« Dial-up still rules | Main | Always On Syndrome and me on the BBC »

July 25, 2003

BuyMusic blocks Macs

Any doubts about Microsoft's hidden influence in the iTunes Music copycat BuyMusic.com site is now dispelled. In what has to be the most heavy-handed tactic I've seen in a long time, they now totally block anyone on a Mac from accessing the site. Macs could open the site fine the first couple of days. Now, Mac users get a message saying its for Windows and IE only. Typical Microsoft take-no-prisoners behavior. Then again, it also is about as ruthless as RIAA thugs and goons in going after the parents, grandparents and roommates of online music swappers.
in Blogging | TrackBack (1)

Comments

Not only do they block Mac users, but any PC user that isn't using IE. You can't get in with Opera, Mozilla, Firebird, or anything.

Posted by: Derek at July 25, 2003 10:02 AM

I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the BuyMusic.com TV commercials, either. They're exactly like the original Applemusic.com ones. Exactly.

At first I thought it was a parody, but come on!

Posted by: Jeff at July 25, 2003 10:04 AM

I seen the site before it was made for windows users only. Believe me, they can have it.

As for anyone doubting Microshafts involment even in a indirect way, is fooling themselves. Microshafts history is an "all or nothing" aproach to everything they are involved in. And if for some chance they don't succeed: they take their stuff and go home. For example, the Internet Explorer for the Mac. But then again, who really cares about IE?

Funny thing is, when you got a good model to rip something off of, why is so many fail to do so, well?

Posted by: paul at July 25, 2003 10:04 AM

You can access BuyMusic.com using Safari, if you have Safari Enhancer installed. Set user agent to Windows MSIE 6.0. I saw this posted on the Mac Observer.

http://www.macobserver.com/comments/commentindivdisplay.shtml?id=30886

Posted by: Jon at July 25, 2003 10:26 AM

But why would anyone, especially Mac users, even want to visit buymusic.com after the insults and cynical tactics?

Posted by: Paul at July 25, 2003 02:56 PM

They're not only blocking Mac users, but all Linux users as well as Windows users using a non-Microsoft browser. The ONLY computer users who can access the site are Windows users running Internet Explorer.

Aside from that, their song & album prices are awful. Far from what is advertised. I'll just wait until Apple releases iTunes and the Apple Music Store for PC users later this year. Tough breaks, buymusic.com!

Posted by: MIchael at July 25, 2003 03:20 PM

Possibly it's part of some contractual obligation to Microsoft?

At any rate, if you advertised that you were 20% cheaper than Apple, but in fact 99% of your prices were much worse than those on the iTunes Music Store, wouldn't you want to block anyone who could surf both stores and put out the word about the *actual* price differences? Remember, PC users can't surf the iTMS and will probably believe anything Buy.com tells them about the prices Apple is charging for the same material. And about all I'm hearing out of Buy.com is "We're charging 79¢ instead of 99¢."

Personally, I've always thought Buy.com teetered on the line between cheap and sleazy. Their whole approach to this online music deal has convinced me that they're definitely over the line and into the sleazy camp, so I won't be doing business with them for *anything* anymore. I mean, would you really trust these guys with your credit card number?

Posted by: jeff at July 25, 2003 03:59 PM

Looks like crap to me. They're doing us a favor (those of us who use non-MS tools). The site stinks, most of the prices I see are higher, and you have to be in bed with Microsoft to use any of it (I use Firebird on my XP laptop and it won't even let me in).

I'll stick with iTunes and my iMac for digital music. If I have to get music over Windows, I'll wait for the Windows version or iTunes.

Funny thing is that nobody has managed to get a decent Windows online music store out there while Apple works on their own. ITMS for Windows is going to clean their clocks if this is the best they can do.

Interesting too that they appear to have created a music download store that won't support the most popular portable music player out there. Strange. Only a Microsoft front could explain it.

Posted by: Doug at July 25, 2003 05:34 PM

Open the terminal and copy/paste:

defaults write com.apple.Safari IncludeDebugMenu 1

Quit Safari and restart it. Now look at the new menu bar item at the top right. It should read "debug". Click it and go down to "User Agent" and then hit Windows MSIE 6.

Browse http://www.BuyMusic.com with your Mac. No limitations!

Send an email to BuyMusic (available at http://www.buymusic.com/support/email.aspx) just saying how silly they are for allowing us to browse the site with a Mac without limitations.

Posted by: Joan Lluch at July 25, 2003 05:38 PM

There's an even simpler way to browse BuyMusic.com from Safari. I saw it posted on another website. Just uncheck the Enable JavaScript box in Safari Preferences, and this will defeat the browser/OS version checking code.

As you look around BuyMusic, feel the chintzy, sleazy way in which they've copied the iTunes Music Store layout, and then marvel at the fact that there's a section on how to use the site -- a surefire giveaway that its usability sucks.

Posted by: Bill at July 25, 2003 08:09 PM

Funny... I wonder if Tommy Lee is fond of his sales on the ITMS... they've got lots of his, and Motley Crue's stuff up there... And what about all those Macs I saw at his house on MTV's cribs? Damn.

Posted by: Tom at July 25, 2003 10:36 PM

you can use a free proxy such as http://proxify.com to access the site without any changes to your browser config. Works perfect with Nestcape 7.02 and OS 9.2

Posted by: Laurent at July 25, 2003 11:30 PM

Hmmm....I just tried the two solutions with Safari to access BuyMusic.com, and MS got me both times. They are therefore actively trying to keep us out. IMO, MS is in BIG trouble; they have painted themselves into a corner with their "Windows for the World" strategy. Although it may take a while, MS is going to collapse under its own weight as people get fed up with these tactics. Apple looks outward, embracing open source with a UNIX-based OS, and MS continues to turn inward. Who will be around in the long haul?

Posted by: Jan at July 26, 2003 08:01 AM

I finally had a chance to test the service on an XP box

http://tingilinde.typepad.com/starstuff/2003/07/more_on_buymusi.html

Posted by: steve at July 27, 2003 06:47 PM

Not to be picky, but the apple music store doesn't allow anyone without itunes installed to browse their store, javascript or not. Also just like buymusic is restricted to selling to US, windows+wmp9 customers, the apple music store is restricted to US, os/x+itunes customers. Where's the difference (other than market share)?

(Disclaimer, I'm a linux guy living in canada, so I don't get either, but at least I can browse through buymusic.com).

Posted by: Arcterex at July 28, 2003 03:15 PM

Arcterex,

The differences?

1. Apple did what is effectively an extensive, if limited, beta test of iTMS (US only, Mac only). It is, however, planning to roll it out to Windows, when the technology is ready, and the rest of the world when the licenses (read: lawyers) catch up.
2. Apple uses open standards (AAC - part of MPEG-4). MS uses WMA - proprietary.

I'm a Linux user, too, so I know where you're coming from, but don't confuse what BM.com/MS has done with iTMS.

Check the thread over at whatdoiknow:
http://www.whatdoiknow.org/mt/mt-comments.cgi?entry_id=1075
and Todd's original post:
http://whatdoiknow.org/archives/001075.shtml

Posted by: Tim at July 30, 2003 07:17 AM

The difference I think is that Buymusic.com is a WEBSITE. Generally websites are nice and open to lots of people.

Posted by: Seth Werkheiser at August 4, 2003 09:06 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits