
Woke up the morning, downloaded my e-mail and checked a couple news sites for the latest sitrep only to suddenly lose my Internet connection. After a couple of reboots and modem resets I called my provider, Comcast. The early Sunday morning tech rep was short on personality but long on patience as we worked through several scenarios. Nothing.
I hung up and puzzled a bit. All of the modem lights were glowing their proper green. Then I looked at the Aiport Extreme base staion. The cable broadband connection plugs straight into the bas station, with a cable from there to the router and other machines. I hit the reset button on Airport Extreme. Still no connection. I then unplugged the LAN cable, and then the broadband cable itself. Still nothing.
Then I pulled the power and restarted it. Bingo. Connection restored. What happened, or why... I haven't a clue.
I did some Internet snooping and noticed that Apple posted a firmware upgrade last week for AE base stations. Maybe that was it. I downloaded it and all now appears to be well. In fact, I swear the connection is better. I'm getting a stronger signal strength reading today. It's "full scale," with all four strength bars showing instead of the three I used to get from the same living room seat in front of the fireplace where I'm now writing.
Anybody know more about AE and the firmware patch? Just what did it fix?
I can tell you one reason it might have gone down. My network access the internet through an airport connected to an ADSL modem.
I have a fairly vanilla connection, so...no static IP, fast upload speeds, etc. I believe that every once in a while the dsl providers have to do one of two things.
1. Work on their servers which will bring down the connection.
2. Cycle their DHCP servers which will mean your DHCP lease could end at the wrong time.
That's my take on the whole thing anyway....
Posted by: Walker at March 2, 2003 10:12 PMWhat you guys may be suffering from is that most DSL connections have an imposed uptime. At earthlink, last time I checked, it was between 10 and 14 days. After that, depending on your router, you may or may not get a new leased connection. You can often reconnect via the web interface of your router or simply repowering your router which releases the DHCP connection for the max time that your DSL provider limits.
Posted by: George Papanicolaou at March 3, 2003 09:08 AM*nod*
I have experienced exactly one (1) unexplainable outage to date. I've had my AEBS up for about 1.5 weeks now. The problem I had may be un-related to the ones mentioned above, but the symptoms are the same: complete loss of routing.
My setup is different in that the AEBS does not act as a dhcp client - dhcp service is not offered by my ISP. The AEBS is statically addressed, and provides DHCP / NAT for both wired and wireless clients on my network. I was right in the middle of a quake3 match when the AEBS just up and stopped passing traffic. The external ethernet interface and the wireless interface was still reachable via ICMP, but no traffic was being passed between them (nor was it being passed from the lan ether to the wan ether). I was running the latest firmware (5.03) at the time, also.
In any case, it's still a new product, so I kinda expect wackiness for a little while.... but this is v3, so it should be getting pretty tight. I can deal with minor problems, like the fact that I can't seem to use the Airport Admin Utility to manage the AEBS after a reset (why do I have to reset it? because of an error while trying to "read the configuration") if my workstation isn't set for DHCP (this is documented). However, the fact that I can't use the Admin utility after a reset even if my workstaition IS set for DHCP... well, that's just a bug. Instead I have to use the setup utility.... anyway, I'm sure it'll get better.
-Andre
Posted by: Andre LaBranche at March 3, 2003 04:52 PMThere is a good article at
http://powerpage.org/story.lasso?newsID=8941
that dicusses this problem with cable modems and AirPort Base Stations. Basicly the Cable system doesn't like the MAC address it gets from the Base Station.
I use a Linksys router to share my internet access, which my Base Station plugs into and never have this problem.
Posted by: Stephen Ludwig at March 3, 2003 08:23 PMHey Mike! I just got a dual 1.25 (Firewire 800 Model) and an Airport Extreme card. I am using the last generation (non-extreme white) base station and I've had some problems too... Sometimes my Mac sees the airport signal, but I can't issue a command to connect to the internet. It's ticking me off... There is no new update for older base stations either...
I'm a little upset because now I think I need to buy an Airport Extreme base station... It won't be that good of an investment because I can only get 1.5 Mbps ADSL where I live... I won't see a huge speed difference. So much for backwards compatibility? Oh, well...
What really sucks is that I live in Japan now and Apple stuff is super expensive here.
Posted by: jeff at March 3, 2003 09:53 PMWow, I didn't realize people where having problems with the Apple Airport stuff. I use Comcast for my internet connection, and use a linksys cable modem router which provides my DHCP addresses in my house.I had the original Airport Base station (purchased in June of 2001) and I have recently (beginning of Feb 2003) upgraded to the Airport Extreme and a 12" G4. I have never seen the problems that you are describing. My wife uses an IBM laptop with a linksys wireless card, and I also have a Dell hard wired into my router...Even when my cable goes out, my Airport has continued to work. I have gone months without rebooting my base station or resetting my cable router and/or modem. Most times that I lose my ability to connect to the internet the problem is with Comcast and not inside my house.
I sent my original Airport base station and my old 12" iBook to Florida for my Mother-in-law. She is having an issue with the base station always attempting to dial out (her internet connection is through AOL and the modem on the base station)...it doesn't stop her from connecting, but it is a pain due to it not stopping trying to connect after she is done. Does anyone know what needs to be done to stop the constant dialing (other than disconnecting the modem cable)???
Posted by: Bruce McPhee at March 4, 2003 04:50 PMJust finished writing an article where we were having major range problems with the base station. Apple was working very hard with us on getting our results to match theirs. 12 hours before my deadline, Apple alerted me to a just-released firmware update. Like magic, it solved all of our range-related problems, and we went from getting 22Mbps at a maximum of 2 feet from the base to getting 22Mbps at 30 feet. So the firmware update is, most definitely, a good thing.
Check http://www.macobserver.com/article/2003/02/26.12.shtml for more details.
-Dave
Posted by: Dave Hamilton at March 5, 2003 10:14 AMOK - here's the definitive solution:
Go buy an Ethernet Broadband Router and run your cable modem or ADSL into it and your PC and Aiport out of it. I've been fucking with the Airport Extreme for weeks trying to get it to work with my PC and this fixed it instantly. The D-Link DI-604 is a uniquely Mac AND PC friendly router - buy it. The Setup Wizard offers to automatically copy the address and everything!
The problem with running a PC out of the Airport Ethernet seems to be that Macs and PCs have conflicting IP addresses (Surprize!). Why Apple can't figure this out - or at least post some understandable tech support on their site is beyond me.
Do this and your Airport is in business!
www.fez.com
Posted by: DJ Fez at April 19, 2003 04:30 PM
Hi, Mike
Just wanted to let you know I have the same thing happen every now and then maybe a couple times a month. my setup is a D-link wireless router connected to my new 12" Powerbook G4 wireless, it is also connected to my Powermac G4 and also 3 PC's via RJ45. When it happens everything looks to be in order but I have no connection to the internet. Its always the same fix, I just unplug the cable modem power and plug it back in ,then everything syncs back up and im back up and surfin. Im on Time Warner Cable in Indianapolis. Im not sure what the problem is because ive had different cable modems and routers in the past and have always had this problem. Ive learned to just except it since it only happens rarely ,but I would love to have a permanet fix.
Posted by: Rob Perkins at March 2, 2003 01:53 PM