« Text messaging spam on the way | Main | Iraq blogger is back »

May 07, 2003

Mail spam filters

I'm using the junk filter with Mail. But I'd also like to add more filters through Rules in the Preferences setting. I've messed around and created a bunch but they don't seem to work. It looks like the Junk mail setting is an either/or feature, meaning I use only it or Custom for Rules. My question is... will Mail use its junk filtering abilities in addition to the specific rules I set up? Also wonder if anyone has a rules template for junk mail. Seems like this would be something worth passing around.


in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Move your own rules higher up the list - above the Junk filter.

Just drag and drop 'em.

The rules are evaluated in order, starting at the top.

Posted by: Jon Claremont at May 7, 2003 09:36 AM

I have a similar problem. Junk mail filter was not catching the continuous stream of Viagra related spam. So I made a rule to eliminate all emails with Viagra in the body of the message. Odlly, my filter is catching about half. Have the spammers found a way to insert a picture that just looks like the word Viagra so my junk mail filter can't catch it?

And my rule is about my junk mail filter.

Posted by: Bruce Balmer at May 7, 2003 07:18 PM

Mike, Mike, Mike, Get POPmonitor and give it a try. After a couple of weeks use you will wonder why you ever bothered with Mails filters. The sample filters in POPmonitor alone make it worth the $25.00. This is the first program I installed on my LittleAL and don't regret the money I spent one bit.
Jon is correct about the way Mail evaluates the rules and filters. First come first served.
cya
dxtr

Posted by: dxtr at May 7, 2003 11:16 PM

The name of Pop Monitor defines thr problem... it only works with Pop Mail.
Get me one that works with IMAP and you've won me over. At least Mail does that now.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at May 8, 2003 08:20 AM

Mike,

Have you made any changes to the 'Junk' rule as supplied by Apple? I did and it caused problems. Here's my story and the remedy:

I came across the hint at macosxhints that I pointed to in your blog entry re Asian email. I followed the instructions literally and changed the 'Junk' rule.

I immediately noticed an increase in spam not being caught. After a few days of misery I decided the increase in spam was probably due to the change I made so I changed the name of the 'Junk' rule to 'Foreign Junk' and tried to insert a new blank 'Junk' rule. Unfortunately, this didn't work - Maill wanted me to set parameters for any new rule and I didn't recall what the old Junk parameters were.

Once the Junk rule was removed, however, my problem was only compounded. It seemed that no spam was being caught....

I had, in the meantime, reset my junk parameters, tried going into training mode again, and all sorts of other home remedies. The bottom line was that once I removed the Junk rule the Apple spam filtering seemed to have stopped.

So I searched the Internet and couldn't find any help. FINALLY, yesterday, I figured out a fix. I determined that the rules were in ~/Library/Mail/MessageSorting.plist. I opened this file in another account and found the default Junk rule. I tried to cut/past the property using Property List Editor but no dice. But opening the plist file with BBEdit revealed a pretty straitforward XML set of strings which I attached at the end of this post.

So I just inserted this text into the .plist file for my Mail.app settings (after quitting Mail first), restarted and life is good once again. I think I had to make sure the Mail -> Junk Mail setting was set to Automatic again, but after all this Mail.app is getting rid of 90% of my spam again.

It'd be nice if someone developed a Mail rule utility that made this a bit easier - and perhaps a Mail rule 'exchange'. There are, after all, a dozen or so Safari property 'tweakers' but I couldn't find a single Mail utility!

Steve

PS - after previewing my post I see that all the angle brackets and stuff are deleted when posting the plist info below. Email me if you want the unmodified version. This should serve to let you know what you're looking for, however.

Active
1
AllCriteriaMustBeSatisfied
YES
AutoResponseType
0
Criteria


Header
SenderIsNotInAddressBook


Header
IsJunkMail


Deletes
NO
Header
SenderIsNotInAddressBook
HighlightTextUsingColor
NO
Mailbox
Junk
MarkFlagged
NO
MarkRead
NO
RuleName
Junk
ShouldTransferMessage
YES
TimeStamp
74043274

Posted by: Steve at May 8, 2003 11:16 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits