
Bowing to what undoubtedly has been lots of pressure from the goons and thugs in the music industry, Apple has released a new version of iTunes called 4.0.1 that disables Internet playlist sharing.
Users no longer can share between different IP subnets, although it's still possible to use Rendezvous to share over a local network.
As we've reported before, lots of people took advantage of the feature and were eagerly sharing their iTunes 4 playlists over the Internet, bringing forth the wrath of the music industry. Apple told MacCentral that "the security of songs purchased from the iTunes Music Store was not compromised."
Whatever that means.
On the positive side, there are also some enhancements in the update, such as support for Dolby Advanced Audio Codec (AAC) and improvements in browsing and buying music.
It's all well and good to accuse Apple of caving in to the music industry shoguns. However, it might be a better idea to point a finger at those numbskull loudmouths who proudly announced to the world they'd found a new way of stealing music.
Posted by: chidi at May 28, 2003 01:58 PMdear mike,
There was no caving go on here.
----
Apple said in the statement that it was "disappointed" that people had used the new feature in iTunes to copy music with strangers.
"Rendezvous music sharing...has been used by some in ways that have surprised and disappointed us," Apple said. "We designed it to allow friends and family to easily stream (not copy) their music between computers at home or in a small group setting, and it does this well. But some people are taking advantage of it to stream music over the Internet to people they do not even know."
----
Let's put the blame squarely where it belongs, with those thieving music pirates who blabbed to the world that they found a great way to steal music, and as a result have forced us honest music listeners to pay yet again.
Posted by: me at May 28, 2003 02:53 PMApple makes a minor tweak to a program and you call it caving in to thugs? I wonder what headline you'd run if something really serious happened?
Posted by: John at May 28, 2003 03:43 PMNope, sorry. This is something that Apple was made to do. iLeech and the like are to blame, as are the developers and users of such products. Does this mean that streaming can continue? Yes, it does: QuickTime and numerous other programs can do it...but the ease is gone. And, as we've all learned from Napster and Kazaa, ease is the name of the game when it comes to people who abuse fair use rights.
Posted by: Geoffrey at May 28, 2003 04:20 PMI dunno. On the one hand, most of my music is stolen. Now that I've started to pay for it, perhaps I'm rationalizing.
On the other hand, I was always aware of some degree of cynicism: Napster was desperate to push the idea that there was a "community" of people "sharing" music. This always sounded like BS to me, since the "community" inevitably consisted of two groups: One, a small number of people who collected thousands of songs that were, frankly, crap, for no other reason than to have a big collection. The second was people who wanted free music.
Even if Napster hadn't been slammed by lawsuits, there was no money to be made from either group.
So whenever I hear about the evil music industry, I ask myself: is it like Napster? Is this "sharing" with actual people, face to face, or is it just a combination of people waving their dicks (look at how big my music collection is! I r0x0r!) and dumpster diving?
Posted by: scooby at June 2, 2003 09:50 PM
This isn't much of a surprise. Internet streaming via iTunes didn't seem like much of a threat, but once utilities appeared that permitted the direct download of streamed files, iTunes was transformed into a Mac-only version of Kazaa. Better, even, with its powerful browse capabilties!
Posted by: John at May 28, 2003 12:33 PM