
My Detroit Free Press column today is about Microsoft's MovieMaker 2 and Apple's iMovie 3. Both of these products have recently been updated and -- although you'll find lots of sniping and whining about the way they work and don't work on the active video editing discussion forums on the Web -- trust me, both are absolutely terrific products for the average user to learn editing.
For people who have never before tried video editing, these apps - both free - are amazingly full-featured and powerful. Apple's iMovie 3 bests MovieMaker 2 in the way it is integrated with other Apple multimedia applications like iPhoto, for handling digital still pictures; iTunes, for editing and managing music; and iDVD, the standard DVD-burning software that comes with Apple?s OS X operating system.
With the Microsoft product, you need third party software to burn off your projects to DVD. But MovieMaker 2 has more transitions and titles than iMovie.
Nitpicking aside, I am amazed at how powerful and easy to use both of these products are. Video editing software is opening up a whole new way to use our computers that I think will soon become one of America?s most popular pastimes.
Again, these products are for average users or beginners in video editing. I'll be looking at more advanced video editing apps for both platforms later.
Apple only lists the cameras that have been tested to be compatible with the various applications. If yours is not there it doesn't mean that it won't work. It only means that it has not been tested. If the Camera manufacturers have followed the DV spec then the cameras should work. If they try to tweak the DV spec for their own purposes they take a risk that it won't work. The fault lays with the Camera manufactures not Apple or for that matter Adobe or microsoft. I have used both systems. iLife from Apple is far superior. Thanks!
Posted by: Brad Caldwell at March 4, 2003 01:38 PMAny digital video camera that doesn't work with a mac isn't worth a penny. Macs are THE standard in the video & film profession and firewire is the reason DV is a viable format. With the exception of odd proprietary formats like the Sony MicroMV Mpeg2 tapes, almost every DV format camera with firewire should work with a mac beautifully. If not, shame on the manufacturer for religating their product to useless toy status.
Posted by: John Papola at March 5, 2003 12:52 AMFor an honest, detailed comparison of Movie Maker & iMovie see http://www.webmastermac.com/macintosh/whymac/xvsxp/applications_video.shtml
Posted by: missmolly at March 5, 2003 01:35 PMTheres no moola in Mac, That's why.
When the market is 80% pc and pc is moving in on video and multimedia with programs like Vegas Video and GigaStudio (audio).
If I made new equip I'd make only for pc too cause of marketing reasons. Anyone who chooses not to gambles their future.
Posted by: gene at March 7, 2003 11:12 PMWell does the Panasonic PV-DV953 work with i-movie 3 or not? I have researched DV cameras for weeks and have decided that I want this one, but if it doesn't work with Mac then it's usless to me.
Todd
Just bought a PV-DV953 and it works fine in iMovie 3 on a Mac running in Mac OSX. Make sure everything is on and pluged in before you even start your Mac and you won't have any problems. Works in OS 9 as well. I've never been concerned with DV cameras and the compatibilty with iMovie. The DV953 is the second camera that is not supposed to work with iMovie, my first one was one of Sony's first DV video camera (DCR-TRV310) and it's still compatible.
Posted by: Troy at August 10, 2003 01:31 AMPlease sign the petition at http://www.petitiononline.com/osxmicmv/ requesting that Sony add support for MicroMV on the Mac.
Posted by: Daniel Guinan at November 9, 2003 12:15 AMHelp! Can the JVC GR-D70u Digital Video Camera work with Mac OS X (iMovie)? The product box says it works with 9.0.04 to 9.2.2 but excludes Mac OS X and Max OS X Classic. Has anyone actually tried it out? This is a Christmas present and I need to know!
Posted by: miriam at December 24, 2003 08:28 PMi've been editing in premier pro with footage from my dv953 no prob.
Posted by: mc at January 2, 2004 11:45 PM
You neglected to mention in your column today that many digital cameras do not work well or even at all with iMovie or even other more advanced editing programs for the Mac. This is even true for Windows. For example, an examination of the Adobe Premiere site reveals many cameras that are only rated as "Conditional support" with such problems as "Assemble editing is unreliable" and "Batch capture fails under Windows ME". Apple's iMovie and Final Cut Express sites list only some cameras that are compatible. I just received the following E mail from Panasonic in response to my inquiry about the compatibility of their new PV-DV953 model with a Mac running iMovie, Adobe Premiere or Final Cut Express -
Re:
Thank you for your inquiry. We regret to inform you that the PV-DV953 is
not designed to work with a Macintosh computer or any of the software
listed in your inquiry.
Thank You,
Panasonic Consumer Support
I guess one has to look carefully at these sites before buying a camera.
Posted by: Leonard Malkin at March 4, 2003 12:44 PM