1988, I have never had so little trouble. I do Mac support, and those of my clients who have moved to OS X have far fewer problems than those still trying to use OS 9.

Face facts, OS 9 was as far as Apple could take that platform. And OS X works just fine in Classic mode for older software, but new and powerful software is being developed and ported from Unix and Linux all the time.

OS X was a smart move for Apple, I have come to believe. The recent worldwide press it is getting for the Virgina Tech supercomputer would not have happened running G4s and OS 9. IT managers who had forbidden Macs from their networks are now looking to Macs with interest due to its Unix underpinnings.

The major point is, you don't have to be an early adopter, (that would have been two years ago);you can be very slow to adopt-- you can keep using OS 9 for a while yet, but the writing is on the wall, so keeping yourself in that thought mode is not productive for you.

Mr. Jobs is smart to be concerned with both margins and market share- both are necessary for long-term viability.

T

Posted by: ToeKnee at November 13, 2003 09:39 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits