« Web ready for war coverage | Main | J-Lab interactive ideas »

March 06, 2003

Mail's junk mail filtering has turned to junk

Something has happened to the OS X Mail app on my G4. It's like the junk filter suddeny broke. I haven't changed a thing but all this spam that used to be efficiently moved over to the junk folder is now getting through. Honest, I really haven't changed a thing. It still catches a few but it's gone seriously kaflooey. I still have it set on automatic but it's barely doing anything.


in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

From what I have heard lately, that could be due to the fact that spammers are getting alot smarter and work even harder to get around even the best spam filtering software. Hopefully when the update to Mail comes out, Apple will address this issue.

Otherwise, check the knowledge base at Apple or go for an internet search for others like yourself who are experiencing a similar problem.

Posted by: Jason Smith at March 7, 2003 04:46 AM

I'd advise switching back to "training" status for a few days; I use SpamSieve w/Entourage X, and it's still doing an excellent job, but it, too, has started to slip over the past couple of weeks.

It's a never-ending battle; sounds like the spammers are starting to figure out a few ways around the current bayselian (sp?) filtering...but I'm sure updates are on the way from both Apple & SpamSieve...

Posted by: Charles Gaba at March 7, 2003 04:53 AM

There is also another feature I recently discovered under Mail where when you get a spam mail.....select the message(s), click on "Bounce to Sender" and if the spammer has a usable email addy (which usually doesn't happen, but it's worth a shot), it will appear to them that your email address is invalid and may prompt them to remove you eventually from their spam list. It's worth a shot if the Junk Mail Filter keeps giving you problems.

Posted by: Jason Smith at March 7, 2003 04:54 AM

I'm pretty sure the only difference between training and automatic is whether it sends mail to the junk folder. I think it still continues to learn when you mark something in your inbox as junk. It just doesn't leave all the junk messages in your inbox for you to see constantly.

Posted by: Mason at March 7, 2003 10:32 AM

I had this same experience with Mail a couple of months ago. What I did was to start my spam filtering over from scratch. The way you can do this is to go into ~/Library/Mail and throw out the file called LSMMap, which is where Mail stores what it's learned about how to filter spam. Your filter will probably start out slow right after throwing out the file, but it will learn quickly, and my spam filter is a lot better now that I've started over.

Posted by: Brian Webster at March 7, 2003 10:35 AM

Mike, do not use bounce. It will not work. When will people learn this? Bounce will send the email back to the *fake* email address the spammer used. Bounce will not be able send it back to the spammer. Don't use bounce to fight spam. It just doesn't work.

Posted by: Tom at March 7, 2003 11:13 AM

Yep, mine has been missing a few as well.

Tips to help fight spam:

Use Bcc header when sending or forwarding to many people, OR

Use Address Book groups and under Mail's preferences > composing > Addressing, turn off "When sending to a group, show all member addresses"

Be courteous and remove the clutter of past recipients in the body of the email, when forwarding jokes, news etc.

Ask your friends and colleagues and friends to use Bcc, groups and "undisclosed recipient" (if using Outlook for Windows. -- not sure how this is done)

Set up a web email address and use only that one for internet correspondence (news, accounts, logins etc.) Some sites will not let you use a web email, and require a "legitimate POP account". If this is the case don't sign up with them unless you are sure they respect your privacy.

Check rigorously for Opt-in and Opt-out check-boxes or written info about such things, on all web sites you sign up with. If they don't offer such info, then write them with your web email, or by post (if you really want their service) to ask them to include that feature on their web site. Otherwise don't sign on with them.

Any other tips I've missed?

Posted by: Andrew at March 7, 2003 12:01 PM

Undoubtedly Apple needs to improve their "junk" feature of the Mail Program, and like Jason Smith mentioned before, hopefully this will be fixed in upcoming updates for Jaguar. It's gotten to be a big problem now. I must get 15-20 junk messages a day thru the Mail program. It's ridiculous!!!

Posted by: Dr_Octagon at March 7, 2003 12:21 PM

I've had to reset the junk mail feature twice over the past six months or so due to it suddenly letting a lot of junk mail through after performing admirably for a while. But when it's working, it only lets through 5-10 junk emails a day out of the 200-300 I receive...far better than anything else I've tried!

Posted by: Craig at March 7, 2003 12:29 PM

I can't blame Apple for any spam I receive only the lowly scum of the earth SPAMMERS!!

Apple has done their part by including the filering and I think all-in-all it's doing a good job. Sure, it can be improved - but when fighting something like spam it would need to be continually improved to keep pace.

I have noticed a slow down when I switch from training to automatic modes. It seems to take a bit too long to move the junk mail out of the in-bin and I get the spinning ball for about 30 seconds.

I think the best option is to jail the spammers. Make it illegal along with all other forms of annoying and harrassing marketing (telemarketing, spam, junk snail mail, door-to-door soliciters, web banners). There is plenty of room to advertise on TV or Radio these days. We should allow people to have their own private services (which WE PAY FOR) not to be bombarded by harrassing intruders.

How rude is it when I get a telemarketing call on my cell phone (which I pay for by the minute) or when I have to spend my time to weed through junk mail to make sure I receive the email I should be getting (personal and business) without worry of deleting something important. I pay for my ISP and my email mailbox - I have the right not to have these spaces trespassed upon.

The same goes for the mailbox at my house. That is my mailbox which I pay for and my taxes pay for.. STOP putting weekly circulars in my mail!! I'm tired of sifting through wasted trees (paper) to find my billing statements.

Why we put up with this in such a great country is unknown to me. We need to SCREAM louder because obviously the politicians can't hear us and even when they do it takes them five years and a day to start to do something about it.

Spam is really not a complicated problem (it really isn't) the first thing that needs to be done is to make it illegal (plain and simple). Than focus on ways of tracking the abusers of the law. You spam, you go to jail.

Sorry for the explosion but it's really up to us, everyone... Certainly not Apple or other companies to stop spam.

I could go on for hours on this topic. Sorry for going so far off topic.

Cheers!

Posted by: Rache at March 7, 2003 12:47 PM

i've just started having this problem, and found this site while scrounging the web for clues. i remember noting an instruction when i set up my filtering to leave, basically, "not too few, but not too many" messages in the "junk mail" folder, for proper operation. but with no guidelines as to what either amount might consist of. it seemed to work pretty well for awhile, but now, with around 2,500 spams in the trap it isn't. i'm going to try just deleting down to about 500 or so, without wiping out or removing anything else, and see how that works. i'll repost when i see some results.

Posted by: glenn at March 17, 2003 02:10 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits