
I'm wondering if some of the problems and limitations on the 12-inch PowerBook G4 are causing any problems for users. I'm about to install Virtual PC 6.0 so I can use a couple of Windows programs. But I note that Level 3 cache availability is suggested - something the 12-incher sorely lacks. Anyone using it anyway?
Also, when will 1GB RAM modules be available for the 12-incher? Or is that a pipedream? I bought 256MB extra but may replace it with a 512MB card... unless I can get a 1GB module.
Mike,
I've read at the Apple Discussion Boards about available 1GB RAM modules. But, the only links I can find now are to sites that are in German! Poke around there... you should find it.
I'm about to install VPC6 on my 12-incher also, later tonigh. Will you please post how it goes? Also, which version of Windows will you install?
Posted by: sdimbert at April 8, 2003 01:13 PMI read that Crucial is planning to release some 1 gig modules, but I thought that was for later in the year. And I'm sure they'll be incredibly expensive. I'd definately opt for the 512 chip now. It really helped performance on my 700 Mhz ibook.
Also, I don't have the 12" Powerbook, but am running VPC 6.0 on my ibook. Not sure what you're planning on running, but it is acceptable for simple programs (I mainly use some bible study software and other low-resource programs) 6.0 is a huge upgrade speed-wise from 5.0, at least in my case. I think that a Level 3 Cache would be nice speedwise, but I have to think that your extra 167 Mhz of processor, as well as the G4 & the other improvements in the 12" powerbook over my ibook would compensate for the lack of an L3 cache. If it were me, I wouldn't have any concern instaling it.
Posted by: Mark at April 8, 2003 01:14 PMI actually posted a bit about my VPC6 experience on the Apple Forums at:
http://discusssearch.info.apple.com/[email protected]@.3bc0c1e4/3
There are a number of other posts with other user's experiences at:
http://discusssearch.info.apple.com/WebX?127@@!keywords=ibook%20virtual%20pc
The bottom line is that it does a fine job at emulating a pc. VPC, from my experience, is very stable, though not particularly fast. It will run Windows fine, though the more graphically intense the windows app, the slower the performance. I'd recommend running Windows 2000 (and NOT XP) under VPC, as it has a whole lot less eye candy to render.
I thought it ran OK with 256mb ram, but more is always better.
You can add a 512mb stick for about $100 from MacSolutions.. it's by far the lowest price for PB compatible 512 ddr right now:
http://store.macsolutions.com/pgi-Product%20Spec?PBDDR21512
Posted by: Mike at April 8, 2003 05:08 PMi understand a german firm offers 1gb for the al12, but the price i've seen is $800. no thanks. i can wait until it's below $200 at least.
the lack of l3 cache doesn't mean you can't run vpc, it just means you must not be in a hurry. [g]
but at 384mb you are at the bare minimum of memory needed to run vpc as you will need to devote at least 128mb or better 192mb or even better 256mb to the virtual machine. but i think you can squeak by if you shut down nearly everything else. windows2000 is said to run the fastest of the windows os's under vpc.
the screensize bothers me more than the speed running w2k, but i just operate the same way i do at work on an old dell--run everything full screen and alt+tab among the windows.
/guy
Posted by: Guy Teague at April 8, 2003 05:25 PMMike,
Unless you need 1 GB really, really bad, it'd probably be wiser to just get the 512 MB module for now. 1 GB modules for the 12" PB are only just being manufactured, so it'll take a while for prices to fall in line with existing modules.
By then, you will be able to upgrade to the 1 GB and sell your 512 MB on eBay - I'm sure there will still be plenty of demand for those a year from now.
Posted by: Paul at April 8, 2003 08:19 PMMy tech has a new g4 12.1. She is on her 3rd one due to chassis warp. 3rd time appears to be the charm, and she runs VPC w/ XP. She has a 512 in it, 640 TTL. It is sluggish, especially when running Novell Console 1, but works and is stable. I agree with the Win2K opinion above. If I had to do it again, I prolly would have downgraded to win2k
Posted by: deanmass at April 8, 2003 09:38 PMJust in case anyone was wondering about the slowdowns with graphic intensive Windows apps, it's because VPC can not use the graphics accelerator card at all. Instead, it creates a virtual accelerator card that uses the CPU.
Needless to say, it gets faster if you have a dual processor machine.
A non-profit I help uses VPC Win98 on 700MHz eMacs, and they seem to work pretty well. We have an Access application that we have to use. You would never mistake the speed for native Windows, but you can get the job done. The update to 6.0.1 made a surprising amount of difference in speed. Make sure you get the 6.0.1 update. The eMac does not have L3 cache, so I have to assume that the the performance of VPC on the 12" AlBook would be adequate as well.
Posted by: Mel Krewall at April 9, 2003 12:28 PMMike,
I use windows 98 on Virtual Pc and it works well enough for me. I use MS access, a terminal emulation, and a data converter program. I set mine up with 398 mg of memory and share the network conncetion. I works faster on the 1 gig but well enough on 12".
Posted by: Mike Mahoney at April 10, 2003 09:33 PM
Well, I upgraded from a 12", 500mHz iBook, so I can't really say that the machine's giving me any problems. It does get hot, and loud, but other than that, nothing wrong. The biggest issue is RAM - such a powerful machine comes with such a minimal amount! I haven't heard anything about 1gig modules, but let's hope it becomes a reality.
Posted by: Chris at April 8, 2003 12:41 PM