
My vote is no. I bought two macs the past two years, and I love them to death. But I cannot justify a new computer for a simple speed increase. Panther is supposedly much faster in anyways. And unless you are a heavy duty video and photo editor, your current mac should last you some time. I say hold off for another year, and then maybe when prices go down for maybe a 2.0 ghz single G5, plunk down the change. Besides, mac diehards (I consider myself a mac fan and owner not quite diehard but close) were up in arms just year ago in fact, saying speed is not what it's all cracked up to be.
Posted by: David Kim at October 23, 2003 12:59 PMJust something to weigh in:
Don't forget. You LOSE Virtual PC if you get a G5.
Posted by: bob at October 23, 2003 01:32 PMI've looked at TONS of benchmarks compairing everything from the 1Ghz iMac thru the Dual 2Ghz G5.
When I came across the opportunity to get a Dual 1.25Ghz G4 for a mere $1350, I jumped all over it.
For most tasks, the speed advantage of the single cpu G5's just doesn't justify the expense.
I'll post the benchmark links if I can find them again...
Posted by: Mike at October 23, 2003 01:39 PMMight want to change GB to GHz in the title.
Posted by: Anonymous at October 23, 2003 03:18 PMOdd I have both a dual 1Hz G4 server and a 1.6 GHz G5. While the dual G4 is better at certain tasks, the G5 absolutely blows it away when doing the more complex stuff. For instance when running 2 copies of SETI@Home, the G4 slows down to the original 10.0 OS X speed, but the G5 never breaks a sweat. Over the past 18 years I've built, sold, setup and repaired just about every computer there ever was: from Altairs to dual Opterons and XEONs. The G5 is by far the best I've ever used or abused. It is a monster! Just make sure you budget 2 GBytes of RAM into the price as well.
Posted by: Don at October 23, 2003 03:46 PMBefore rendering an opinion it would help to know what you would be using it for!
Posted by: Steve Dieringer at October 23, 2003 04:08 PMDepends on what you do... if you are a web guy, your money would probably be better spent getting a bigger screen and a faster video card.
If you do intensive number crunching, 3D, or video the 1.8 G5 is the only way to go.
My own experience going from a 400mhz G4 to a 1.8 has been that I am not blown away by the speed doing normal things. I AM blown away by the speed when taxing the system (doing multiple serious things simultaneously).
Posted by: timbo at October 23, 2003 04:09 PMaccording to the www.barefeats.com and xlr8yourmac.com, when both are equiped with the same ati 9800 and same amount of ram the dual 1.25g4 is faster at most things then the single g5, esp when using mp aware apps and multitasking like quake 3 etc. even games are as fast or faster, if you must get a g5 only the dual has a decisive advantage over the dual g4, one reason other than two processers and large l3 cache, is altivec is better on the g4 chip and most programs trult take advantage of it.
at least until g5 optimized apps come out like logic, cinema 4d, photoshop. etc.
Hold off until after MacWorld in January. If G5 processor upgrades are going to be sooner rather than later, this would be when they hit. I'm planning on getting a G5 and am waiting for this very reason. By then most bugs/issues with the G5 should be resolved and faster models should be in the pipeline.
Posted by: David Gregory at October 23, 2003 05:03 PMYou can ignore most of the the sites showing any G4 anywhere near as fast as the G5 1.8. There is very little software that has been optimized for the G5. When developers optimize applications for the G5 no G4 DP will be anywhere near as fast.
Go to
http://www.nemetschek.net/news/pressreleases/101503.html
which shows tests runninng VectorWorks that the G5 1.8G 512M RAM was faster than a G4 1.25G DP 512M RAM by much more than processor speed would indicate. The G5 redraws twice as fast, renders 3x faster, and performs Solids Modeling Operations nearly five times faster.
I'd wait for Rev B of the G5s.
Posted by: Baw at October 23, 2003 05:59 PMman! You guys are good. Awesome feedback. keep it coming.
Posted by: Mike Wendland at October 23, 2003 06:04 PMwho cares ?
Posted by: mike at October 23, 2003 06:23 PMI just sold my dual g4 1 ghz and got a G5. I do photoshop, photo imaging, large file copies, backup, multiple complex tasks at the same time, and the g5 is definitely worth. I know the dual g5 would be even better, but for the money, the 1.8 is fine.
I have 3.5 gigs of memory and 1200 gigabytes online, and an ati radeon 9600.
I also have USB 2.0 drives and firewire 400 drives, and the sata drives are 3 time faster, not even using a raid.
So I recommend the 1.8 g5.
Posted by: WJMilles at October 23, 2003 06:51 PMRead this article (and more if you can find 'em)
http://www.macspeedzone.com/html/hardware/machine/comparison/all/index.html
As usual..it all depends
Posted by: Lynn at October 23, 2003 08:09 PMAt this stage in the game it would be wiser to wait until January 2004.
I'm betting on the middle of the line G5 going dual without a hike in price.
MWSF is just around the corner and a Rev B G5 is going to be that much less problematic than a Rev A (although so far nothing terrible has hit the Rev A from a design point of view)
And of course more apps will be ready to fly on the G5 come the next revision.
Posted by: AvonB7 at October 23, 2003 08:38 PMHere's my opinion. Save up for the dual G5. If you've saved up enough for the 1.8, wait a little longer and save up for the dual G5. You won't regret it.
Posted by: BDK at October 24, 2003 01:01 AM200% decrease (Jeremy Frith), wow!
So a render that takes 10 seconds on a dual 1GHz G4 is decreased by 20 seconds (200% of 10 seconds) on a G5 1.8GHz. It's actually done 10 seconds before it starts!
I agree with Dan Toker. Not much software is optimized yet for the G5. When it starts to happen, then the jump will be worth it, but for now, I'd hold off. By the time the software starts coming out, you'll be able to get a better machine for the same $. Look at your 12". they just announced an iBook with essentially the same specs, for $1100. (I iknow it's not exactly the same, but pretty darn close) If you can wait 6 months, you'll be able to get a better machine for the $.
Posted by: Mark at October 24, 2003 07:38 AMthere's still another point:
G5 is 64 bit, it will last longer as the focus will shift onto 64 bit software after some years.
Posted by: Steven Brangers at October 24, 2003 02:35 PMSteven makes an excellent point. In 3 years, 4 GB of RAM will be fairly ordinary, but the G4s will have hit the memory wall.
The G5s, however, will still have lots of breathing room and we all know having more RAM effects speed far more than processor speed. The single G5s will fly with lots of RAM and using very bandwidth intensive apps.
Just think of what iMovie and Final Cut Pro will be doing just 2 years from now.
Posted by: Paul at October 24, 2003 06:23 PMI am trying to decide between G5DP1.8 and G5DP2,0 I t loks to me like the 1.8 Dp is the best buy . Are there any test out yet?
FC
Definitely make the switch. I did some render tests in FCP and experienced anywhere from a 50% to 200% decrease in render times on a 1.8 compared to a dual 1 GHz. The huge increase in frontside bus speed as well as the faster ram and faster hard drive makes for a huge improvement over the dual G4. The faster FSB and RAM more than compensates for lack of a second processor. Go for it, Mike!
Posted by: Jeremy Firth at October 23, 2003 12:15 PM