
I want to continue and advance this discussion about sending video electronically. There are some great responses on the first post.
Basically, it seems that what I'm hearing is my idea of e-mailing or ftp'ing a network quality news package is probably not do-able.
Looking at the specs for FCP 4... I see it ads something called "Compressor" to make ftp-able MPEG 4 files. Wonder if it would work well enough? It seems, though, the encoding and then the ftp'ing process would take hours.
What I want to do, as a longterm, on deadline and as a real life daily experiment, is cut video news packages in the field and then be able to get them to the TV networks via FTP or some other way rather than burning to tape and giving to FedEx or driving to an affiliate and having them send the taped piece via the bird.
Is this even feasible???
I'm ready to launch this experiment soon as part of a converged reporter project. There will be no microwave or satellite facilities. Just me, a camera, a FCP laptop and an Internet connection. What routes do I have to make this work?
I know this can be done on the Web but we want this to air on the news so it needs to be fullscreen broadcast quality.
Is the technology available? Any and all suggestions, alternate ideas and help appreciated.
But Bill... this is not broadcast quality, let alone fullscreen TV.
It doesn't help with the issue at all...
What kind of internet speed are you going to have? I saved a 1.5 min DV file to my desktop and got a file that is around 330 meg. Compressing it with Stuffit brought it down to 270 meg.
As I said before, you might get lucky using some of the other Codecs, but you could lose quality. But it WILL be better than some of the stop motion stuff coming out of Bagdad.
Compressor is a competitor to Cleaner, and it just gives you more control over your different codecs and codec settings.
If you DO have high speed and end up using FTP, just remember, DV isn't true broadcast quality, so the station will have to pull the DV file and run it through whatever process they use to prep it for broadcast. But uploading a file in a few hours is sure faster than FedEx. Just leave it uploading when you go to bed.
Posted by: Brian Peat at April 19, 2003 03:49 PMNo... again this doesn't work.
It's news and waiting hours for uploading and encoding is unacceptable.
I'm not hearing any real solutions other than dubbing it to tape and then physically taking it to them.
Short of my own satellite upload (hah!), it appears technology just can't do this yet.
Thanks for all the brainstorming.
Right - if you have sufficient bandwidth, ftp is just fine.
How large are your files? It's easy enough to calculate how long an upload would take, if you know the bandwidth of your connection . . .
Posted by: Roland Dobbins at April 19, 2003 07:10 PMMike,
I don't know who thinks DV isn't "broadcast quality". Its the basis for both the DVCAM and DVCPRO formats, and DV was all over the nets during the early War in Iraq. Is it equal to Beta SX? Uh, no.
I know fellow TV news types who edited news stories on a laptop onboard an aircraft carrier in the Gulf and pumped them out over the net, after crunching them via Discreet Cleaner 5. The trick is to break up the big file into chunks and to be patient on the uploads (remembering that most broadband links are capped out at 128K upstream.) The chunks have to be reassembled at the receiving end.
The key tool you need to do this kind of thing is patience.
Posted by: Kirk Varner at April 19, 2003 10:10 PMMike,
I handle multimedia efforts / web dev work at The Indianapolis Star. Our newsgathering partners is our local NBC station (WTHR-13/Indianapolis).
To make a long story short -- I can't even hand them over a DV tape off our GL1 / XL1S cameras as they being a fairly modern network, can't handle anything but their beta carts and VHS dupes. So I end up taking my footage for air and downgrading to VHS (not even SVHS) for air (yuck!) .. I have tried to even get them to go with a DVD inbetween (Mpeg2 CBR HQ).
I can see some television stations supporting DVCAM in the near future, but until then I think they are leery to support what I think they consider a "prosumer" format (DV).
I have family up in Ann Arbor and I follow your columns often (we lack a tech writer at The Star), but I can't for the life of me think who your television partner is. But I can't imagine that whatever station would accept a 720x480 NTSC MPEG4 at a "medium" bit-rate for broadcast.
We accept the quality in remote situations like Iraq, but no way a local affiliate is going to accept that quality.
-- Matt
Posted by: Matt at April 20, 2003 02:12 AMI shoot right now my NBC piece in DVCAM... edit it with FCP.. and then burn the tape to broadvast beta, which I FedEx to NBC. I've been doing this for years and the quality is broadcast fine.
The step I'm trying to avoid is the burning to beta and shipping part. But as far as quality goes, DV is fine for news stories.
The issue is getting the edited piece from the laptop to the TV station as efficiently as possible.
BTW... I've done Internet trainig for two years with the Dispatch Group in Indy and Columbus. It's a terrific news organization. And I can't believe the Star doesn't have a tech columnist.
Thanks...
Here in Holland at the public Newsstation I setup a system with a scanconverter. Through FTP the clips are put on the server. The operator takes the clips and starts them using Windows Media Player/Quicktime. Ofcourse plays them FULL SCREEN through a scanconverter to the AVID Mediarecorder or betacam (SP/SX/digital)
A scanconverter is a box to get the computer videosignal to a component/composite signal.
The PC is connected with the video infrastructure through a patchpanel.
We now also have installed a card from CANOPUS called AMBER. This card plays MPEG2 files.
Posted by: Ernest Otte at April 21, 2003 03:04 AMHi Mike,
We are a Gannett paper, subscriber base is slightly ahead of The Detroit News up there. We are Gannett's third largest behind USA Today and The Arizona Republic.
Gannett has syndicated tech columnist-types, but we haven't embraced using them in this market (which I don't know why, yet)..
All in all, you looking at a monster of a file that you could compress and break up into multiple segments. Question is what kind of bandwidth you have to push it upstream (definately not from a cable modem!)
Our affliate is about a mile down the street from us in downtown Indianapolis, so in our case, it's not a big deal to send one of the newsroom couriers to drop it off. We aren't at a point where we are trying to accomplish what you're trying to do.
-- Matt
Posted by: Matt at April 21, 2003 12:58 PMWhat i posted is certainly not broadcast quality. what has been happening with video recently is that while we have been getting better at video compression as mp4 demonstrates, we have made virtually no improvement in mobile communications beyond a 56k modem - especially in this country. With GSM phones becoming more widespread in the US, the mobile bandwidth situation will improve. when it comes to mobile technology, we're way behind Europe. And I resent that the French have better Cellular phones:)
Posted by: supportTEX at April 21, 2003 01:03 PMJust one thought for you and Matt from the The Indianapolis Star. DV tapes will playback just fine in DVCPRO decks, and they are considered "broadcast quality." For heaven's sake make WTHR pop for one because it is criminal to bump your DV down to VHS for air.
Mike--if you haven't already you might also want to check into the folks from an outfit called Telestream (www.telestream.net) who are in more than a few television stations with their internet-based clip delivery systems. A number of station groups are using them for moving non-critical stories.
Posted by: Kirk Varner at April 21, 2003 01:08 PMThat was ME that said it wasn't Broadcast quality. What I should have said was that is isn't Broadcast ready. Hand your DV tape to the TV guys and watch what happens...they won't just stick it in a DV tape player and slap it on the TV. It's in the wrong color space and needs to go through some conversion, and THAT takes time. That was all I meant by the comment.
Posted by: Brian Peat at April 24, 2003 07:52 PM
Although final cut pro can create mp4 files, you don't really need to have final cut pro to make mp4 files. All you really need is quicktime pro. In fact, quicktime pro can export video many of the formats mentioned here.
MP4 is currently the tightest quality compression there is. It's the "next step" in delivering video over the internet afte people get tired of giving Bill Gates money. And you can stream this format if you have windows NT, mac OSX, or any number of unix/linux systems. You'll find this software here:
http://developer.apple.com/darwin/projects/streaming/
And you don' t have to give anyone money to use it or even download it.
A sample movie I have made from final cut was an exported quicktime .mov formatted file. It's exactly one minute long. I filmed it a little over two years ago and edited it with final cut. The original file was 28.1 mb in quicktime format. The versioin i have placed online is the same lengh, compressed with Mpeg 4 and it is 1.1 mb in size. Small enough to email.
it can be found at:
http://homepage.mac.com/wgcarver/iMovieTheater17.html
Posted by: supportTEX at April 19, 2003 12:02 PM