« New Palm/Phone combo to be expensive | Main | Making a PC look like a Mac »

February 25, 2003

iMovie 3 problems

I'm hearing a lot about problems with iMovie 3. I have only had a chance to spot test it and it did fine in cutting a two minute piece. I've been planning to go back and compare it to the new Windows XP Movie Maker app but a bunch of reader e-mail and a growing number of negative stories like this have prompted me to check this out a bit more. Dropped frames, frequent crashes, out of sync sound and difficulties with longer edits (over 15-20 minutes) seem to be common complaints. These problems sound more like something you'd encounter in a Windows program, doesn't it? Judging from the user feedback, iMovie 3 seems like it is not quite ready for prime time. I'll work with it over the next week or so and let you know.


in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Don't bother trying the new Windows Movie Maker because it has all of those problems plus more. Its even worse when they force you to install it and the install alone crashes your computer.

Posted by: andy at February 25, 2003 09:25 AM

Yeah, iMovie may be having problems but Windows Movie Muker, er, Maker, is a lot worse.

Better yet, through down the guantlet and get FCPro of FCExpress and stop wasting time with the amateur programs.

Posted by: joshua at February 25, 2003 10:29 AM

I've made 3 projects with iMovie 3.0 and have only experienced 1 problem and that was with centered text and even that is easily corrected. The reason I left windows/pc's was the inferior movie/photo/music progs that would not work for me. Macs just work.

Posted by: Benny at February 25, 2003 12:08 PM

I'm a big user of Final Cut Pro. In fact, I edit my weekly NBC-TV segment "High Tech Talk" on my G4 with FCP... It goes out every week to all 215 NBC affiliates.
I haven't had a chance yet to put Final Cut Express through the paces but FCP is simply an awesome program.

Posted by: Mac Mike at February 25, 2003 01:43 PM

My understanding is that most of the issues people are having with iMovie 3 have to do with the install mucking around with some file permission settings; after installing *any* major-app/OS upgrade in OS X, the first thing you should do is launch Disk Utility, go to First Aid and Repair Disk Permissions (this can be done on any volume, *including* the one you're booted off of). Fixing the disk permissions should clear up most of the problems people have been reporting.

Still, I'm sure that a 3.1 update is on the way...

Posted by: Charles Gaba at February 25, 2003 07:10 PM

The problems with imove 3 are deeper than permission settings, I'm afraid. I was really looking forward to the whole iLife upgrade, and then couldn't believe how the whole suite seemed to bring my loaded G4 to a halt. I even did a fresh install of OSX.2.4 on a new freshly formatted and optimized hard drive -- and installed no other programs but iLife -- and it still was crash prone and sluggish on even the most basic editing tasks.

It is too bad -- because I simply love my macs -- and use imovie quite a bit. So, I'm back to imove 2. I did buy Final Cut Express -- but haven't had much time to get into it. I sure hope 3.1 addresses these issues -- because what has always set apple apart was STABILITY. This is greatly lacking with iLife. What bothers me more is that Apple simply won't tell us when they plan to fix it.

I have gotten all kinds of family and friends to "switch" -- but I'm afraid I have lost a few over iLife.

Other than this -- my total mac experience has been incredibly positive. I have been somewhat paralleling PC now Mac-Mike -- re-experiencing Macs after several years PC frustration. I use PC's at the law office all day -- and look forward to getting on my Mac at home each evening -- it is like pulling a sports car out of the garage after driving trash truck all day.

Keep up the insightful essays Mike.

Posted by: Sean O'Bryan at February 25, 2003 07:47 PM

Thanks Sean...
using a mac is " is like pulling a sports car out of the garage after driving trash truck all day."
Best line I've heard yet on THE difference.

Posted by: Mac Mike at February 25, 2003 10:16 PM

I had a problem with iDVD3. I would burn a DVD disk on my PowerBook using iDVD3, and it would play well on my PowerBook, but it wouldn't play on my G3 iMac. Some disks would play, others would freeze and stop, others wouldn't even load into the G3 iMac. I tried playing them on my neighbor's G3 iMac, and I had the same problems. I had never had problems with disks I made with using iDVD2. It seems that I have solved the problem, and I can now make very stable DVD disks, with nice chapters, using iDVD3. What I did that seems to have worked (I'll keep my fingers crossed) is I reinstalled my operating system OS X, then I trashed iDVD, iMovie, iTunes, iPhotos. I emptied the trash, and then I loaded iLife. I have now burned some DVDs which work perfectly on my iMac G3. This makes me confident that they will play on most DVD players. I can jump from chapter to chapter, freeze the picture, unfreeze the picture, everything seems to work well. There might be some sort of conflict between the old iDVD, iMovie, and the new iLife stuff.

Posted by: Robert Menefee at March 6, 2003 10:08 PM

I'm having problems transferring to my digital camera. Everything looks and sound good on the computer; however, upon transferring audio prior to a transition is pushed back a second and a half. All titles lower the audio over that section. Everthing else that is transferred is in sync. somebody help.... I've tried everything from record through to camera to deleting all transitions and titles from the program. I like imovie because it's easy to work and produce a weekly show on it. I'm thinking it's time to switch to Final Cut Pro.

Posted by: Willie "the Kid" Cantu at March 6, 2003 11:00 PM

I get about 30 to 40 seconds between crashes. It makes editing a real pain. I have tried everything Apple suggested including 2 new logic boards, new hard drive and nothing helps I am now about to trash the entire program.

Posted by: Michael at April 15, 2003 06:36 PM

Make the Imovie work with ALL old DV-cameras. I have a Panasonic NVDA1 ... No connection.- suckie suckie

Posted by: Imov at April 16, 2003 06:08 PM

I am having incredibly bizarre problems with FCE. It loads the title screen, and then about 5-10 seconds later, the thing completely crashes, I'm running OS 10.2.5.

I tried creating another user, re-installing FCE. Same exact thing happens.

It's quite annoying.

Posted by: Alex at April 25, 2003 12:23 AM

hi all you in here!

ive read your articles. as youn seem to have quite a lot experience with imovie i would like to pone a question:

my problem is, that i cann not import a .mopv file. its not even visible if i open the direcory with imovie. Uff! has anyone a hint or a solution??

arianna :-)

Posted by: arianna at April 25, 2003 04:56 AM

AUTHOR: !! arianna !!
EMAIL: [email protected]
IP: 195.245.225.31
URL:
DATE: 04/25/2003 04:57:42 AM
AUTHOR: !! arianna !!
EMAIL: [email protected]
IP: 195.245.225.31
URL:
DATE: 04/25/2003 04:57:42 AM

Posted by: !! arianna !! at April 25, 2003 04:57 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits