
In our never-ending quest to diminish the ever-rising flood of spam into our e-mail, we've been carrying on a spirited discussion here and via private e-mail about whether the Rules setting possible under OS X can be used to supplement the built-in junk filter used by Mail.
I'm having very limited success.
I've scoured the Net and tried to add Rules as suggested by other sites and from readers. Let me post some screengrabs of what I've done.
First, I have trained the built-in Junk filter for several months and have it running under Automatic. It is at the end of my list of Rules (I have multiple accounts being filtered). Here's the Junk Rule.

Since these images are large and not everybody is interested in this, I'll post the rest under an extended entry.
Now... the Junk filter works fairly well. It catches maybe 40 percent of all the spam I get on my various accounts.
Much of the Korean, Japanese and foreign-language spam I receive, however, passes right through. So, following this suggestion from macOSXHints about how to filter it out, I added other countries and set-up this rule that I labeled Foreign:

Under each e-mail heading (you have to use View-Show All Headers), you'll see some non-English spam is labeled as Content-Type and some as Content-Class. I've made rules for both. Well, no matter because it doesn't work. I have tried these filters as additional conditions under the Junk Rule and as its own stand-alone Foreign language Rule. Neither stop the non-English spam. So, right now, its set up as its own Rule and I'm hoping to find out why it doesn't seem to move spam from those designated countries into the Junk folder.
I have another rule that tries to set conditions on Sender, Message Content and Subject. I labeled it Block and Delete. Here's what it looks like:

Again, it doesn't work.
So... what's a spam-sick fella to do?
I suspect the solution will be so simple I'll whack my head when it's pointed out to me.
But that's better than pounding my head against the wall trying to figure this out alone.
I think Jim's put the finger on your problem. Why do you have the Junk filter at the end of your filters? That almost guarantees that some other rule will intervene before the message gets processed by the Junk filter. I have the Junk filter at the top; the only thing above it is a rule I've named Automatic Delete, which is essentially the same as your Foreign or Block and Delete, except that, under "Perform the following actions", I have "Delete message" followed by "Stop evaluating rules." It works well, and, by placing these two at the top of the Rules list, you have the added advantage of speed: You winnow down the number of messages processed by other rules
Posted by: Scott Richert at May 8, 2003 07:49 PMI have the spam filter as the next to last filter in my list. The last filter transfers mail to a folder called "spam-potential" based on the single rule content-type = multipart. I realized that the only people who send me multipart mails are people I am expecting those mails from so they are caught by the preceeding filter. This has caught 495-500 spam in the last few days with about 4-5 false positives, which I then went back and created filters for.
Posted by: Robert Buice at May 8, 2003 08:29 PMMike,
Which asian rule setting did you try? The one for Entourage or the one from Macosxhints I pointed you to? I'm using the one from Macosxhints without problems.
And regarding order of the rules, I have the Junk rule at the end and it doesn't cause problems.
Steve
Posted by: Steve Dieringer at May 8, 2003 10:56 PMNONE of the settings seem to work... regardless of the order I put them in.
Only the Junk filter set to Automatic.
I wonder if that should be deactivated and only the rules used?
I have a similar problem in that the default Junk filter, even after training for many months, just doesn't seem to catch anything at all. One or two per week out of 10 to 20 junk emails per day (my ISP is also filtering and cuts the worst of it.) I don't even have any other significant filters.
I was hoping 10.2.6 would 'fix' this. But it didn't...
I tried the macosxhints hint to filter on gb2312 and that didn't help cut Asian junk either, or make any discernible difference.
It sounds like a good idea to move the 'Junk' filter to first in the 'Rules' list though so I'll try that.
Posted by: Tim Cox at May 9, 2003 11:23 AMApologies in advance for the duplication, but I posted the following in a different thread a few days ago. It might apply to those who are having more junk mail slip through the filter than they expect. The key seems to be that making changes to the default 'Junk' rule might cause problems. Here's how I deleted and restored the rule. Very little spam escapes the filter now.
Steve
Posted by: Steve at May 9, 2003 11:43 AM
I set up a very simple filter that works after the Junk filter - "If any of the following conditiond are met: Subject contains WARNING! perform the following actions: Transfer Message to mailbox Trash" That's all I did, and it works fine. I had trouble at first because I was duplicating a field setting that was covered by another rule. There was no warning, it just didn't work. After I figured out that I was asking it to do two things to the same message field and fixed that; it worked fine. I also did not attempt to change the color. I also had trouble getting it to go to the Junk mailbox, but the same rule sent it to the Trash fine. Good luck ...
Posted by: Jim Bunnell at May 8, 2003 07:01 PM