
Here's one for you video people. Has anyone figured out a way to send edited Final Cut Pro pieces via e-mail, as attached files or by ftp'ing into a site?
I know because of the huge size of video that it's a tough send.
But I'm wondering about an edited piece no longer that 1:30. Can it be compressed enough to send via broadband in a reasonable amout of time (two or three minutes) and then opened and uncompressed on the other end and still be broadcast quality? We're talking full screen, ready-to-air video, not Web thumbnails.
It seems redundant to edit a Final Cut Pro piece and then have to dub it off to broadcast beta tape and FedEx it to the network or TV station.
The key, of course, is simplicity and speed. It should be something very easy to upload from the Mac, attach to an e-mail or ftp and then, of course, to download and open on the other end.
Is anybody doing this?
Well, you could try one of the Jpeg comression schemes, and try not to set it too high. It could get you something that will work. It would need to be rerendered on the other side, but I have gotten video collections crammed on CD that werre compressed using some kind of Jpeg codec instead of DV.
Posted by: Brian Peat at April 18, 2003 09:39 AMHi Mike I believe you could export your FCP movie to QT pro compress the movie to your delivery mode and screen size. I FTP'd my demo reel to my isp which allows 20 megs of space. the movie is 13.5 megs .....big file. i like this way of method of showing your reel You don't have to worry about which format your need to send...can you believe some people request 3/4 inch. i have never stuffed a QT file
Good Luck
Ted Lindsay
Mike--
How large is the uncompressed, full-size file to begin with?
I presume you've already tried (or thought of) StuffIt Deluxe? If the end-user is on a PC, just use DropZip; both DropStuff and DropZip also have self-extracting modes.
Not sure how much space this would save, but it would ensure that the file is intact when it's received at the other end.
If it's larger than 2-3 MB I would *not* recommend e-mailing it...that's what FTP is for (and by the way, Transmit is THE best FTP app around, hands down!)
--Charles
Posted by: Charles Gaba at April 18, 2003 10:45 AMHere's the problem...
A 1:30 sec Final Cut edited project is 127.5 MB.
That is obviously too big to e-mail.
I edited the package, then exported it as a selif-contained final cut movie.
127,5 MB... gulp!
If I understand you correctly, you want this clip to be broadcast quality, which means that a lossy compression scheme (i.e. quicktime, mpeg 2, etc) is out of the question.
The best thing you could do is try using Stuffit on the file generated by FCP then FTP it. Uncompressed DV should shrink by a decent margin with Stuffit, but even then you'd still have a 70-80mb file.
Posted by: Mike at April 18, 2003 11:57 PMMike, I agree with the FTP idea--I've not seen anything broadcast quality that long in a tiny file size. I don't know of any compression codecs that do shrink it that much and still maintain the quality.
Best bet, FTP. I recently transferred a 1.3 gig video file via cable modem--took me almost 8 hours but I needed it get there in full quality.
A 130 MB file shouldn't take longer than 30 minutes on a broadband connection.
Good luck! :-)
Posted by: Steve Richards at April 19, 2003 12:27 AMMike...
here is the deal.
1. "Broadcast Quality" is EXTREMELY relative these days, Have you seen what they are "broadcasting" from Iraq?
Yes... your 1:30 file would be about 130 MB, not surpriseing... However that is a DV file. DV IS COMPRESSED, DV is a 5:1 compression as it leaves the camera. An Uncompressed file would be FIVE times that size.
2. Compression... a DV video file is already compressed and no Stuff It or other "Zip" technology will help you. A compressed video file is already comressed.
your original post requesting a 1:30 file that can be eMailed in 2 or 3 minutes is basically impossible. Just because you can edit video on your Gucci 12" powerbook that sits on your lap doesn't mean you are dealing with small managable files. VIDEO IS BIG. really big.
By the way. I love your page. It is so nice to see pro mac comments from a recent convert who is intelligent enough to see the forest for the trees.
keep it up and bring some more converts with you!
fen
www.chrisfenwick.com
Posted by: Chris Fenwick at April 19, 2003 02:30 AMre: fen
thankyou for posting some sense!
most others are posting rubbish: "uncompressed DV" !
ignore the other posts, mr. fen knows what hes talking about.
the only thing i'll add, is you may be able to compress the file a bit more if you export it from fcp with the cinepak codec. this will take a long time to encode, but with care you should produce a smaller file, with good enough quality.
Posted by: Alex Kent at April 19, 2003 06:53 AMYou could use a basic mpeg encoder. We run live events and have been using hi-quality mpeg's encoded with the freeware TPMG encoder with great results. Your going to have to blow the dust of your PC though ;)
Look at approx 10mb per minute i.e. 13mb. Not great, but beats the hell out of 130mb. You can also set the bit rate lower to make for better compression/worse quality.
Posted by: Rich...! at April 19, 2003 07:22 AM
Never tried it but the standard Stuffit tools should work just fine, Still going to be a big file though.
seeya
Posted by: dxtr at April 18, 2003 09:07 AMdxtr