« Mobile phone number switch to have some hitches | Main | Reason 3,256 why it's time to dump Microsoft »

September 28, 2003

Games? What games?

I own not a single game except one of the Tony Hawk skateboarder games that someone sent me for the Mac. Since I'm not a skateboarder, it just hasn't excited me much, though my grandson, Zachary, age 9, liked it well enough the first couple of times he played it. Then even he grew tired. But the larger issue for me is gaming. I have never really played one and have no desire to do so. But yet even my newspaper has recognized how huge gaming is by adding a whole Sunday page devoted to the latest and greatest. Am I missing something here? I ask you, Macheads, because, to tell the truth, I have more productive ways to spend my computer time than gaming? But I value your opinion. Do I need to also be a gamer to be a relevant tech columnist? Man, I sure hope not. Because it holds absolutely zero interest for me. But there's no mistaking it: This gaming thing is more then a trend. It unsettles, me though. I see a lot of violence, sexism and really unhealthy subjects in the vast majority of these games that makes me wonder whether this is should be treated as worthwhile review material in general interest publications. As always, I humbly seek your collective wisdom.
in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

It may seem like there are more games that have violence and sexuality but I think it is because of the media's love for hype, and those kind of games DO create a lot of hype for different reasons.

I have found some that aren't violent and actually are very nice to play. I'm not that hard core when it comes to games although I do love the graphics in some of them. I just like to have fun every now and then.

Personally, if I could, I'd get a gaming console as those are better suited for games most of the times and there are some titles out there that are actually fun to play. I'd love to be able to play Mario 64! :D

Posted by: Kim at September 28, 2003 06:50 PM

I don't think you need to worry about it, but the Mac side in general has to. Many people _only_ by computeres to play games on them. So I assume some are being forced to buy PCs instead of Macs... I was never much into gaming myself, well maybe but the sacrifice was small compared to all the problems you avoid by having a Mac instead of a PC :-) Let the true gamers worry about commenting on the games side of things.

Posted by: Jess Have at September 28, 2003 06:54 PM

I'm only a part time gamer. Even so, it seems I have to have the latest and greatest games anyway. If I don't buy them, I will usually at least d/l the demo and play a few times. Games can be a powerful draw on the computer. Colorful, musical, beautiful. Games are a diversion when I want some mindless fun - a way to get some quality non-productive time on my Mac! A good game pulls you in. Hours later you look at the clock and wonder where the time went (and why you didn't quit long before!).

Millions of people, adults as well as kids, play games on their computers. Games are not about productivity, Mike. For me games are just another way to have fun as a Mac user and part of the entire Mac experience.

Posted by: Larry Elseman at September 28, 2003 09:28 PM

Hi!

If you're new to gaming, I could recomend Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2003, It's easy and fun to start with and quick 15 minutes games are possible. But if you like it, you can spend hours without thinking about it.

Posted by: Ulf Carlsson at September 29, 2003 01:32 AM

Computing is a vast subject, and I don't think that you should feel compelled (nor would it be possible) to cover every facet of it. For instance, would you review a molecular dissection program? A medical system written expressly for cardio consultants? Computers are reflective of life; the only way to progress is to specialise. Do what you do, but do it well. Mike Wendland doesn't need to review games - there's plenty others who do.

Posted by: Chris Randall at September 29, 2003 01:56 AM

Hi Mike,

another game with no sex or violence is Championship Manager 4 (football - i.e.. soccer for you Septics ;) ), the first of the CM series to come out on the Mac as well as Windows (AFAIK). I've wasted many happy hours on version 2 and 3. As soon as I get a Mac, that will be a must-buy!

Posted by: Tim at September 29, 2003 09:57 AM

I only play games occasionally, as I consider 99% of the stuff out there rather pointless. But games are important to the Mac because a lot of people DO play games. Games are to a computer platform what a hot sports car is to a car company.

Like when Nissan killed of the Z car a number years ago. Without a flagship car to capture the imagination of the buying public, Nissan brand and image really started decaying.

It's the same with games. Games constantly push the hardware, and this evolutionary pressure ends up benefiting all computer users.

Also, the majority of gamers are adults and I recall a recent study saying that half are now women. So just like only a fraction of movies are rated G, games themselves are featuring ever more mature content. It would be silly to expect Hollywood to strike out sexual or violent content from all its movies, and these days, many top tier games have production budgets of $20 million or more. Viewed in that light, games are fast becoming another form of media, albeit an interactive one. The only question is having an ecosystem that has enough variety so we don't get stuck with one or two genres.

Posted by: paul at September 29, 2003 02:37 PM

I don't believe that it's important for you to worry about covering the Mac as a gaming machine. I sell Macs for a living, and I rarely ever sell a Mac based on its gaming capabilities. I'm not discounting its importance as a gaming platform, which has improved dramatically in the past couple of years, but I don't think that's one of the main reasons most people buy a computer. There are other platforms that cost less and are designed specifically for gaming.

What I find more troubling is that too many non Mac users think that our platform is just for "graphics." They are often surprised to learn that the Mac can be used in any area where a Windows box can be used. Those are often the ones I switch over! :-)

Posted by: Karl Groeger at September 29, 2003 10:42 PM

You personally definitely don't need to review games. Especially since you have no interest in them and no knowledge about them. It would be pretty difficult to write a review about something you have no interest in, or previous experience with.

However, games are way more than just a "fad". Games generate more revenue than Hollywood does now. It's a huge industry, and is definitely here to stay.

No, it isn't productive, but neither is watching a movie, or TV, or reading a book, or going for a picnic, or playing basketball, etc. It's a way to have fun and relax. That's why they are called games and not "productivity simulators" or something like that.

Yes, a lot of games focus on violence and objectifying women. But so do movies. Are you similarly unsettled about violence and sex in movies? Or are you just unsettled by the same thing in video games because it is "new" to you?

People that aren't familiar with video games still seem to think that they are only for kids. Then when they learn that games have violence and sex in them, they are shocked that the designers are making violent games for kids. But they are not for kids, games have a rating system just like movies do. Surely you don't think all movies should be G-rated so that kids can watch every single movie. It's the same with games, there are tons of games out there that have no violence or sex in them at all. These are the games kids should play. However there is an even larger market of adults that play games, and there are other games that are aimed at their interests and maturity level, just like in the movies.

If violence and sex in games really bother you, than pick up a Nintendo console like the Gamecube or the Gameboy Advance. Most of the original Nintendo games are still based on old favorites like Mario, Luigi, and Zelda. The games are always colorful, very polished, and most importantly, extremely fun. I'm 21, but still own every single thing that Nintendo puts out, just because they still make games that are a blast to play. Many games on other consoles (and some on Nintendo consoles of course) seem to use violence and sex as their only selling point. Take for instance Soldier of Fortune II, which is probably the most graphically violent game out right now. It's main selling point is how accurately it models someone's arm being blown off, or blood spurting from their chest after they get hit with a rocket launcher. Other than that, it brings nothing new to the table, and is actually pretty boring to play. Nintendo still focuses on gameplay and fun, rather than extreme violence and sex.

Enigmo is a really fun game that is Mac-only.

http://www.pangeasoft.net/enigmo/

It's a puzzle game, kind of like the Incredible Machine from Sierra in the mid 90's. The object is to get some dripping water from one container to another, by using a few objects you are given to redirect the water. You can angle them, some are bouncy, some shoot out the water like a cannon, etc. It's kind of hard to express exactly what is fun about bouncing water around, but if you enjoy puzzles of any kind you should definitely enjoy that game.

You may also want to look into a strategy game like Sim City 4 or Age of Mythology. If you are not a gamer, an action game based on fast reflexes and complex button combos like Tony Hawk is probably not the best place to start. There are many other games out there that can appeal to just about any audience, you just have to find the ones that you like.

Posted by: Derek Rose at September 30, 2003 09:25 AM

Mike, the only thing you HAVE to keep in mind about gaming is that IT is whats driving hardware these days in the PC World. The gamers are THE driving force behind ever faster chip speeds (especially graphics chips). I have a pretty good PC gaming rig (about the ONLY thing I use my PC for since switching). I play when I can. I wouldnt buy a Mac to play games -- although I havnt tried your new 2dualG5.

Posted by: afpilot at October 1, 2003 12:00 PM

I'm not a huge gamer, but I do remember playing an awful lot of Marathon (by Bungie, the guys who now do Halo) in my freshman year of college. I bring Marathon up in particular because it's a Mac classic.

It's pretty difficult because of the sheer breadth of games, and in some of the best games (especially anything by Bungie) the amazing depth. To wit, there is a site devoted to carefully analyzing the Marathon story and, after 8 years, it's *still* *going*.

http://marathon.bungie.org/story/

(Scroll down in the frame on the left, maybe poke around "Facts and puzzling things about...")

Keep in mind this is all within an 8 year old game that uses the standard "shoot bad guys, find the switch, get to the next level" formula.

I think games are, in that respect, a lot like any other form of art. There's a huge amount of soulless trash, and every now and then you'll find something amazing. Generally, the most mindless sex and violence simply indicates a game that has nothing else to offer.

Posted by: scooby at October 3, 2003 10:36 PM

Hey Mike,
I agree with those here, don't bother with gaming if it isn't for you. If people ask you questions maybe finding a site that does an honest and great job of dealing with games could be a good direction to lead them in. www.penntarcade.com is great. The guys there seem nice enough maybe there could be some cross promotion or something. Anyway, that's my 2ยข. Personally while playing games I'd rather sit on my couch that in front of my computer I work at all day. Though, Warcraft is really hard to say no to when my friends hit me up in iChat.
Later man, enjoy reviewing the G5!

Posted by: Aaron Miller at October 5, 2003 01:42 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits