
The more I use Macs the more I appreciate them. But just what is the appeal of these machines? It is really hard to define and some of the posts and comments from other recent switchers I've been receiving have really got me thinking about how difficult it is to explain this attraction to PC folks.
Here's an e-mail I got last night, for example:
Windows does a great job, but thats all it is - it just does what you want it to, and now without crashing. But it does not stir any emotions. Windows is like your maid, the Mac is like your spouse. Talk to someone who has never loved - they have no clue what love is about. But talk to someone who has loved - they do not want to lead a life without love. And that may be why Windows users go out of their way to bash Mac users.- from PravinThis guy "loves" his Mac. An IT manager (see below) wrote me the other day to say he was "seduced" by a Mac. Others have called their Macs "elegant" and "pliant" and "sensual."
I am a sales person for a web-development firm here in Michigan. I use a PC at work, and a Mac at home. In fact I just bought one of the new low end power macs, and I love it. But I am not speaking here as a mac user, but as a salesman.
I have gone through months of sales training, and there is one thing that is stressed over all other concepts.
People buy emotionally. They say their are practical reasons. But all purchase decisions are fundumentally emotional.
People buy from me because they trust me. Trust is an emotion. People don't switch from Windows for a variety of reasons, fear, comfort, anger. These are all emotions.
Posted by: John at February 21, 2003 09:56 AMIt is the Macintosh Experience that gives us that passionate reaction to a system that "feels right".
That is why even though I'm an MCSE with an MSCS, I became the CEO of MacNut Mazine.
Life is too short to have to deal with stuff that doens't work. Macs work well.
Posted by: Robert Pritchett at February 21, 2003 10:20 AMI'd like to tag on to what John just said. People have often questioned the appeal of Macs, suggesting that "emotional" appeal somehow shouldn't count, that computers are tools. Yet who buys cars without emotion? Even Taurus (or, God help them, Camry) owners look longingly at the sexy cars across the showroom before choosing their conform-mobiles. And if you want to talk about true tools, go to a hardware store and note the people holding and admiring Estwing hammers, or DeWalt drills - they're well-designed aesthetically as well as functionally. Just like a Mac.
American culture (and I'm fully a product of it) has big problems with design and aesthetics. It's a bit like the old cliche about Athens & Rome - Greek artists, Roman engineers. Americans have almost always fancied themselves Romans. But at least the Romans were wise enough to value Greek aesthetics. I'm not sure mainstream America really recognizes what it's missing - whether they drive a Camry or work on a Dell.
Posted by: JRoth at February 21, 2003 10:23 AMI rarely write letters on the internet, but your recent discussion about
the Mac's appeal made me think about it myself. (I'm originally from
the Detroit area. My family owns a photography store in Royal Oak. So
I get a kick out of reading a Free Press writer.)
I am (like you) buying my first Mac after years of working with PCs. I
just ordered a 12 inch powerbook after borrowing a 15inch powerbook from
the university where I work. I think about Macs in relationship to
cameras, which I know very well.
A camera is a tool, like a computer, but each one is different. It
offers different features, has a different feel, in short, it has a
different personality. Over the years, PCs have become almost
indistinguishable from each other. They are so generic in their design
that the buyer has almost nothing to choose from. I've bought Dells
because of their service. Otherwise, I see very little difference
between them and other PCs.
With the Mac, on the other hand, it seems they are designed with the way
that individuals actually think and work, and the seamless integration
of the programs is remarkable. Aesthetics are important, especially
when you're working with a tool as much as I do. I can get good
pictures with a Pentax, but I certainly like the feel and sound of a
Leica a whole lot more. And it's the same with Macs. I write for long
hours, make numerous powerpoint presentations, use the web for research
and fun, do digital photography, and burn CDs. Using a Mac is like
using a fine camera. There is an integration of design, functionality,
and aesthetics that doesn't exist on PCs. Plus they work.
The Mac mystique -- it's something that fascinates me. In all other material things, I stress functionality, not style (I drive a Subaru wagon, for instance).
And yet I'm hopelessly sucked in by Macs. As corny as it sounds, they've always "spoken to me" on some fundamental level. Yes, I know they're just machines, just wires and circuit boards, but I get the sense that the people who design Macs really try to do something special with them. Yes, the machines are souless, but not the people behind them. Plus, under their elegance and style, there is a very powerful OS that lets everyday folks like me do some very neat stuff -- that is the essence of good design.
And Macs certainly appeal to some people simply because some people, as a matter of principle, will not follow the crowd.
Which makes me wonder -- if Macs, as wonderful as they are, had 95% of the market, would people feel so passionately about them?
Posted by: Scott at February 21, 2003 08:25 PMIf Mac's had 95% of the market, I invision a few things...
1. The products wouldn't be as cool, as Apple wouldn't have to try harder.
2. There would be less war, as people would be not as full of anger and hostility, bred from the Blue Screen of Death.
3. Steve Jobs would be "the most hated man" but geeks worldwide.
-- Joshua
(PS: You forgot to add MacNN.com to your Mac site list. I did add you to mine however!)
Posted by: joshua wachs at February 22, 2003 07:42 AMOops! MacNN is now added. Don't know how that happened as it's one of my favorite Mac sites.
Meantime, it's good to know that I'm not the only one with an emotional attachment to my Mac.
Apparently, it lasts forever....
The appeal to Mac for me is the integration each feature and piece of software has. PCs are typically sold on features lists which often don't work together at all. When Apple adds features they tend to compliment the basics. I relate it to building a house slowly according to a master plan instead of hundreds of different contractors tacking on the latest trendy room. That formula works well for productivity and avoiding headache. If I bought a PC now I would have a hard time bringing the features up the what my Mac has. I wouldn't even know where to start adding firewire cards, graphics cards, sound cards, and gigabit and wireless networking. The PC world still doesn't have anything close to iMovie. I like being able to pull the machine out of the box and start working. Most PC users are reluctant to switch because the don't believe that Macs work so well. I started bringing my PowerBook to work and now many people in the office have already bought one, and the rest have their old PCs on eBay. I have found that a demonstration is necessary because PC people don't believe that it is possible to make a computer work so seamlessly.
Posted by: Bill at February 22, 2003 08:31 PMMy need for the Mac is simple -- I'm in the advertising business and here in Malaysia, colour separators support the Mac platform 100%.
Here, if you're not on the Mac platform, you're not in the creative business.
I'm replying a tad late to this but I heartily agree. I have found I've gotten more excited over my iBook compared to my Sony VAIO. It just takes me by surprise how much more I enjoy computer now that I've switched.
I also love how easier it is to be creative on Macs. I only wish it could help me come up with good story ideas! ;)
Posted by: Kim at October 10, 2003 05:09 AM
I agree in the lack of ability to explain why Macs appeal as much as they do. Its coincidental that this is today's post, because just yesterday I had a discussion with a coworker about why I love my Mac. The only conclusion I could tell him was that while Microsoft products are good at what they do, Macs are just plain fun. Microsoft OS's don't give you that "fun" feeling when you use them. When I go home at night and turn on my Mac, there is a rush that I just don't get with a PC. Maybe its the elegance of the Mac. Who knows. But for whatever reason, I'm glad I switched, and can't see ever not owning a Mac again.
Posted by: Matt at February 21, 2003 09:21 AM