« How to stop messenger pop-up ads | Main | Underage kid arrested for sending out worm »

September 26, 2003

What's Apple going to do about 10.2.8 problem?

Okay. Let me see if I have this right. According to comments to yesterday's post and elsewhere on the Net, the 10.2.8 OS X upgrade causes severe battery problems in PowerBooks, messes up networking and the monitor display and who knows what else. It's so bad, in fact, Apple has had to it from its download site. Am I right?
Then what is Apple doing about it? What are those whose machines are adversely affected supposed to do until Apple gets its act together? Live with messed up machines? Please, somebody, tell me why I shouldn't be a tad bit skeptical of Apple's concern over customer satisfaction.
And please - Apple cultists who blindly defend the company no matter what - do not reply here. And let's also not hear from Apple apologists who weakly defend Apple by comparing it to Microsoft, saying at least Apple is not that bad.
I know Apple is better than Microsoft. That's not the point. The point is we should all expect Apple to behave better here in speedily resolving their buggy update. It's been two days without a remedy for those who updated and encountered problems. I find that inexcusable.
in Apple | TrackBack (1)

Comments

I agree that this is a huge public relations (maybe CUSTOMER relations) problem. But, in the back of my mind, I have the comforting thought that Apple will make things right. I have faith in the company. I am not a cultist, but, really, what would Microsoft do in the identical situation?

Posted by: emacguy at September 26, 2003 09:57 AM

I agree, i think that Apple should release another patch to remove the problem parts of the 10.2.8 update. Then after fixing bugs reissue 10.2.8.

Posted by: Jeff Z at September 26, 2003 11:25 AM

Whoa! Well, of course Apple has a problem with the most recent update, but, please, Mike, your little item today sounds as if Apple has rendered a large number of their computers useless and is hiding from users. A less passionate approach would cite that Apple released a non-essential bad Update, of which SOME early adapters noted trouble. Apple appropriately pulled the Update, and assumingly is working on identifiying the problem and fixing it.
From none of the items I've seen has the Update glitch caused any irrevocable troubles. From what I can tell, those that exerienced troubles have worked their way back to usability.
It's certainly possible that Apple doesn't know what went wrong and can't project when an Update will be posted.
I don't know why this has gotten under your skin so badly. Is there anything you're not telling us?

Posted by: Chris at September 26, 2003 12:27 PM

Jeff Z said: "Apple released a non-essential bad Update, of which SOME early adapters noted trouble. Apple appropriately pulled the Update, and assumingly is working on identifiying the problem and fixing it."

Uh, Jeff, it wasn't a Beta. It appeared in Software Update for *all* users of Mac OS X to apply. Like any good netizen, I immediately applied the Apple-sanctioned patch to patch any security vulnerabilities that may have been addressed in that update. I'm not an early adopter, I'm a registered user!

Now, that being said, I'm not biting apple's head off over this, but I think they should be moving faster. More information from them about the reasons the update was pulled would be nice. An uninstaller (or some other method) to revert my system to 10.2.6 would be better, as my battery's going all wonky on me. Some idea from Apple as to when the update will be updated would be great, too.

Posted by: Brian at September 26, 2003 12:47 PM

Bah. s/Jeff Z/Chris/. Sorry guys.

Posted by: Brian at September 26, 2003 12:48 PM

I'm making do with the update, since it would take way too long to reinstall 10.2.0 and then run all of the updaters to get to 10.2.6. My eMac is only a little broken by 10.2.8 - I can't consistently double-click icons for files for classic mode applications. OS X will bring the correct app to the foreground, but most of the time the file refuses to open by double-clicking. For now I'm dragging file icons to the application icons in the Dock. Frustrating.

Makes me hope Apple will adopt a Microsoft innovation, the ability to "rewind" your OS updates when things like this happen. Of course, Windows users tell me Microsoft doesn't do the best job with this feature, but in the few cases where Apple has released a bug-laden update, being able to step back a revision or two would be a godsend.

Posted by: Dan Knight at September 26, 2003 01:21 PM

Apple has been vocal about this update in the Support are of their website. I'll guess very few people have seen the KB document on 10.2.8..

APPLE HAS POSTED AND UPDATED ITS SUPPORT DOCUMENT 3 TIMES ABOUT THIS UPDATE AND HOW TO FIX THE PROBLEMS IT CAUSED.

I have updated three computers including the most affected computer by this update; PowerMac Dual G4/450 and I can tell you that none of these computers are having problems. I feel very lucky.

But most are blowing this out of proportion.

Shame on Apple for not having some kind of Software Update uninstaller.. That should have been introduced with 10.2.

Lengthy FYI--

Technically speaking; updating a Unix OS is not that easy especially if you have to support such diverse hardware such as Apple's line of computers. I'm not defending Apple on this one -- trust me -- however we should never think that an update is going to be perfect with this OS given the current base of hardware.
Think of it this way Sun and SGI (unix) all have a very finite and structured set of hardware to run their respective operating systems Solaris and IRIX, the hardware is in a sense build around their OS and thus operates and updates very well. My point is that Apple has lots of hardware to support and that''s their biggest problem with OS X updates.

ALL updates will break (disable) hardware and/or software at one time or another. Unfortunately that is the nature of Unix OSes and possibly computers. They are not perfect systems regardless of the manufacturer. Remember always backup!

Now that the G5 has been introduced I'm sure all new hardware will be build for OS X only and these update problems will begin to disappear.

-- By the way

we've had about 14 or so updates, you'd think people would have learned by now to expect this sort of thing. :)

Posted by: Christopher at September 26, 2003 02:01 PM

I tend to agree with you, Mike, that Apple has been and is causing it's customers a lot of needless aggravation. I also agree that Apple is not living up to it's own reputation and claims they've made (to the effect, "It just works").

As a former purchasing agent, I can assure any Apple loyalists that they are treading on thin ice. As customers often learn to their sorrow; NEVER trust a vendor to deliver on blue sky promises. Also, it would be wise for people to adopt a more selfish attitude when it comes to the time and money they expend on any product.

Specifically, with regard to OS 10 we've been subjected to a long series of 'development releases' which only means that the product has not been ready for release for about 2 years now. I bought my eMac at the end of July and in the 6 or 7 weeks since, Apple released 10.2.7 and 10.2.8. I bought too soon, should have waited (at least) until 10.3 (Panther) was released.

Each of these releases has caused some problems for limited numbers of Mac owners, in aggregate, the numbers must be "significant" and that alone leads one to conclude that Apple is pressing it's luck, abusing it's customer base.

We've become conditioned by all computer and internet companies to accept these "little things" when we should have been applying pressure (big time) to make them stop excusing their own haste and sloppiness (not to mention their avarice).

Proof of Apple's haste is also evident in some features of OS X. It's being sold partly on the basis of the "digital hub" concept, yet they've yet to provide a version of "Addresses.app" that will let you put a list of intended recipients into the (ungainly to achieve) BCC header so you can send "blind carbon copies" while preserving some measure of privacy. There's simply no "BCC" button to click on in the dialogue window, even when you've already created a BCC Header in the message form field. And you must create a BCC header for each and every email you want to send that way, it's not permanently part of the email message form-- as it is in so many other email applications.

So, yes Mike, Apple deserves a kick in the heinie for this one. And we would serve ourselves well if we keep kicking for a while.

Posted by: Jack at September 26, 2003 02:45 PM

I don't hold out much hope for a quick fix, at least for the battery life problem. I had a similar problem after upgrading to 10.2.4 (only it was worse then, I went from 4 down to 2 hours, this time I went down to 3 hours usable time on my ibook.) They never really fixed that bug as far as I ever heard. I did squeeze a new battery out of them that time. This time no luck. Very disappointed, to say the least. You wonder how thse kinds of major problems slipped throught QC. Didn't anyone testing the software use a laptop? Didn't they know their batterty life suddednly dropped after upgrading? After the 10.2.4 problem, weren't they looking specifically at this issue? also, with the networking, how could they not catch that one either? Just how many machines did they actually test on for compatibility? Frustrating!

Posted by: Mark at September 26, 2003 08:32 PM

Well Mike,

Lets take this one at a time.

"Okay. Let me see if I have this right. According to comments to yesterday's post and elsewhere on the Net, the 10.2.8 OS X upgrade causes severe battery problems in PowerBooks, messes up networking and the monitor display and who knows what else. It's so bad, in fact, Apple has had to it from its download site. Am I right?"

No your wrong. The 10.2.8 upgrade effects a small, let me say that again, SMALL, segment of the total Mac community. As with almost all Mac users they are very vocal about any glitch in the software that comes from Apple. So the loaded response from a journalist, and the Mac Community is magnified by just such statements and comments as the ones in your blog.
All the individual statements have a morsel of truth but when combined have the effect of a tactical nuclear weapon used to put out a dumpster fire.
Compare the number of responses to the same question posted on this blog and on the PCMike blog. That's the difference between Mac and PC people.

"Then what is Apple doing about it?
What are those whose machines are adversely affected supposed to do until Apple gets its act together?"

They pulled the update. They posted easy to find information to help the users that were adversely affected. Ever seen another big company react that fast? Looks like a company with a together.. act to me.

"Please, somebody, tell me why I shouldn't be a tad bit skeptical of Apple's concern over customer satisfaction"

You should not be skeptical of Apple's concern over customer satisfaction. They have reacted fast and will come out with a fix as soon as they can. Apple, more than most, has tried to place the Customer over the Dollar. By pulling an update that only concerns a small portion of Mac Users and acknowledging the problem on their Web site demonstrates with Action not Lip Service the commitment to Customer Satisfaction.

What you should be skeptical of is any System upgrade from any company. Skeptical enough to backup your System and critical work incase you are one of the unlucky few that get hosed. If you blindly upgrade from ANY company you are asking for trouble with a capital T! As someone with a lot of influence over the computer public you should be advocating the backup strategy in every column about any software upgrade. No excuses, every time you review, praise or dis a product the first or last sentence should always include the word "Backup".

seeya
dxtr

Posted by: dxtr at September 27, 2003 01:27 AM

Well, agreed 10.2.8 affected a small population, but my gripe is more with APPLECARE, or more appropriately, APPLEDOESNTCARE.

Spent $500 on it with initial purchase of my PB17, and just a dreadful experience with their tech folks. It's like they've memorized the "Redmond Mantra" of "Reboot, Reinstall" but modified it as "Archive Install".

That was also the response to the 10.2.8 fiasco.

That's their answer to every problem I've had since June (3 separate incidents).

No troubleshooting, no actual "thinking" (differently or not...) -- just plain lazy if you ask me. "Gee, I don't know..." is the most technical thing I've ever heard them say.

I ask, if they don't know, who does?!? They're the VENDOR!

Fixed the 10.2.8 etherNOT ;-) with the kext replacement hack, so that's up and running (whew!)

2nd most recent issue I ended up fixing ON MY OWN with a parallel install on FW drive, then a little kinkiness with a command-line "bless" and voila! problem fixed.

$500 is a bit steep when all I assume I'll ever get is hardware replacement.

"Archive Install" (qv. "lose a week of my time reinstalling apps and recovering data from backups") is NOT tech support.

And they want to sell me Xserves? I get this GARBAGE from them with a PB, you think I'm going to trust them with my SERVERS???

When pigs fly...

*grumble*

Posted by: Rob at September 28, 2003 04:49 AM

I switched to Macs in 2001 from being a Windows user ever since I learned how to use a computer. This was the time that OS X was first released and I almost went back to Windows because of the difficulty in getting OS X to work with Mac applications meant for OS 9 which meant you had to run Classic mode till such time the software was released in the OS X version.

I think we Mac users, new converts and old users alike, have grown used to not being subjected to the torture of Windows anymore which is the reason why we have Mike steaming over the problems caused by the 10.2.8 update.

We need to remember that if we had still been using Windows we would have to contend with endless patches, virus threats and the dreaded BSOD which had us reinstalling Windows and all of our applications and having to spend at least 3 days getting everything back in order again. Truth be told the only Windows version I didn't have this problem with was 2000 but I did spend the same amount of time going over websites with tweaks trying to get it to run more efficiently.

I think Apple and Steve Jobs are going through baby steps. However, if you ask me, I'd rather stick with Apple than having to go through the nightmare that is Windows.

I actually get to use my computer now for what it was meant for not like before when I was sitting in front of it to tweak it, resolve hardware/software compatibility issues, etc.

Apple wasn't the first to come up with the plug and play tag line but they're about the only ones who can back it up.

I'm sure that when they've got the update cleaned up, OS X will be even more worth it.

Posted by: RG San Luis at September 28, 2003 07:09 AM

People make mistake, and I am sure Apple will fixed the stupid mistake soon. I installed mine on the PB 17" and every thing seem fine. I even notice that a fix on css bug has been done on the Safari.

Posted by: Thomas Chai at September 28, 2003 01:14 PM

"people make mistakeS", and any software company should do a decent amount of regression testing before posting an update. It wasn't released as an early adopter here there be monsters option it was released as something you should be downloading. Apple needs to adopt the winupdate philosophy of critical, optional and other.

To the people who keep talking like Windows is a busted nightmare of cobbled together code, please take a moment and look at a recent release of the OS and beware the day enough computers run an Apple OS to make some cranky nut write a virus just for you.

Posted by: Mr. G. Teacher at September 28, 2003 04:17 PM

In reaction to Mr. Teacher's comments, I don't think the day will come when OS X will approximate the number of users Windows has for the simple reason that Apple has no reason to run after the market share that Windows has.

Wintel machines are cheap in terms of desktops but if you look at notebooks and compare them with the powerbooks, value for money alone will leave you no other decision than to buy a powerbook unless you believe that the transition from Windows to Mac will be a painstaking process.

Mr. Teacher seems to have too much faith in Apple overtaking Microsoft in 10 years. Not going to happen unless somebody comes up with a virus severe enough to make everybody using Windows to change to Mac overnight. If there is a cranky nut out there already working on this....

Posted by: RG San Luis at September 29, 2003 07:22 AM

I just have to say is this...after years of using Macs and PC's Macs are easier to use..why? well say you have a 60 gig HD...partion it three times..then you can install OSX on the first, OS9 on the second and OS9 or whatever on the third..and reboot into whatever you like..try that on a windows box!...as well as I have an external HD that I have OSX installed on...why? because of potential update problems...the OSX backup is a carbon copy clone of the last update (10.2.6) which has no known problems..I installed 10.2.8 on my main HD with no problems...so I updated my backup OSX to 10.2.8..my point being...EVERYONE should have a backup of thier OS (OSX or OS9) for this very reason of update problems...this way when a problem does happen (like with 10.2.8) then you are not screwed..dont update your backup HD until you know that there is no problems..give it a few days...then you can use your backup HD and carbon copy clone back to your main HD or reinstall the OS on your main HD but at least you are still up and running...and yes every company has it's nasties...apple is not exempt, and they are still my favorite no matter what...cheers, Mark

Posted by: Mark Trites at September 29, 2003 10:38 AM

Apple is doing what it can to fix the problem i am sure. For those who affected by the update should simply archive all your info and go back to 10.2.6 untill the problem is resolved. I dont like the fact that the person who posted this thinks that software problems can be fixed overnight. Things take time, and it is well worth the wait for anything Apple makes in either software or hardware.

Posted by: mike at September 29, 2003 08:04 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits