
Intuit has updated its powerful financial and accounting software with QuickBooks 5.0 for Mac - the first one available for the Mac OS X operating system. It's so full-featured that Apple is now bundling the $179 standard version free with the sale of some of it's new PowerBook laptops.
Previous Mac editions of the software seemed like limp versions of the Windows offering ported over to the Mac platform. But version 5.0 was totally redesigned to allow small business owners to track time, do estimates and manage the books with more customizable forms and specific report printing.
I really, really like it.
But there's a near fatal flaw in my estimation.
The Mac and PC files can't talk to each other. With most accountants using PC's, files made on a Mac aren't going to do you much good when it's time to have your taxes prepared. Unless you don't mind spending a couple hundred extra bucks having the files converted by a third-party service company.
Well, they can talk but only one way: Mac>Windows.
http://www.quickbooks.com/support/faqs/qbm5/301789.html
One can export a Mac .qbb file to Windows, but it can't be re-read in the Mac version. If the file is altered on the Windows side, those changes must be HAND entered into the Mac file (unless there's some third party solution of which I'm unaware.).
Intuit can be so inane.
Posted by: scotti at March 5, 2003 10:18 AMMike--
I think THIS is what you're looking for:
http://www.myob.com/us/index.htm
http://www.myob.com/us/promo/twitcher/rebate.htm
For what it's worth, I'm in the same situation--I use QuickBooks 2000 Pro via Virtual PC, and was hoping that QB 5 for OS X would free me of Windows...except for this STUPID, STUPID oversight (or was it deliberate?).
Fortunately, I don't use QB for much more than the basic register, so it's a minor issue for me.
MYOB's AccountEdge supposedly includes 100% cross-platform compatibility & conversion to/from both the Windows & Mac versions of QuickBooks. Plus, in a VERY smart move, they include *two* copies of the software--one for you, one for your accountant. I haven't used it myself yet, but it's gotten rave reviews & looks very promising.
Posted by: Charles Gaba at March 5, 2003 10:20 AMI asked the Intuit reps about the X-platform compatibility issue at Macworld SF in January. They said that since the two versions (Mac/Win) do not have feature parity, then it is not surprising that the files cannot go back and forth very easily. While I think this ia a strange way to market a product (having 2 different feature sets) it does help explain the problem.
It also means that it is not easily fixed unless they decide to make comparable versions for both platforms.
Posted by: travelscott at March 5, 2003 11:18 AMBeside the cross-platform issue, there is one other major problem. It won't network. There is no multiuser option. This has existed for Windows for several years. Iy makes it useless in a business where more than one person might generate an invoice or effect the inventory from a different computer. Now THAT is a an "OVERSIGHT". Intuit thinks Mac users are idiots and is basically trying to sell them the same old QuickBooks in an OsX shell. There are no real improvements.
Posted by: johnO at March 5, 2003 11:48 AMI bought Quickbooks so I could get away from Quicken Home and Business under Virtual PC. What a disappointment! I was amazed that Quickbooks can't send electronic payments or download transactions from my bank (and importing a QIF file is a poor substitute). I got my money back. I guess I'll be using Virtual PC for the forseeable future.
Posted by: J foster at March 5, 2003 12:19 PMAnother piece of B.S.--they claim one of the wonderful "innovations" in QB OS X is that you can "save reports as PDFs".
Of course, in OS X you can do this with ANY file, whether text, graphic, etc...it has absolutely ZERO to do with Intuit/QB.
Posted by: Charles Gaba at March 5, 2003 01:36 PMI cna only speak for myself, but I'm happy as hell that Intuit came out with a new version of QB. I've been using 4.0 Pro for the last however many years, and it was the last major program that I was using in classic. QB 5.0 is great for me. While it doesn't contain every upgrade I was hoping for, it is a major improvement over 4.0. In fact, the ability to run it natively in X is worth the $180 to me. Plus the fact that they will be doing yearly updates to the software and I'm happy. I imigine that a lot of the features that we are all crying for, including multi-user capabilities, will be released down the road in future versions. Last time they released an update (4.0) it has so few improvements over 3.0 that I didn't bother switching, and I'm sure most other users didn't either, which is probably part of the reason Intuit decided to exit the Mac Biz software biz. Here's looking forward to the future,
Posted by: Mark at March 5, 2003 04:35 PMHave been running virtualpc to enable Quickbooks. My accountant uses QB for windows (of course). I was so looking forward to being free of VPC, and giving my administrator a fast interface (QB on VPC is painfully slow).
I shelled out $300 for the pro version, plus $300 for deluxe 24/7 support. When I found out that I cant import our two years of QBwindows data, and can't "save as" QBwindows to send back to our accountant, I also returned the whole deal.
The CEO of intuit was on the board of Apple. What gives? Does Jobs care? Can I get my accountant to try MYOB (doubt it).
Posted by: Daniel at March 5, 2003 06:39 PMIn Canada ... last week a third party focus group survey to Mac users re upgrading to qb from M.Y.O.B ... a response - A question about why you haven't - or will you be switching yada yada ...the radio button checked was "NO" with this small rant.
"Because of the way the initial product offering was put out with a calous disregard for MYOB users and the ending of their payroll year. As a matter of business civility it would have been appropriate for the management to recognize how small business has to approach their year end accounting and payroll year ends. Imagine dumping us into a new payroll year with no options, other than to purchase new software, and learn it and retrain staff... at no small expense. All they had to do was furnish one payroll update with the 03 tax tables to tide us over and give us a chance to adjust and switch gracefully and some may have. Instead the MYOB users got together and made up out own tax tables...PC and MAC versions...shareware! We may not get many product updates but we will be able to use our software for many years to come. Or at least take our time to choose other viable alternatives. Intuit has alienated many users who will not use their products in the future.
It has been my experience that this company is so market oriented as to not worry about small market segments and business cycles. It appears that they are corporate centric and profit motivated with disregard for Mac users & MYOB converts. They want to take control of my business functions(payroll) and want me to pay for it. Not a concept that I can live with. I personally will never use their products. There are other players in this market who are a lot more user friendly, appreciate my money, my support payments, my product evangelicalism (free salesman), and my loyalty.
Intuit will not get the chance to test any of the above."
On top of that missing "feature" you can't customize the layout of your invoices like you can in the windows version. This MAJORLY sucks for a design shop like mine.
Posted by: noel at March 6, 2003 09:39 AMAn Intuit rep admitted to me that the "new" Quickbooks for Mac 5.0 is the equivalent of - TA-DA! - Quickbooks for Windows 99 Basic. I read an interview with a Mac rep on just how "committed" - Ha-Ha! Intuit is to its Mac customers. I think total abandonment was more honest than a braindead product release that lacks conversions. MYOB is able to do the conversions, albeit with only yearend figures and a huge "historical adjustment" transaction so that you can never get at any old data. Because of that, we had to stick with 2002 Pro on Virtual PC v.6. Slower and shakier than a Hawaiian at the North Pole. Anyone remember when there was actual competition in accounting software?.
Posted by: Jim at March 11, 2003 04:16 PMI, too, am totally disappointed in the new Mac 5.0. I bought it so that my accountant could open my files. They had progressed so far in PC versions that they no longer could open my 4.0 QuickBook backups.
And frankly, I don't see anything new except that it's prettier on-screen. I DO see that I can't print invoices easily anymore. I might have 6 goes at it until all the type comes out clear (otherwise, it haphazardly makes it into a garbled mess). Changing the PPD and/or driver does not work. Rules now come out like 1-point (FAT and dark) to which Intuit says that's all we can do (even though, with 4.0, they came out fine).
I agree with the guy who runs a design shop. It's TOTALLY embarrassing.
Intuit's online "support" tends to give you completely misleading information or skip a subject altogether. Does anyone know where, online, I can find other Mac QuickBook users?
I also cannot believe, at this late date, that you can't even run a report on a single customer, you can only run a report on ALL you customers and then find them. AND I can't believe that invoices, etc., look nothing on screen like they print on a laser printer.
Posted by: Diane at March 15, 2003 06:17 PMI was taken in by the folks at Intuit just like everyone else on this page. I was at my accountant's yesterday and ran into the same problems everyone else has been talking about with Quickbooks and it's incompatability with the Windows version accountants use. I called Intuit and was formally told that my only option was to buy the Quickbooks for Windows version so that I could use an accountant for my business taxes.
I do not believe this is any way for Intuit to take care of a flaw they built into the software they say is a great improvement over the old version 4.0.
I support other companies and thier computer systems which are either Macintosh or Windows. So I am dealing in cross platform issues every day and there is usually a simple solution for every issue. I do not even run Virtual PC on my PowerBook now since 99% of the work I do can be done from the Mac as is. I use cross platform backup software to backup and restore any Macintosh or Windows computer and I do this all from the Mac.
I have all of my data on my Macintosh because I prefer the platform to Windows and also because of my last Windows computer's hard drive crashed and the data was gone. Thankfully I had the information on my Mac in Virtual PC and was able to recover almost all of my data.
I am totally fed up with Intuit and feel that I have no other alternative but re-entering all of my data into MYOB and having my accountant work with the accountant version of MYOB.
I cannot tell you how angry I am at having taken the advice of my accountant and purchased Quickbooks for Mac and then to have this problem rear it's ugly head.
I believe that there is a good case for a class action lawsuit against Intuit for putting out a product that, their own accounting program which is only in Windows, cannot work with the Macintosh files and return them in working order to the Macintosh.
Posted by: Sean at April 24, 2003 08:46 AMHas anyone used their Quickbooks 5.0 for payroll. I am taking a pc QB class because a Mac version is not available. I noticed that the payroll on PC version is not included on the Mac version and they use Atrix software instead. How can there be compatibility and support if it is completely different?
This makes me very frustrated as I was getting ready to change from old MYOB to QB 5.0 and now I'm seeing that it may be the wrong decision. We have already invested the money on the QB 5.0. Does Amazon.com offer software returns?
Posted by: Sara at April 25, 2003 07:07 PMConverting from 4.0 to multiuser 2003 for PC
don't want to leave mac but I have a business to run and mac is now for kids ( newest products are all muisic or video deals)
However Intuit still sucks.... as i have 40meg of data in mac 4.0 that I cant convert to the pc version without first buing a support pacage from QB that might solve the problem or paying them an extra $700 to convert my data for me in two weeks.
I'm running Quickbooks Pro 2003 on a Windows OS, and I hit this site while searching for "alternatives to quickbooks". Does that say enough? It's inflexible (alphabetical ordering in 'items' lists, etc. is MANDATORY!), poorly documented (just try searching the help file! The book they provide could be entitle "Pointing and Clicking for Dummies, Book 1"), non-user-friendly (try deleting a statement charge) and overassuming (Payroll).
Currently, I'm trying to teach my father how to use it, while setting up his electrical contracting business. It's not a lot of fun...
I'm looking into open-source software right now, and if I find anything with potential, I'll get back to this list.
Posted by: Catherine at May 8, 2003 02:14 PMWe are having major problems with MAC 5.0 and Attrix software. It locks up everytime we try to launch it. Can anyone help. We have tried the Attrix support and given the fact that G4 has compatability issues but our mac is a g3. We have restarted the PC numerous times to no avail.
Al
Is there a way to do a statement of Cash Flows on Macintosh Quickbooks? I can only find a cash flow forcast option? Help!! Thanks!
Posted by: Sarah at May 28, 2003 02:38 PMIn response to Al's comments about Aatrix Payroll software. It is the worst I have ever used! Ours locks up if we use the tab key to move from fiield to field....we have to click on each field. The checks have to be printed individually because payroll reports are garbled if we print check from the print que. I would give anything ot find a good payroll software for Mac that is compatible with Quick Books. I love the Quick Books accounting program and was very disappointed when they terminated the Mac payroll module. Al, are you trying to launch for an icon or the Aatrix f folder?
Posted by: LEE OBRYAN at June 4, 2003 03:10 PMI just got off the phone after calling "Tech support" for the new quickbooks 5.0. I have a very real problem, after just upgrading from 4.0 where the problem didn't exist: I cannot get mailing labels to print out! The only options I was given were costly support options: $75 one time fee for the first 20 minutes or worse, $175 plan for some period of time of unlimited calls. NOTHING for free to a new installer!! When I told the techie this was unlike any software I've dealt with before, and that they should at least offer a week of free set-up related support, the guy says, "Well, if we sold our software for $3000, maybe we could offer this." Lame. Really lame.
If I can't get this fixed for free, I'll be sending it back. No friends at Intuit, that's plain.
After my upgrade from Quickbooks 4.0 to 5.0, relinking Aatrix's payroll information back to Quickbooks is IMPOSSIBLE. Obviously phoning QB's tech support is an exercise in Expensive Futility, and both Intuit and Aatrix play "pass the buck" - neither company taking responsibility for their product's performance - although they PROMOTE & SELL Mac users this combination as the ultimate in business software.
Posted by: Joe at July 9, 2003 12:56 PM
Are you kiding? This product was NOT totally redesigned, just carbonized and 2-3 (small) new features were added.
In essence, it is a $180 upgrade to a 7 year old product with nothing more than window dressing added, and it doesn't do windows!
None of the features that were requested by this user were added and I switched to MYOB b/c they seemed to care about the Mac and my business.
T
Posted by: Tman at March 5, 2003 10:15 AM