
It's the first nice day in my part of Michigan for a while so I took advantage of my Airport Extreme wi-fi networks and worked out on my back deck in the warm sunshine using my 12-inch G4 PowerBook.
Remember all those complaints about the aluminum case heating up? Many wondered what would happen when the weather got warm.
I just finsihed an hour and a half of intensive work with mine in the full sun with nary a problem... except my sunburnt nose. The outside temperature reads 81 degrees. I detected no unusual heat buildup in the Powerbook - which continues to be the best laptop I've ever had.
The only inconvenience experienced was in reading the screen in the full sunlight. With a bit of squinting, I found it acceptable tradeoff for the pleasantness of being able to be outside working on a great day.
Its amazing that a laptop that seems hot enough to fry an egg on will be cooler in hot weather. I tried the heat test at the apple store in ny with an ibook, 900 mz. next to a 12 inch. powerbook. I was shocked how much hotter the powerbook was. great as a leg warmer if you live in Alaska. and the g3 ibook was a hair faster in applications that aren't altavec. all in all i was very disappointed since i had money in my pocket to burn. i bought the ibook. great machine and even that is still hot but not a leg burner. amazing how getting stuck with a lemon can justify making other people think its a great computer. i have a mirrored g4 desktop and the noise factor drove me nuts. i didn't convince myself it was quiet and led other people to believe it was. even the noise replacement kit stinks. bite the bullet and admit when something is poorly designed so others won't make the same mistake. avoid the 12 inch powerbook. its hot as hell.
Posted by: Steven at June 6, 2003 10:53 PMI've dragged my new 12" Powerbook everywhere. The left side (top and bottom) does get hot, but not unbearably so -- in fact, sometimes it's pleasantly warm.
The fan does get kind of loud when it comes on, which seems to be at random times.
The biggest concern I would have with the heat is how it will eventually affect the LCD panel when running in closed "docked" mode. Some have noted that it only seems to heat up when plugged into an AC adapter -- but that's the only way to run it for docking.
All-in-all it's a sweet machine, much better than a G3 iBook. It's certainly not a lemon, with its DDR memory, 133Mhz bus, 40G hard-drive, built-in Bluetooth and most excellent keyboard. The biggest gripe I have is that it has 128MB on-board, and a 128MB SODIMM in the only memory socket, which becomes worthless as soon as you (of course!) put in a replacement 512MB. Put 256MB on board, Apple!
Posted by: Leflyman at June 6, 2003 11:20 PMCome on Leflyman...it's not a lemon...it's a lemon grove!
Posted by: LF at June 7, 2003 12:47 PMThis is a joke, right? You mean, your $2000 computer actually worked fine in 81 degree heat? :)
Wow. Dell had better watch out!
Posted by: Paul Thurrott at June 7, 2003 03:24 PMA lemongrove? Not quite. Show me a PC laptop which matches the size, weight and features of the 12" Powerbook -- at near the same price (hint: there isn't one.)
And don't bother touting the 15" Gateway/Compaq/Dell deal dujour. I'm talking lightweight (2.1kg if you're counting) streamlined (3.0cm) portability -- with a built-in slot-loading drive.
The closest you will find is the Sony V505 series. But check the price.
I have been debating whether to get the 12in PB vs. iBook 900mhz. Your post has given me the confidence to go ahead and buy the Powerbook. I also hear in terms of graphics it is way better than the iBook.
Posted by: Kwame at June 10, 2003 07:07 AM"I have been debating whether to get the 12in PB vs. iBook 900mhz. Your post has given me the confidence to go ahead and buy the Powerbook. I also hear in terms of graphics it is way better than the iBook."
If you've got the cash, go for it, but the iBook is also well worth its price.
(Wishes he had the cash...)
Posted by: scooby at June 11, 2003 04:46 PMNow now Leflyman, be nice to the PC users, im sure pc's are usefull for something. (I have yet to figure out what though) The most dissapointing purchase I had ever made is Virtual PC for my mac, figuring i would need it. It got deleted right after IE and Office for mac. (The only programs that ever crashed) .
As for the PowerBook, I have been reading tons and tons of reviews everywhere. It is by far the best deal, the 17 inch is too big and expensive, and the iBooks (as fast as they are), have a cheap case and get hot.
Everyone has to admit, a Powerbook G4 867 with a superdrive for 1800$, apple has finally done it. I cant wait to see the fallout from when PC users see a better laptop for cheaper than they paid for thiers.
If someone would give me one, maybe I could take it oustide today, tomorrow, or the next day and test it in 105 degree weather. 81 degree heat is nothin.
Posted by: Pete at July 15, 2003 10:15 PM
It's a good design thing. Since aluminium is such a good conductor of heat and reflective, it will stay cool in the sun. My G3 firewire powerbook has also never even had the fan come on (that I'm aware of.) In fact, I once called apple because I thought it didn't work. I was informed that it only comes on when a certain temperature is reached. Apparently I've never reached the temperature. My multimeter says that the fan is good though.
Gotta love these.
Posted by: supportTEX at June 6, 2003 05:20 PM