
I found that the best way for me to run Windows applications on my mac while working at a mostly-windows shop was through Remote Desktop Connection, a Terminal Services client for the Macintosh made by Microsoft. In addition to working with a terminal server, it will allow you to remote-control a Windows XP computer. So where I worked, we found it cheaper (and faster) to dedicate a fast server as a terminal server for Mac users (and those with older slower PCs) to run the windows-only vertical market products. It also worked well for those workers who worked from home. They could use any old PC or Mac at home and access the same software they'd get at work, but at full-speed.
This is also a positive way to do things because it saves processor power on the Mac so you don't have any slowdown. Corporate customers should do this more often (don't they all like the thin-client idea anyway?) and even a home user with a PC could install XP on it and control it from the Mac... just an idea or two.
Matthew
Posted by: SuperMatt at September 2, 2003 07:40 PMThe VPC problem is related to the G5's lack of support for "little endian-ness" or the way x86 feeds code into the chip. The G5 is "big endian" only.
The G3 and G4 had the ability to emulate little endian mode.
VPC, to squeeze as much performance out of an emulated chip, had a significant portion written in assembly, or machine code, rather than a higher level abstracted code like C++, or even C, for that matter.
With this hardware specific code comes portability problems. But MS is a company that is never afraid of selling a product, and I don't think they view VPC as undermining any advantage they have, so I suspect this will get solved in not too long a period of time.
At worst, they might not put too much effort into wringing the last bit of speed out of the code, at best, I think they'll put a lot of resources into it (they supposedly want to use VPC code to improve server compatibility across platforms, after all), and use it as another club in their arsenal of blunt weapons, along with licensing, SMB/CIFS specs, and MS Office file formats. :)
Posted by: Mason McDaniel at September 2, 2003 09:27 PMI mostly agree with SuperMatt, but you need XP Professional (not Home Edition) to run Remote Desktop Connection (actually the list is as follows:
Windows XP Professional
Windows Server 2003
Windows 2000 Server
Windows 2000 Advanced Server
Windows 2000 Datacenter Server
Windows NT Server 4.0, Terminal Server Edition)
So if the person in question is a switcher running an older OS, it doesn't make sense to upgrade the PC to use Remote Desktop. I do agree with the concept however, I recommend Timbuktu in many cases.
My brother decided to change his law office over to Macs last summer. But his partner didn't like iCal, instead preferring to somehow keep the Microsoft Works Calendar program. Virtual PC was just too much of a pain to run this one program, so we set up one of the old Dells (Win98) with Timbuktu. The two lawyers and the secretary can each access the Dell easily through Timbuktu (aliases to the connections are on their desktops). You can get Timbuktu Pro 2000, which runs on Win98 and ME, for cheap, and the full Timbuktu 6.0.3 for OS X isn't too expensive, especially if you get the Pro 2000 version and then upgrade.
On your home network, you can set up a "headless" PC which will run a lot better than Virtual PC, even on an old PC. Timbuktu could be improved, but it's damn good now and has saved me a lot of time.
Posted by: ToeKnee at September 2, 2003 10:21 PMOf course, no one really needs VPC, but if they want a safety net, just wait a few months. The G5 is newer than new, and everything will be up to speed before long.
My suggestion? Buy a Powerbook. VPC will run fine, and you'll have enough juice to do anything you want.
Posted by: Jeff Jay at September 3, 2003 01:30 AMCheck this out. It is an alternative to VPC! for only $30!
Posted by: Dorian Mattar at September 3, 2003 09:51 AMThe link did not post on the previous message.
But here it is. An alternative to VPC for $30!
Posted by: Dorian Mattar at September 3, 2003 09:51 AMIf you want a free alternative, try VNC. Clients and servers are avalaible for Mac, Win and *nix.
http://www.uk.research.att.com/vnc/
Posted by: Tim at September 3, 2003 10:01 AMWell this put a huge dent in efforts to upgrade our G3's to G5's at a large corporation. The IT people want XP because of specific windows apps (and ignorance). We argued that using the G5 could save money by running our legacy apps and any PC program we might purchase. A demo of the G5 was scheduled with Apple. Not anymore....
Posted by: CJ at September 3, 2003 10:08 AMI just read an article at Macworld UK about a Windows emulator for the G5. OpenOSX just announced a new product called 'WinTel 1.0.1 for Mac OS X Jaguar' - which is accelerated for the G5 processor. Would this be a product your potential switcher could use instead of Virtual PC?
Here's the story link: http://www.macworld.co.uk/news/main_news.cfm?NewsID=6829
And the link to OpenOSX: http://www.openosx.com/wintel/
Posted by: John at September 3, 2003 10:39 AMI just set this up and it works better than VPC, but does require having a PC. I've installed VNC from http://www.uk.research.att.com/vnc/ on my PC, but for Mac OS X, I used VNCViewer from here: http://homepage.mac.com/kedoin/VNC/VNCViewer/
Together, they work like a charm. I connected my PC's display to my Mac which has dual monitor support and just use the full screen VNCViewer of the PC screen on the other monitor. It works pretty wonderfully and is so much faster than VPC. Plus, it can actually come out cheaper to run a headless PC on your network. You can also setup your PC via VNC to be used over the internet, so you can control your computer from anywhere in the galaxy. So considering that, you might want to put a password on your VNC server.
The problem now is figuring out how to make my PC as quiet as my mac!
Posted by: Harry at September 3, 2003 02:32 PMHow many switchers actually get rid of their Windows PC? In my case my 12" PowerBook replaced a notebook running XP Pro, but I still have my desktop running Windows 2000 Pro, so I haven't really encountered problems with running Windows programs when I need to.
I agree with the comments here that the Microsoft Remote Desktop solution works well. In fact, I will probably upgrade my W2K Pro desktop to XP Pro because of it.
Posted by: Frank McPherson at September 6, 2003 12:42 PM
I just removed VPC from my G4. Really no use for it in my home office. I run Windows 2000 at the main office. In my experience, it's just more staisfying to run apps in their native environment. VPC is just too slow. Prospective switchers should simply look at the apps they want/need to use, and then make an informed decision. In my opinion, VPC should never be a reason not to switch.
Posted by: Brian Richardson at September 2, 2003 07:11 PM