
What's with this? On a full charge, my 12-inch PowerBook G4battery life meter shows just 1:47 left. I got about two hours earlier today before getting the re-charge warning.
New, it was close to 3 hours.
I followed the instructions and drained the first charge down to zilch but over two months of use, there's no doubt now that I'm getting less and less out of a full charge.
Anyone else having similar problems?
They don't say deep discharge it, actually; just to the point the computer goes to sleep automatically. That's probably not enough to really damage it.
Posted by: Jay Maynard at March 22, 2003 09:55 PMHave you been running OS 10.2.4? I've read of several reports of the update killing batteries. It seemed to be mostly iBooks, but my old Pismo hasn't charged the same since I upgraded. I went back to 10.2.3, but it didn't help. Good luck. Hope you have Applecare.
Posted by: Ramona Hutton-Howe at March 22, 2003 09:56 PMIt's on warranty. Get a new battery.
Posted by: Mike P. at March 22, 2003 10:08 PMcheck the apple forums for the 12" ibook - everybody had the same problem. Including me - apple replaced it (in warantee) after I told them the power leds were flashing.
IBM laptops have had the same problem.
yeah this is a 10.2.4 permanent battery damaging issue. You will have to have the battery replaced.
Posted by: mike at March 22, 2003 11:42 PM... or are you hosting the webserver on the mac? >:) you just got slashdotted, kthx
Posted by: nontoxic at March 23, 2003 01:31 AMMacOSXhints.com has a nice article about Li ion batteries: http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=20030314081843218
Posted by: dave at March 23, 2003 02:48 AMI've had the same problem and fixed it (at least for now) following a hint on www.macosxhints.com. Once the "you are low on power" reminder comes up, shut down the system using
sudo shutdown now
Then, drain the battery some more by executing a pointless command, e.g.,
yes
At some point, the PB goes into "deep sleep." The power led is still pulsing but the caps lock light won't come on any more. Turn off the system by pressing the power button for 2 seconds, then turn it on again and recharge fully. This procedure got me from 1:35 to 2:54.
Posted by: drhfk at March 23, 2003 09:15 AMsheesh...so nice to read all these posts that make me feel as though im not crazy..i bought a second a second battery cause the first was so poor...im going to get them both replaced...the lousy battery has been the only thing about my 12 inch i disliked...last time i checked i got maybe 100 minutes out of the charge
Posted by: steven acker at March 23, 2003 06:39 PMi am new to the 12" powerbook, so i haven't experienced sever battery life problems. i also haven't gotten anywhere near the five hours advertised uptime.
i have an old gateway solo 5150 that also uses a lithium ion battery. i got that machine circa 1998. i find that i occasionally need to rerun the battery calibration by fully discharging the battery in bios (callibrate gas guage).
i think this is a problem with physics more than the battery.
Posted by: eliza_turing at March 24, 2003 02:14 AMI just purchased the 12in PB last Friday. I'm upgrading from a 700MHz 12in iBook. So far the upgrade has been fantastic. I haven't noticed any of these problems, and hope I don't... but I will definitely watch your site to see what happens with your situation.
Thanks for the info.
Posted by: Garrett at March 24, 2003 12:55 PMI have had an alternate problem on my new 12 inch pb. My battery meter says that i should be getting 15 hours, then shuts down the computer after about an hour once the meter drops to about 85 percent. It doesnt warn me or anything.
Posted by: jon at March 25, 2003 10:58 AMAfter only a few days of using my new 12" PowerBook my battery life dropped to 1:55 on a full charge. I called up Apple today and they had me reset the Power Manager. As soon as I restarted the computer, the battery time started climbing and topped out at about 3 hours. That's still pretty lame for a battery that's only been used for a few days, though.
Posted by: Tonya at March 27, 2003 03:27 AMI've had exactly the same problem of low battery time with my 12" powerbook, too. And I've just "switched". Surely Apple wouldn't release an OS that damages batteries.
JT
Posted by: JT at March 30, 2003 08:34 AMI've developed basically the same problem as jon (March 25, 10:58AM) , only its with my 15'' powerbook. Also a recent 'switcher' from a debian/PC, and this is extremely frustrating.
Can mike or anyone else tell me more about this "10.2.4 permanent battery damaging issue"? Sounds to me like a not-so-subtle way for apple to scare inexperienced mac-users (like myself) into buying applecare.
SD
Posted by: Sagar Damle at July 21, 2003 05:15 PM
I suspect deep discharging a Li ion battery is not the way to go. As opposed to the NiCad stuff, you should keep the Li ion plugged in all the time.
Posted by: t at March 22, 2003 09:31 PM