« Voice recording on an iPod | Main | Put parent's voice on smoke detectors to wake kids »

October 17, 2003

Unhappy iTunes Windows user

All is not happy with iTunes Windows users. Consider this e-mail from a guy named Jim:
I thought I would give it a try.  I created an account and downloaded one song and it worked great using Apples' '"Media Player", but here are my problems. 1) I cannot convert the song to MP3, therefore I an unable to use it on my portable MP3 player (by Rio).  I guess I need to purchase an Apple iPod now $$$. 2) I tried "burning" the song to an audio CD.  The only options it gave me were to "burn" it as a MP3 or a Data CD.  I tried the MP3 option and it said it could not because it was a "Protected Song".  I tried the Data CD option and it worked, but it saved it as a M4P file (an Apple proprietary file type), therefore I can only play it on my computer (using the iTunes Player).  I guess this option is only used for "backup" purposes. 3) So I went to iTunes Technical Support site.  I found an article, which was updated on 10/15/2003, called "iTunes: How to Burn Your Own Audio CDs."  It is directed towards MACs and states that you should go to "Edit --> Preferences --> CD Burning  and check Audio CD.  Well, as a Windows user, I don't have that option.  All I have is an option for MP3 (which does not work; "Protected Song") and a Data option (used for backups). I am very disappointed that Apple did not give the same options to Windows users as they did to the MAC users. I searched the iTunes Players "Help" options and Apple's web site for a fix to no avail.  Please let me know if I am missing something here.  I had thought I would be able to play these downloaded songs on my stereo and in my car, but at this point all I can do is play it on my laptop.  Maybe Apple is still upgrading their Windows based iTunes player.
Hmmmm. How can we help this guy?
in iPod/iTunes | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I just checked the preferences in my copy of itunes for windows and it does show audio cd as a burning option, and even has a field for selecting the gap between songs and enabling sound check ( to level the volume between the tracks). I haven't yet bought any songs to try burning but I don't seem to have the same problem the letter writer has.

Posted by: Sam Abuelsamid at October 17, 2003 12:49 PM

The Preferences option in the Windows version is under the "Edit" menu, as is the case with many Windows applications. I have not, unfortunately, tried burning from Windows, as my fiancee's computer does not have a burner (I have a Powerbook). Could it be that Jim is trying to burn the song using an outside program? Although I like Toast, when burning songs, I like the way iTunes seamlessly handles the converting and burning process. "It just works." Perhaps Jim is not aware of the Burn Disc icon in the top right corner of the iTunes window? From there it is easy to burn an audio CD (it should be the same as it is on the Mac), and then rip the track back to his computer in any format he chooses.

Posted by: Matt at October 17, 2003 01:39 PM

The other respondants have addressed his second complaint, so I'll address the first one:

"1) I cannot convert the song to MP3, therefore I an unable to use it on my portable MP3 player (by Rio). I guess I need to purchase an Apple iPod now $$$. "

Well, first off, all he has to do is burn a CD (see answers to #2 above) to convert it to AIFF format, then re-rip it back into MP3 format. This isn't officially sanctioned by Apple, but it's easy enough to do.

Having said that, iPod owners face the exact same dilemma (in reverse) with the MusicMatch store, the upcoming Napster store, etc., which use WMA format--which is unplayable on an iPod.

The big difference is that WMA is a closed, proprietary format, while AAC is an open standard--other portable music player companies (and other downloadable music stores) *could* use AAC (which is, after all, the next generation of MP3), they just don't.

Posted by: Charles Gaba at October 17, 2003 01:56 PM

MP3-CD, Audio CD, and Data CD options are all there on Windows.

Breaking off on a tangent, I am sad I can't burn it to an MP3-CD (though I do understand why, unfortunately) because instead of an iPod I have an MP3-CD player in my vehicle. Now I either have to deal with a ton of Audio CDs (if so, then why'd I get one with MP3-Cd playing in the first place?) or deal with doing conversion (maybe even burn/rip) to get it to a format I can put on MP3-CD, thus losing the great quality that I purchased.

*sigh*

Posted by: cgriego at October 17, 2003 02:21 PM

cgriego,

I'm not sure what you mean by you can't burn on MP3 CD. I believe iTunes can burn both standard audio CDs as well as MP3 CDs. The protected AACs you download will automatically be converted to unprotected MP3s if you choose to burn an MP3 CDs.

I'm not sure why the original writer is saying he can't burn MP3s of AACs bought from Apple's music store.

Under Edit --> Preferences --> Burning

there is an option for "MP3 CD" as well as "Audio CD"

As far as I know, protected AACs should be converted to unprotected MP3s easily and transparently, same as on the Mac.

Posted by: Paul at October 17, 2003 03:01 PM

Actually I don't think itunes will convert and burn aac files to mp3 cds. I believe you can only go from aac to audio cd or data cd. MP3 files that are imported into itunes or ripped using itunes can be burned to mp3 cd. I may be wrong about this and if so just forget what I said.

Posted by: Sam Abuelsamid at October 17, 2003 03:18 PM

It would be nice if someone could test this out and come back with a definitive answer.

One issue that I think will present Apple with a problem is non-iPod support for digital music players. I have a Mac and a 20 GB iPod so this is not a personal concern, but now that Windows users have iTunes, what will Apple do about supporting 3rd party players?

My guess is that iTunes will continue to support only the iPod, particularly since all the other music players seem to have no inclination to support AAC (or if it's even possible to support Apple's protected AAC) and in any case, seem bedded with Microsoft's WMA format.

iTunes for Windows is as much about AAC vs. WMA as it is about Apple making more money.

Posted by: Paul at October 17, 2003 05:16 PM

I have to extend Paul's previous comment: of course it's about Apple making more money. Is that such a bad thing? iTunes for Windows exists to equalize the iPod experience for Windows users, not provide a convenient music source for people who want to buy a competitor's product. iPod is the 800 pound gorilla of the portable music player market, and yet the Windows-based music services so far appear to be in total denial of that simple fact -- why else do they only support formats that can't be used on the most popular portable player? Why then, shouldn't Apple use that same hook to increase the appeal of their own players?

Also, AAC is an open implementation of the MPEG-4 protocol, and COULD be supported by other portable music players. No reason at all why Rio or Dell couldn't build that into their players and give customers a choice of using them with ITMS. If there's a compatibility issue here, it's not just one way.

Naked MP3 is simply never going to be an accepted format for online music sales. Some form of digital rights management is going to be built into whatever one is used. There's no way Apple is going to support one from Microsoft (like WMV).

But like Paul, I have a Mac and iPod, so I'm set.

Posted by: Doug Cobb at October 17, 2003 06:32 PM

--Paul--
I'm not sure what you mean by you can't burn on MP3 CD. I believe iTunes can burn both standard audio CDs as well as MP3 CDs. The protected AACs you download will automatically be converted to unprotected MP3s if you choose to burn an MP3 CDs.

[...]

As far as I know, protected AACs should be converted to unprotected MP3s easily and transparently, same as on the Mac.

Posted by: cgriego at October 17, 2003 07:15 PM

Am I missing something here?

iTunes will import in either MP3 or AAC format - simply go to preferences->importing->import using and change to MP3. Henceforth all files imported into iTunes will be MP3.

No big deal.

Posted by: Chris Randall at October 18, 2003 06:34 PM

Simple (and elegant) solution: Buy a Mac. :-)

Posted by: afpilot at October 18, 2003 08:50 PM

Purchased music will not burn as MP3. Purchased Music will not import as MP3. You can however burn purchased music as an audio cd. Then if you want you can import back to iTunes as MP3, although then you will have an ACC and MP3 version of the same song. or you could use another mp3 "ripper" and convert the Audio CD (AIFF) files to MP3, still having multiple copies. THis is anoying since I bought a car Mp3 player and have to jump through these hoops to burn an MP3 disc from music I purchase from ITMS. And then I guess there is a loss of quality in all the conversions, I havent noticed the loss in the car though. Oh well, DRM is going to be a fact of life but I have got to think there is a more elegant method short of buying a ACC cd player, I don't believe they are made now, or using an iPod in the car and all the adapting, FM modulators, cables etc.

On a side note it is amazing how people can give different views on how iTunes works with purchased files.

Posted by: Richard Brennan at October 18, 2003 10:53 PM

Protected AAC files cannot be burned to MP3 CDs because the burning process would remove the DRM. They can be burned to data CDs or audio CDs. This limit is the same with iTunes for Mac and Windows. Anyone know if there are any car CD players available that will play data CDs?

Posted by: Dave Clark at October 18, 2003 11:11 PM

If your car stereo has any auxilliary inputs, (many newer ones, especially mp3 cd players do) all you need is simple patch cord from the headphone jack to the rca phono plugs (about $3-4) No other adaptors or modulators needed. I have this in my car and it works great without the loss of sound quality that you get from the tape and fm adaptors.

Posted by: Sam Abuelsamid at October 19, 2003 08:11 AM

Say you put the ITMS .m4p file on a data disc- it's still DRM protected content. How is the car data disc player going to prove it's authorized to play that content? If there isn't some process like that going on, there's no DRM....

Some head units that have CD changer control ability can use an adapter that will provide 2 RCA jacks out of the changer input. Another cable can convert from RCA to headphone jack, where the iPod/player of choice can be directly plugged in. This is how I interface my iPod with my car. It's the slickest way there is.

Posted by: Steve Yuroff at October 19, 2003 09:32 AM

Thanks for the help. I re-installed the iTunes Player and now have the option to burn an audio cd. After burning the audio cd, I used my Rio Player to copy the CD back into my computer as a MP3. So now I can use it with my MP3 player (and yes, the iPod is the Mercedes of players but there is also $$$$).

Thanks again.

Posted by: Jim at October 19, 2003 11:01 AM

I bought a song today and tried burning. Itunes gave me a warning and would not allow me to burn a protected aac track to an mp3 disc. A standard aac track works fine. once it is on an audio disc you can use itunes to import it back as an mp3 track. If you don't want to use or save the audio cd's you can do this step with cd-rw discs and reuse them.

Posted by: Sam Abuelsamid at October 19, 2003 08:27 PM

Wouldn't it be pretty easy - for Win or Mac - to write something that makes a virtual audio disk on your hard drive, then burns it back to mp3?

Has someone done it yet?

Posted by: matt at October 21, 2003 04:42 PM

I was getting worried after reading the original article. After reading the comments, it sounds like I can use I-tunes after all.

Would be nice to have someone post a more definitive answer, though.

Posted by: Book Review at October 24, 2003 11:55 AM

Today I bought an iRiver player, rushed home and started downloading music from iTunes, only to find as described I cannot convert the ACC downloads to MP3 (to then put them in my new player), and when I tell it to burn the playlist to a CD, I have also been unable to do so. Very disappointed with iTunes.

Posted by: walterhutchens at October 25, 2003 12:22 AM

This goes back a number of posts, but I work at Radioshack, and about a year ago we carried an panasonic mp3 player that also had support of aac. Now, I don't know if this would play the apple version of aac or not. Hard sell especially back a year ago, most didn't know what the hell aac was, and far fewer wanted to pay $300 (canadian) for a 64 meg player that was upgradable via SD cards. lol

Posted by: \-\ardcore Canadian at November 4, 2003 12:18 AM

Mac users have a not-quite-iTunes option that makes it relatively easy to convert protected AAC's to AIFF files on your hard drive: iMovie.

You can go into iMovie and set your protected AAC file as the soundtrack to a blank movie. Then go to "Export..." and save the sound track of the movie as AIFF. (iTunes can convert AIFF back to AAC with no significant loss IF you use a 128k bitrate). The whole process takes under a minute.

I'm not sure if this is possible with windows also, but I suspect there's a way we're just overlooking. With version 6.2 (old version) of QT player, you could save as a self-contained movie, but Apple disabled that in the latest QuickTime. So Relax, folks -- there will always be ways to circumvent the copy protection ;-)

Posted by: $omebody $ad at November 8, 2003 01:21 AM

I purchased a song from itunes on a windows2000 pc at work. when i got home to my winME pc, i couldn't play the cd. i could only use it on a regular cd player UNTIL...

...i opened nero burning rom. nero was able to read the cd. IT EVEN PLAYED IT. yeah, i was excited :) i burned a copy of the cd and was able to play the copy on any of my pc's even though none of them have itunes. i could have also made a mp3, wav, or whatever cd before burning but i just chose to make an audio cd for now just see if it would work.

one thing i noticed is that my creative cd player could play the original cd that i burned from the itunes machine but my plextor could not. the plextor did play the copied cd though. go figure.

Posted by: MJ at November 20, 2003 06:46 AM

I have a piece of software called TotalRecorder (shareware for $20-or-so) that can record to WAV, MP3 or WMA (I think) the output from your audio card driver. I have used it to record RealMedia streams of a particular BBC radio show called Worldwide and give the resulting MP3's to my friend on a CD, to import into iTunes and then play on his iPod. The software can just as easily be used to record the output of the audio card driver when iTunes is playing the music. This doesn't involve analog cables (RCA or phono jack), which would result in degradation, but it does of course involve transcoding, which would be true when you burn an audio cd and then rip to MP3. Thus, this method is no worse than the burn-audio-CD-then-rip-to-MP3 method. It takes less time, because you are only playing the relevant album once so that TotalRecorder can encode. You can get the software at www.highcriteria.com.

On a related, more theoretical note, is this discussion a violation of the DMCA? I'm simply curious about this. Aren't we discussing methods to circumvent copy protection? Wasn't a Princeton professor threatened with a lawsuit for doing something just like this, even though his publication had academic merit, rather than being for personal financial gain?

Posted by: Kumar Mangalick at November 20, 2003 07:52 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits