
The more I use Macs the more I appreciate them. But just what is the appeal of these machines? It is really hard to define and some of the posts and comments from other recent switchers I've been receiving have really got me thinking about how difficult it is to explain this attraction to PC folks.
Here's an e-mail from a reader, for example:
Windows does a great job, but thats all it is - it just does what you want it to, and now without crashing. But it does not stir any emotions. Windows is like your maid, the Mac is like your spouse. Talk to someone who has never loved - they have no clue what love is about. But talk to someone who has loved - they do not want to lead a life without love. And that may be why Windows users go out of their way to bash Mac users.- from PravinThis guy "loves" his Mac. An IT manager wrote me to say he was "seduced" by a Mac. Others have called their Macs "elegant" and "pliant" and "sensual."
I agree that it is sometimes hard to put into words what makes Macs so wonderful, but they defiinitely are wonderful to work with. Elegance is the best word for the OS and the machines themselves. That is definitely not a word you use with Windows. A small example is when you are copying files, and you get the two little folders in Windows with the little piece of paper floating from one to the other, it is so tacky. Everything about OSX is so clean, bright and elegant, except the slow window resizing, which will hopefully be dealt with in Panther.
Mike
Same here. I have three PC's in my personal office at work and am responsible for 3 or 4 very large AIX servers (the largest with 8 CPU's and 12 GB RAM!), but I always carrying my iBook around and find it so much more loveable (yes, an emotional word), than any of them. I really cherrish my Macs in a way that I would never ever feel about my PC's and other computers. I have wondered seriously about it too, but don't seem to find any reason either. I guess that is what love is like ;-)
Posted by: Kim Gammelgå²€ at June 11, 2003 07:39 PMI agree with you, Mike. Explaining the Mac "allure" to others isn't easy.
One of the best attempts I've seen is a little book, "Macintosh...The Naked Truth", by Scott Kelby. I think the last chapter, "The secret of Macintosh", does a great job of explaining why we Mac fanatics really want others to experience and enjoy the Mac like we do.
Posted by: Garry at June 11, 2003 09:18 PMI liken this feeling to the Matrix and the Smiths being Bill Gates' brothers
what IS real?
I think it has a lot to do with the fact the Mac seems to respect you. As Jobs noted in the iTMS presentation to the independent music labels, Apple has never taken money to sell for product placements within the OS. You don't get a situation like Microsoft and the PC retailers which whore themselves by placing a bazillion icons on the desktop, which are basically just paid ads.
I mean, have you seen a typical PC with all its certification stickers? You have a sticker for Windows, an Intel Inside sticker, a sticker for USB, a sticker for this, a sticker for that. What's weird is that I've NEVER seen any PC user take any of these unsightly stickers off. It's like they are resigned or complacent about just accepting things as they are.
But the Mac, it treats you with respect. From Microsoft, we get "helpers" like Clippy or auto-correction features in Word that you have to fight with not to "correct" what you really want to do.
The Mac is like a friend ready to help you out...one with principles.
Posted by: Paul at June 12, 2003 04:03 AM"A Rebel without a cause." Maybe that's the allure! I DO miss my iMac though. I think it was the sounds it made...
Posted by: geek at June 12, 2003 07:36 AMI just switched recently. Things I used to do in Windows - saving attachments, renaming, FTP'ing, etc. - I was comfortable with. I almost wanted to do these things on my Compaq and not my brand new iBook (for shame!)
But then I just did it. A simple drag and drop from my email, click, rename, drag and drop on my FTP program... it wasn't "familiar" but it felt "right". As Mike Kaylor above said - those "flying documents" are ugly, but on the Mac everything moves so.. soo... so right.
Posted by: Seth Werkheiser at June 12, 2003 12:51 PMI'm in the process of swtiching right now. I sure do miss my 5-button optical wheel mouse. (right-clicking was so easy) Oh well, I'll just have to learn to live without for a while.
Posted by: Chris Hall at June 12, 2003 01:42 PMChrist, just plug in any USB multi-button mouse and it will work in OS X. Just because Apple ships Mac with a one-button mouse doesn't mean you are limited to just using Apple mice. I have a Microsoft wireless optical multi-button mouse and it works fine, no drivers to install.
Posted by: Paul at June 12, 2003 03:01 PMACK, sorry, I mean to type "Chris" in the above post, not make it sound like I was angry or anything. Sorry! :-P
Posted by: Paul at June 12, 2003 03:03 PMIt all goes back to the smiley Mac at startup on the old Mac Ses and earlier. It's always been a "friendly" computer, especially compared to the competition
Posted by: Bookman at June 12, 2003 03:26 PMI first encountered the Mac in 1984, soon after its introduction. I was using CP/M (a command-line-based operating system for 8-bit computers) at the time. PCs had been around for a couple of years, but with PC/MS-DOS being very similar, there really wasn't any compelling reason to change. Then I saw a 128K Mac running MacPaint. I was gobsmacked. "This is the way computers should work and will work in the future," I thought to myself. I was hooked.
One thing about Macs that has always impressed me is the consistency of operations between applications. Up until recently, applications on Windows couldn't even agree about keyboard shortcuts for clipboard operations. Was it control-v or shift-insert? On the Mac, applications are much more predictable, if that is the correct word. Each new application builds on the base laid down 20 years ago by MacWrite and MacPaint. Most things are familiar and, therefore, comfortable. It's not the big things that trouble me about Windows, but the lack of attention to the details, the fit-and-finish, if you will.
Posted by: Bob Studer at June 12, 2003 03:44 PMLOL! I think it may be time for Apple to put a note in the box saying "It just COMES with a one-button mouse. If you don't feel comfortable with it, just plug a different one in!"
Posted by: Mark at June 12, 2003 05:51 PMwell I was just sitting here polishing my iMac 17" Flat Screen and my 12 Powerbook, Can't remember ever doing that to my Wintel PC's! That's gota tell ya something.
Richard
Posted by: Richard at June 12, 2003 07:48 PMI have had my imac for three years now and have noticed something intesting when taking with people who have computers. I can with a fair amount of accuracy detect who has a mac and who has a pc by the way they talk about their computer (without saying the brand name of course). This doesn't work all the time but has often enough for me to post it here.
I have noticed that the pc guys and gals (but mostly guys). Will talk about what their computer has in it i.e. hardware or games.
Mac guys and gals will for the most part talk about what their computers can DO instead of what it HAS. Unless it's specific like a digital camcorder.
I orginally picked up on this about two years ago and started to follow the stats as a hobby.
Being a baseball fan stats are a way of life for me so it was easy. When it's all talleyed up i guessed with 87% percent accuracy of who had a pc and who had a mac by what they said within the first moments of conversation. I know it was insulting to guess a mac was a windows pc but three of the guys had recently "switched" and that threw me off. The other ones i plain screwed up.
Why should I love my car but hate my computer?
How am *I* the irrational one here?
Posted by: scooby at June 13, 2003 10:50 AMI'm a recent switcher...
Jaguar feels like a direct copy of Windows 2007. That's why I like it. It's a leap from what I was using with my PC just a few months ago.
Posted by: Kent at June 13, 2003 09:13 PM" I mean, have you seen a typical PC with all its certification stickers? You have a sticker for Windows, an Intel Inside sticker, a sticker for USB, a sticker for this, a sticker for that. What's weird is that I've NEVER seen any PC user take any of these unsightly stickers off. It's like they are resigned or complacent about just accepting things as they are."
Funny- although I'm a Mac user, I read this while surfing your site on a Dell laptop (I'm on my front porch, and the battery on my iBook is low)- I immediately tried to peel of f the stickers; the Intel sticker came off without a hitch, but the Windows sticker left a residue like boogers behind- so you think that means something?
Cheers,
Ken
This is a question I've wondered a lot about myself. Mike, I think you're right that many Mac users buy Macs for emotional rather than practical reasons, because they bring out people's emotions -- yes, sometimes "My Mac is driving me crazy" but mostly 'My Mac is FUN and enables me to do COOL stuff." (Right now, for instance, I'm listening to the Plimsouls via iTunes sharing on a campus network at the university where I work. I haven't listened to them since college -- almost 20 years ago -- and I'm loving it.)
Yes, Macs are just "machines," but when you use one you get the sense that the people who design and program these machines are really trying to make them connect to people on a human, emotional level. For a great perspective on this from a switcher, see:
http://www.furia.com/twas/twas0415.html
Posted by: scott at June 11, 2003 05:20 PM