« Safari v65 | Main | Grabing screen captures »

March 11, 2003

1Movie 3.2 and Final Cut Express

I've finally had some time to check out the 3.02 upgrade to iMovie, as well as Final Cut Express.
In both cases, I wasn't attempting anything detailed. I just wanted to get a general feel how they worked, especially on my new 12-inch G4 laptop.
With iMovie 3.02, I edited a short little video of a grandson bustin' some moves to Billy Idol. I put it up on a mac.com personal page for you to see. It's nothing fancy. I just FireWired some video from my DV cam into the PowerBook, grabbed an MP3 file for music and tried some titiling and a couple of dissolves. It was very simple, very intuitive and - although I didn't use it in my Dancing Nick video, I really like the Ken Burns still image effect. I think iMovie would be very useable, even among professional news editors out in the field if they needed to quickly cut some raw video into a piece.
With hobbyists, take it on vacation and edit the family fun into QT movies you can e-mail to relatives back home.
The only real downside I found in editing on the 12-inch is memory-related. I only have 384Mb in my laptop. I need more. It took about two minutes to render the MP3 file and about three minutes to export the movie to QuickTime. That would be much faster with more memory, which is something I need to add.
I was very impressed by Final Cut Express, even compared to the full-featured version of Final Cut Pro. FCE handles only DV, but that's about all we use these days, anyway, right? I use Final Cut Pro to edit a technology piece that NBC-TV News Channel affiliates get each week. On the road, Final Cut Express would be a perfectly acceptable alternative.
I was most interested in seeing what Final Cut Express would be like on the tiny 12-inch PowerBook. Truthfully, the small screen size was not that big of a problem. Again, max out the PowerBook on memory if you're planning to use it a lot for video editing.
Bottom line: For most hobbyists, iMovie is probably all you need. For prosumers and professionals, Final Cut Express is a very reasonable alternative to Final Cut Pro which is a very solid (but expensive) professional package that delivers broadcast quality work hard to beat. But you may want to wait before buying Final Cut Pro. Next month at NAB in Las Vegas, Apple is widely-expected to introduce an upgrade to v4.


in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Yes, I agree with your evaluations. I have all three also. Sometimes though, iMovie 3 is confused by larger projects that v2 could handle. Also I found that FCX is faster to to somethings where you do not need all the power of FCP. Color correction, a must with camdoders (I use GL2) is a pain, maybe because my fastest machine is iMac G4, 800Flat

I always enjoy your articles in our home paper (DFP) and followed you on your road to Damascus. I am MacSam of Farmington Hills. ( my basement studio features over 20 Macs from the original 128k.

I read your article on blogs and I was almost conviced to start one. Good work

Posted by: Sam Kawesa at March 12, 2003 05:27 AM

Yes, I agree with your evaluations. I have all three also. Sometimes though, iMovie 3 is confused by larger projects that v2 could handle. Also I found that FCX is faster to do somethings where you do not need all the power of FCP. Color correction, a must with camcoders (I use GL2) is a pain, maybe because my fastest machine is iMac G4, 800Flat

I always enjoy your articles in our home paper (DFP) and followed you on your road to Damascus. I am MacSam of Farmington Hills. ( my basement studio features over 20 Macs from the original 128k.

I read your article on blogs and I was almost conviced to start one. Good work

Posted by: Sam Kawesa at March 12, 2003 05:30 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits