
Here we go again. Technology is like the proverbial horse out of the barn. Mac sites sharing music downloaded from the iTunes Music Store have the music industry in a tizzy.
"It sounds as if it is a hole in the security that needs to be closed," Cary Ramos, an attorney for the National Music Publishers Assn., said Tuesday. "I don't know what Apple can do to achieve that, but I would certainly hope that they would take steps immediately to address this issue."Guides on how to share are online and sites like iCommune, SpyMac, and iTunes Tracker are proliferating daily.
This is much ado about nothing. The songs purchased via the iTMS can NOT be streamed remotely unless the client-end computer is Authorized (which is limited to 3 machines anyway, and which requires the server-computer-owners' password, which I guarantee you they DON'T want to give out!).
In other words, the only music which can be shared through this process is the same stuff that's already being swapped via Kazaa etc.--MP3s/AACs ripped off of CDs...and you're not even copying the file, you're just streaming it...which also eats up your bandwidth.
Bottom line: the iTunes sharing adds ZERO additional negatives to the situation, while adding quite a few positives.
Posted by: Charles Gaba at May 14, 2003 01:42 PMThe PROBLEM is that there's is a hole in the iTunes web server...you can right now get a program off Versiontracker.com that will let you STEAL non encrypted tunes from a public iTunes list. That means that unsuspecting iTunes users who post their IP address publicly can be ripped off, not just listened to. This is WAY more than just KNOWLINGLY sharing music files.
But the other problem is that running your own "radio" station requires you to pay royalties, and using iTunes to list your tunes publicly is basically the same thing. But there's really no way anyone can police it. I think it's a cool feature, but I think the braodcasting companies are going to come down on Apple for it once they know about it.
Posted by: Brian Peat at May 14, 2003 01:54 PMThe thing is, Microsoft's ThreeDegrees has had a similar feature for awhile. As have many Windows MP3 players, like Media Jukebox and others. This "music serving" (meant for personal use only, as the software's warning reminds) maxxes out at 5 connections, so it's not like this is going to kickstart any massive piracy operation. I have all the sniffing/snorting/dl programs that have popped up in recent days (web front ends too!) and about 1 in 30 IP addresses actually work, the rest require passwords, don't connect, or are maxxed out. No one's gonna put up with that when Acquisition/Limewire are just a click away. Not to mention the $0.99 option at iMS. This is MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING.
Leave it to Apple to get some good press for once, and bring attention to a feature that has flown under the radar for all this time.
Meanwhile, their DRM on purchased music remains secure, seamless, nearly invisible to the customer, and generally regarded as a fair compromise that everyone's happy with. None of these "revelations" take away this new platform of copyright protection. So what's the big deal?
Posted by: Fofer at May 14, 2003 02:32 PM
I like http://www.shareitunes.com/
Being able to listen to other people's libraries doesn't reduce my willingness to buy music from the iTunes Music Store. In fact, it has increased my interest in music on my computer.
Posted by: Chimpee at May 14, 2003 12:01 PM