
We Mac users sure are smug about all these worms and viruses taking out the computers of our Windows-using friends.
But are Macs really immune from the threats?
That's the question I'm asked more and more these days by interviewers. I don't have an easy answer for it. Microsoft is sure the big target, with such a huge user base and such notoriously sloppy security. But technically, I wonder, if hackers and script kiddies set their mind on it, how secure is OS X?
I've never heard of a Mac user hit by a virus or worm, though. How about you?
In fact, I'm also asked a lot whether Mac users really do need anti-virus software. What are your thoughts and recommendations? I know of Norton's Antivirus for Mac, and McAfee's Virex. But do we really need these programs?
Hi Mike,
Even Linux has had a small number of viri ;) You're right - it's MS's massive installed base and inherent security holes that makes it an easy target, but unix-based systems aren't immune, just better protected. I'd still run that AV software, if I were you...
Posted by: Tim at August 18, 2003 11:23 AMI've been using Macs since 1985 in the
Mac Plus days, and I've never gotten
a virus or worm, in spite of not always
practicing safe computing. Mac OS is
a smaller target, but even so, almost
20 years with no problems.
Macs are not 100% safe, but Apple
doesn't suffer from the sheer
ineptitude you see among MSFT
programmers. Remember, the "I love
you" bug came about because MSFT
morons decided it was OK for
apps to execute within Outlook
without the user clicking "OK".
MSBlast came about because MSFT
shipped their OS with port 132
open. This stuff is just plain
careless and stupid. Occassionally
Apple leaves holes open, too, but not
nearly as often.
A fresh install of Windows XP Pro will result in about 10 open ports. By comparison OS X has no open ports and all the sharing services turned off on a fresh installation.
It seems to me that MS has designed its default OS configurations for corporate environments where admins need to access and control the PC and the users a afforded some protection by firewalls. Apple, on the other hand, has designed the Mac for deployment in more hostile environments and where an admin may not be available.
In something as complex as an OS you cannot find every potential hole, but why leave anything to chance and purposely leave ports and services open for exploitation.
Posted by: Matt Davis at August 18, 2003 01:24 PMI remember reading recent studies that showed that the number of attacks on Macs - even with it it's low marketshare - are disproportionately low. Also interesting was the fact that of all the attacks reported about 90% were caused by MS sofware. Apple simply makes a better more secure OS, I consider using a Mac safe computing, no need for antivirus software. If I inadvertedly spread a virus too bad, you should have protected yourself and bought a Mac. :-D
Posted by: Roert Lopez at August 18, 2003 03:07 PMA few years ago I asked the same question of a high level tech support person at Apple. He said he had never, nor had any of his staff ever encountered, or heard of anyone being infected by, a virus or worm on a Mac in the fifteen years of doing the highe st level tech support. So if the highest levels have never had any Macs infected in decades and there are tens of millions of Macs, the risk is essentially functionally non-existent but theoretically possible. It's this theory that ALL PC morons use as th eir defense.
Ee
Please check out this link for further discussion:
http://www.macobserver.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=11125
Posted by: Dan D'Errico at August 18, 2003 08:55 PMall that should matter to a CIO or IT director is to look at the landscape of what IS... not what MIGHT BE. What IS is Macs have not suffered crippleing viruses or woms for nearly 20 years. Windows seems to have a new fun virus, worm, or exploit every few weeks.
Add up the total cost of downtime, cost of virus software, and associted risks of not really being the only one with admin privs on your machines - and tell me in The Real World - not the dream world where Macs are hit daily by viruses - which would be easier for you to deal with and let you sleep more soundly at night knowing that tomorrows next cutely named virus attacking the internet will not in any way affect your all Mac, Linux, and BSD network.
in the real world...
Posted by: joe blow at August 19, 2003 02:54 AMMy first Mac was a Mac Plus, and for a while, we were plagued by the wdef virus which would infect the desktop file on any floppy that you put into an infected computer. It seems quite benign by today's virus standards.
However as Macs become more prevalent, I won't be surprised to find us under more serious attack.
Posted by: Doug Hogg at August 19, 2003 03:23 AMIn the old days (10-17 years ago) we had landslides of viruses on the mac (nVir etc.) Since then there have been dormant viruses found on machines but an active virus has not surfaced in my surroundings for at least 5 years.
But better safe than sorry since there is a certain threat even today.
Also if Apples marketshare should start to rise significantly there is no knowing what those crackpots may do. So virus software stays on my machines.
Posted by: Hans J. Gunnarsson at August 19, 2003 05:37 AMIt is demostrably true that Unix OS based systems are MUCH less vulnerable to hack or virus attacks, when compared to Windows OS based systems -- Apple's OSX operating system is based on a flavor of Unix called BSD Unix -- BSD Unix is considered to be one of the most bullet-proof/secure, general purpose OSs available, bar none. Apple's implementation of BSD Unix takes security to another level -- for instance, there is no root access available to either the legitimate admin/user or the hacker on a factory install of OSX -- having no root access available limits the amount of damage that can be caused by an Unix-centric virus/trojan horse attack, and renders most of the core system files impervious to manipulations. Second, there is no equivalent to VBScript on the Mac/Unix/Linux. VBScript allows nefarious no-gooders to secretly run VB code that can cause significant problem within the Windows OS, by virtue of the fact that VBScript can "touch" the Windows OS at a low level. Third, there is no Mac/Unix/Linux equivalent to the Windows OS registry, which is an oft-exploited security weak point within the Windows OS.
Posted by: Stan Hollins at August 19, 2003 11:24 PM
Nothing is 100% safe, Macs are a smaller target so there are not as many viruses made for the Mac. But even if the virus makers of the world would want to make viruses for MacOS X it's unix-like base would make it more difficult to write and harder to distribute.
Posted by: Tryggvi R. Jónsson at August 14, 2003 11:35 AMOn the other hand MacOS has it's share of security vulnerabilities which can be exploited if one wants, not as many as Windows but a few of them.