« Blogging as journalism | Main | Terrorism conspiracy sites thriving »

September 04, 2003

Is 17-inch PowerBook too big?

As I packed up the the 17-inch G4 PowerBook I had been testing and sent it bak to Apple the other day, I realized again just how much I like my own (still-being-paid-for on my credit card) 12-inch PowerBook. The 17-incher is just too big. It's heavy, huge and hard to handle on an airplane or perched on a lap. I suppose it would be a good desktop replacement for some and I'd probably want it if I did a lot of on-the-road video editing. But for convenience, ease and efficiency, the 12-inch is the perfect size for me. I notice that several PC makers like Toshiba and Sony have come out with their own 17-inch machines, again copying Apple. But I still wonder how much of a market there is for these giants.
in PowerBook | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I think the point of the 17 is that it is a desktop replacement that travels - mine goes from my desk at school to my desk in the office to my desk at home. I always have all the same data and the same programs. If I used three desktops, I'd constantly be syncing them. (Reminds me of the SE30 I had with a travel bag. Same purpose.)

Posted by: Jim Bunnell at September 4, 2003 12:32 PM

I have both a 17 inch PowerBook and the latest 15 inch PowerBook. (Both are 1 GHz CPU models.) For me, the 17 inch model is the best portable I have ever used. When I write code on the 15 inch, I really need to attach a second monitor. With the 17 inch, this is unnecessary. There are other tasks where the larger screen really is useful.
I do occasionally look wistfully at the 12 inch PowerBooks and iBooks, but only when I am on the road and just need the computer for e-mail, etc. For 'real' work, the 17 inch PowerBook is what I need.

The 'only' advantage that the 15 inch model has is that it will boot into OS 9, and I hope that I will not need to do this at all by this time next year.

Posted by: george woodrow iii at September 4, 2003 01:21 PM

I love my 17" and I've never found it to be too big, but I can see how it would be for some people. :-)

Posted by: adam at September 4, 2003 01:25 PM

I own the 17" PB and I disagree with you that it is too big.

Obviously it is a matter of choice and taste. I travel extensively, and while it is bigger and heavier, it is no worse than a lot of machines out there with less screen real estate.

Plus, a couple of pounds is a small trade-off for the extra screen size. The way I figure it, you deal with the size and weight occassionally, but get the benefits of the screen with every single use.

Posted by: Winston Bright at September 4, 2003 02:19 PM

For graphics and video users, the 17" makes total sense. I can't imagine buying one for any other reason.

Posted by: Doug S at September 4, 2003 02:40 PM

I wanna 21". I am 55 and am tired of leaning up to see through th lower part of my bifocals. I have a neck ache and a headache from it.

Posted by: shaitan at September 4, 2003 03:19 PM

On my last flight, the flight was over sold, I arrived late and was moved to coach (from first class) and the 17" PowerBook is to big on my lap or tray. Not a problem in first or business (on a 3 class plane)...

Posted by: Henry at September 4, 2003 03:36 PM

I bought a 17" PowerBook as my primary machine earlier this year. It actually was lighter than the PC laptop that it replaced, and not a lot bigger. I move mine between work and home, as well as take it on trips. Size has not been an issue.

Posted by: S.Fuller at September 4, 2003 03:57 PM

I find the 17" just to be a little bit too big at times, but I think I would take the real estate space anyday over the 15" or 12" PB' which I have worked on as well. In the long run, having all that space is so nice to have anywhere you go. Plus, the current 17" screen is much brighter and crisper than any of the current PB's or iBooks. My vote is yes it is big, but not too big where I would rather have a smaller screen.

Posted by: Kent Mercurio at September 4, 2003 04:28 PM

I have owned 2 TiBooks (400, 667), the 17" Powerbook and the now lastly the 12".

I liked all 3 and each is suited towards different things. The 15" is the perfect size for people who travel, but have a monitor at home for larger scale tasks. The 17" is great for video editors/graphic designers on the go, and the 12" is for people who travel a lot and size/space is of greatest importance. I liked the 17", but it IS a beast to travel with, and after having read of a few people who have had the screen break from the latch mechanism tweaking out, I'd recommend some form of insurance. The 17" also didn't give me that 'sturdy' feel when picking up with one hand from a corner when open or closed (the 15" does).

I downgraded to the 12" for portability. I also have a breakout box that connects the 12" to a 20" Cinema display as needed. I like the size, and power of the 12". I hope Apple finds a way to make it thinner (ala 15,17) and a run a little cooler. Yes, the 12" PB does get a tad bit warm on the handrest on the left side...

~chris

Posted by: Chris at September 4, 2003 08:03 PM

I own a 15" which is perfect for my uses. But for video/photo/dvd aurhoring, I use a 17" iMac (great second machine). I do understand the 17" PB now, since at first I considered to simply purchase a second monitor for my 15" Ti, but the second monitor sits at office or home waiting for a machine to be connected, whereas you get the 17" PB everywhere!, I did settle on a 17" iMac though for the wife/second machine.

Posted by: hasapi at September 4, 2003 10:50 PM

I bought a 15 inch iBook (strongly influenced by MacMike's experience with his crossover) which promptly blew up. Screen froze whenever it was moved. Couldn't cope without a Mac so went and bought a 17 inch and yes, it is too big but what a great machine. Then bought a Ti 600 15 inch for travel so suddenly had 3 Macs. Sold the iBook for a handsome profit, dropped the Ti and smashed the case so am now back to one PB. Bought a 20 inch cinema so have absolutely over-capitolised on Mac. Will probably end up with the new 15 Inch PB and sell the 17 but love it.

Posted by: Ihian Mackenzie at October 1, 2003 06:37 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits