« Old programming language has defenders | Main | Stop it already with terror hysteria »

February 24, 2003

Apple PIM apps are weak

Apple needs to better integrate its PIM applications - iCal, Mail and Address. I really like all three. I just wish they were bundled. I miss the way Outlook for Windows shows all three apps and data from them in a single window. Entourage doesn't do as good a job but still makes them more accessible than the Apple apps.
I'm missing appointments or being surprised by them because they are not always in front of me like Outlook kept them.
Maybe Apple will soon upgrade its apps? Or maybe I should look for a third-party solution. The key for me, though, is it has to synch with my Palm Tungsten T.


in Software | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I hope Apple keep all these application separate.

Personally I hate having to open one big application to look at an address or my calendar, having separate application that talk to each other is so much better imho.

Look at the integration of the AddressBook in Safari, it look's promising for future integration between applications.

Posted by: Stephane at February 24, 2003 12:49 PM

> I hope Apple keep all these application separate.

(Nod)

I agree. I don't want a bloated warthog of an App filling up my screen to display contacts and meetings...

MacMike, if your having problems reminding yourself about your appointments, run iCal in the background by default...

Posted by: CarbonCopy at February 24, 2003 01:49 PM

I see more some itegration like the new iApps (iTunes, iMovie) automatical adding of brithdays from addressbook, automatical linking of addressbook entries to iCal events

Posted by: jacco at February 24, 2003 01:59 PM

I'm running Now Up-to-Date and Contact for OS X. I keep my calendar configured to occupy 2/3 of the screen and contacts the other third. It's a nice solution. Much more feature rich that Apple's products and still separate apps.

Posted by: David Phillips at February 24, 2003 02:13 PM

I like the Mac PIM apps so far. I only just started using them a few weeks ago and I've yet to have any real problems with them (though some of the interface elements leave a little to be desired - I thought Apple made this). What I would really like to see though is some kind of integration with the Stickies application. I use Stickies much the same way I use todos, plastered on my desktop reminding me of some critical task I absolutely can't forget to do before I turn off my iBook.

If the Stickies app could pull todo info out of iCal or, better yet, if I could set an "alarm" that would paste a Stickie to my desktop a day or so before an apointment or before a todo item is due to be completed. I think "Sticky Alarms" would make for a great feature. I run Stickies in the background on my computer all the time anyway (starts on login) so I wouldn't need to run any extra apps in the background if Stickies could just access the iCal and Address book databases and decide on it's own whether or not to display new information.

Posted by: M Popke at February 24, 2003 03:13 PM

I own a copy of Daylite which is a great PIM/CRM applications. This application integrates the calender and address book functions and also syncs up with Apples address books. There is also an import for most other major PIM's. I believe that Daylite will also eventually sync calenders with iCal.

Another new and great application is Konfabulator. For the person who wants to incorporate Stickies with iCal, there is a widget that does this. Konfabulator is a program which accomodates Java Scripting in the form of Widgets ( small programs for specific purposes). It has been on the market for just a couple of weeks and there is already over 100 programs posted to do interesting and useful things. One of them happens to incorporate a To Do list with iCal.

The best thing about both of these programs are that they were developed for native OS X.
And of course, if there are weaknesses, it is because they are not yet fully mature.

Posted by: greg at February 24, 2003 03:57 PM

Try Personal Organizer. It loads fast and does the work of a secretary. Excellent app!

John Davis

Posted by: John Davis at February 24, 2003 04:36 PM

For my important meetings and stuff in iCal I use the alarm function...This pops up a window and makes a sound, the sound and pop up even come up on my iPod.

I like them separate, then I only have active the stuff I want/need at the time. I agree that the one big application to solve all my problems is a way I don't like to go...

I like how Apple is integrating all of their applications, various pieces of information are available and passed in between.

Office (including Entourage) has some nice features that I would like to use, but it doesn't integrate with the Apple applications (or iPod) very easily.

Now if I could pick the application vendor for the functionality I wanted, and had them all integrated together...that would be cool!

I have tried the Microsoft Outlook on the Mac, but they do not offer an OS X version...When I have tried it (my work email has an Exchange Server) it seemed very slow. I also use Lotus Notes (work customer) which seems to perform acceptably, but the font size is to small. And the way Lotus says to fix that doesn't seem to work for me (entry in an notes.ini file)...

Posted by: Bruce McPhee at February 24, 2003 04:57 PM

Working with windows during the day and Mac's at night allows me to cross-reference each system. I prefer the small package approach of the separate application. The Outlook/entourage system is too much all in one for my liking.

Integration is the key however. If each program could be kept tight, and the integration maximized (similar to what is just beginning to evolve with iLife), I beleive we could have the best of both PIM worlds.
Lets hope that this is the direction apple is taking us.

Posted by: MacKenzie at February 24, 2003 05:46 PM

I agree with the original comment that PIMM’s on the Mac are WEAK. Anyone who has been exposed to applications like ACT! And Goldmine (both only on Windows). Will see that the two top Mac entries (Now and Organizer) are but pale in comparison. There is a new PIMM called DayLite from Marketplace that is attempting to fill that gap but they have a way to go.
The other business area that the Mac is deficient is in Time billing. This is true since TimeSlips got off the Mac. Again, there are several applications that are trying to enter this area but they are from very weak to middling. If the Mac shall succeed in the business world Apple must rectify these deficiencies.

Posted by: Richard Meyeroff at February 24, 2003 09:23 PM

I tried Now Up to Date. It's a very full-featured program BUT has no e-mail integration and, what's worse, the Contacts do not work with Apple's Mail or Address. Meaning you have to open up contact, manually find the e-mail address, copy, then paste.
UhUh. No thanks to that.
I e-mailed support asking when a workaround or script would be developed to work with Address Book or Mail.
Naturally, they didn't bother to answer.
The more I look, the better Apple's Mail and Address Book looks after all.

Posted by: Mac Mike at February 25, 2003 07:40 AM

Mike--I'm confused about one thing...why not just use Entourage X? It's basically Outlook without Exchange capability, which MSFT just announced will be added for free this summer.

There's exactly two useful programs that MSFT makes in my opinion--Excel and Entourage, and while I generally dispise Microsoft, Entourage is indeed an excellent all-in-one PIM app.

Posted by: Charles Gaba at February 25, 2003 07:06 PM

My biggest problem with Entourage X is it's rather inefficient and needlsly complicated junk mail filters. Even with Spam Sieve, it's not nearly as efficient as Mail - from my expeierience.
I also like Mail's signature control - automatic by account. And I also like Address book's general look.
I may go back and start again with Entourage. Then again, word is that NUTD will soon have a patch that integrates its contact list with Mail.

Posted by: Mac Mike at February 26, 2003 08:01 AM

I switched from Outlook (on a Windows PC) to Entourage and I felt shortchanged because some of the features were weaker than their PC counterparts . . . especially in an office enviornment where we trade calendar events, sent notices of events, assign tasks to other people, etc. I have now migrated again and this time to iCal and it obviously is NOT designed for integration in the business enviornment. Entourage is not much better, so for now I am sticking with iCal, but the reality is I am giving up even more features.

Apple simply needs to offer more small business apps and features if it wants to be competitive. As an Apple evangalist inside my company, I am often forced to admit that Apple simply does not offer the tools (even in the form or 3-rd party apps) to effectively compete with the win-tel dynasty. iCal is a nice try, and probably great for a family calendar, but not in the work-a-day world.

Posted by: Bob Skurka at February 26, 2003 03:00 PM

Here is the latest for Now's PIM:

on Macintosh:


Now Contact to/from AddressBook scripts - In testing

Now Up-to-Date to/from iCal scripts - In late development

Now Up-to-Date 4.5 - In development

Now Up-to-Date Public Event Event Server (running as a Daemon) - In development

Now Contact 4.5 - In development

Now Contact Public Contact Server (running as a Daemon) - In development

For Windows:

Now Up-to-Date for Windows - Done! Released in late 2002 and selling well!

Now Up-to-Date Palm Conduits - In testing

Now Up-to-Date Public Event Server - In testing

Now Contact - In development

Now Contact Public Contact Server - In development

Now Contact Palm Conduits - In development

Posted by: Moshdaddy at February 26, 2003 05:26 PM

If you have a Palm, why not use the free and quite serviceable Palm Desktop? I've been using this for several years and it works great.

Unfortunately, iSync for Palm is pretty nasty. It would be great to sync the Palm with my Apple Address Book, but I won't use iSync until the bugs are ironed out. Too many reports of people having their Palm databases mangled by iSync.

But Palm Desktop is jes' fine. For me, iCal is pretty weak by comparison. Buggy, slow, and overly simplistic. They'll have to beef it up before I can really consider it. And why use NOW when Palm Desktop is free and integrates so nicely with the Palm hardware?

Oh -- and welcome to the Rebel Alliance!

Adam

Posted by: Adam Bezark at February 28, 2003 10:42 AM

i've been using the Palm Desktop, syncing between home and work, and i've found it imperfect -- good enough to keep using, so far, but not reliable. WAY too often, updated records don't update, but duplicate instead, so i will have, say, two entries for my girlfriend, and i have to toggle back and forth to see which one is the more up to date. or, i'll notice that events that i know i input, and i remember seeing on my home desktop in the morning, are not on my hand-held (and, therefore, of course, not copied onto my work machine).

has anyone noticed this difficulty, and if so, discovered a fixable cause for it?

as for iCal, i was greatly intrigued, before i got it, particularly for the ability to separate home and work skeds, to look at them individually, or together. (and, of course, to have other calendars too, for sports events, or tv watching, or whatever.)

but since my handheld will only display one calendar, the iCal "advantage" -- and i can't see anything else it does differently, never mind better, than palm -- seems unavailable to me. anything that doesn't allow me to keep one database -- at home, at work, and on the road -- is of no use to me.

does anyone have thoughts on any of this, please?

thanks.

Posted by: Michael P. at February 28, 2003 11:01 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits