« Michigan's U.P. gets the Net in a big way | Main | Abandoned Web sites litter cyberspace »

November 04, 2003

Don't want a virus? Get a Mac

That's what I flat-out said at a press conference last night before I did an evening talk to the Bay Area Economic Club in Escanaba, in Michigan's snowy Upper Peninsula. The reporters all took notes when I answered a question about how to avoid the plague of virus and worm attacks of the past few months. I looked at the coverage in the local newspaper this morning but they didn't mention a word of my pro-Mac rant. After my talk that night before the Econ Club, several people in the audience approached to ask me about my little 12-inch G4 PowerBook, which I used to run my presentation. I repeated my pro-Mac comments and saw a lot of nodding heads.
in Mac culture | TrackBack (0)

Comments

is it good or bad to be an "Internet crackerjack touts future impact of World Wide Web"

I always thought it was bad to be a crackerjack...

Posted by: Eric at November 4, 2003 01:31 PM

No play for the pro-Mac comments huh? Sounds like professional incompetence to me.

Posted by: afpilot at November 4, 2003 02:39 PM

What proof is there that Macs are immune to viruses? If your reasoning is that you never hear of security problems with Macs, consider this. If you were a virus writer, what system would you target...a PC with 95% of the market share or a Mac with 5%? As more people start to use Macs I'm sure you'll see more news of security issues with them as well. No system is immune to viruses, security hacks, etc...

Posted by: Tom at November 4, 2003 08:24 PM

Tom, if you were also a virus writer, you would also target a system that ships with all its ports left open (Windows), that allows any process to overwrite core system files (Windows), that executes code automatically in email (Windows/Outlook), that gives Administrator access to programs that shouldn't have Administrator acess (Windows).

The combination of 95% marketshare and the incredibly insecure design makes for a "perfect storm" for crackers.

With Mac OS X, crackers would have to expend 10 times the energy and still get virtually nil results. Windows is insecure BY DESIGN and its domination in the marketplace is just frosting on the cake to crackers.

Posted by: Paul at November 5, 2003 01:11 AM

BTW, the bottom line is Mac OS X is "secure" as you can get in the real world, as there hasn't been a single virus or worm that's been able to exploit the occasional security holes that get discovered in more than 2 years.

No Mac OS X viruses vs. 70,000+ known Windows viruses. That doesn't mean it isn't impossible, but it CERTAINLY means that at the present moment, OS X is infinitely more secure than Windows.

Posted by: Paul at November 5, 2003 01:15 AM

Walt Mossberg (Wall Street Journal) said it first, and said it best:

http://ptech.wsj.com/archive/ptech-20031023.html

Posted by: Josh at November 5, 2003 01:24 AM

I agree with you for the most part, but my main point is better said in the article provided by you in your link...

"In addition, Macs constitute such a tiny share of the world's computers that they just aren't an attractive target for virus writers and hackers. You can't take down many computers, so you won't get much publicity."

Posted by: Tom at November 5, 2003 11:32 AM

Tom,

If a 'successful' virus can infect 10-20 million WinPCs, would an equally virulent 'Mac virus' infect only 5% of Macs or 10-20 million of them?

And, what kind of a 'rep' would a hacker garner for being 'the one' that took down all those stupid Macs back in 2003/4?

Posted by: MacBuddy at November 5, 2003 05:12 PM

Tom makes the usual mistake of conflating market share with vulnerability. Following this absurd logic, the Apache web server, which is used on over 50% of the public web servers on the Internet, should be swamped with attacks. Yet most of the successful attacks are directed against Microsoft's IIS, which has about half the market share enjoyed by Apache. Conclusion? Apache is harder to crack, but IIS is not, so most of the attacks are directed against IIS. Tom, I think your ignorance -- or your bias -- is showing.

Posted by: Bias Alert at November 5, 2003 06:32 PM

What's the deal with Tom? Seems like he's wound a little too tight.

Posted by: Hatchet Jack at November 5, 2003 07:02 PM

While I agree with Bias Alert, according to news.netcraft.com Apache is used on nearly 70% of web servers. Microsoft's IIS is used on approximately 21% on the latest graph. The trend shows steady increases for Apache and decreases for Apache.

With only 1/3 the marketshare of Apache, IIS still gets most of the viruses.

So much for Tom's virus theory.

Posted by: Voice of Reason at November 6, 2003 02:16 AM

Mike is right. If Macs are vulnerable to viruses but people don't write them because the Mac has miniscule marketshare, who cares? The result is still that you have better odds of safety--for the time being--using a Mac than using a PC.

Posted by: Ron Bell at November 6, 2003 12:25 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits