
Being an IT Manager in a commercial environment, I am heavily involved in the whole PC culture (that's the IBM personal computer variety). However, a recent visit to PC World completely changed my outlook on the Computerscape. There, sitting in a poorly maintained display were a number of machines bearing the Apple logo. Intrigued, I played on a 15" Powerbook running OS X. Within minutes I was hooked - no - utterly seduced by the sheer sexuality of the Mac OS X experience. I've since tried to apply objectivity to this emotion and cannot come up with a logical explanation for my love affair. Is it the software? Is it the beautifully crafted hardware? I can't answer, but regrettably, the desire felt has been expressed through my wallet. My credit card now bears the full impact of an impulse purchase of a 17" Powerbook from the UK Apple store, and my nights are now spent in feverish anticipation. However, business does not succumb to such emotions. I ask myself, much as I love what I've already experienced and read about my newfound discovery, how could I, as an IT Manager in a competitive commercial environment, make a sound business case for moving to the Mac platform? Hardcore Mac afficonados seem to miss the point; Linux is only being considered as a possible viable alternative to the Windows platform because it is free. Cost counts for everything in business - if I can have 95% of the functionality with 100% reduction in cost, my Finance Director will jump at the opportunity. If I make a case for 95% of the functionality with a 100% increase in cost (as per the Mac), I'll most likely get fired. Unfortunately, Apple's strongest points (sex appeal) count for little within the business community and whilst they continue to exclusively manufacture their own hardware, cost is going to be a prohibitive factor. To port OS X to the Intel platform would also be corporate suicide - a large proportion of their turnover comes from selling hardware, and the additional development burden imposed upon them by having to deal with the compatibility issues of running on an infinite number of hardware combinations, would grind the OS development to a virtual standstill. I suspect stability would also suffer. So, can Apple make it in the Business sector? I don't think so. Apple's real growth opportunities lie in the domestic market, where sex appeal can influence buying decisions. If a hard headed, PC oriented IT Manager is willing to make the switch at home, it's proof that there's a market. - Chris Randall, UKI know of three large U.S. businesses - one of them my own employer - that will be doing major upgrades to their computer systems this year. Apple wasn't even in the consideration. Long-term, of course, anything is possible. The new laptops are turning heads everywhere. The new iMacs are works of art. You don't hear PC/WIntel users gushing about how much they like their Dells and HP's and clones. Apple's continuing retail efforts to capture home users by "switching" WIntel buyers, coupled with a renewed effort to win back the large amount of educational sales that have gone to PC makers in recent years, will slowly help change the culture and put Macs back on the radar screens of would-be buyers/upgraders. But that means a lot of new products building on the Mac platform need to keep coming out. The reputed new color iPod will be big. So will a rumored 15-inch PowerBook to sandwich between the tiny 12-incher and the massive 17-incher. And, of course, prices have to drop even more. Though greatly improved, Macs are still too costly, when compared to comparably-equipped PC's. Build on your strengths, Apple. It isn't the corporate world. It's the home and educational user. And, above all, keep nurturing your community. Strengthen customer relations. Nobody sells better than a satisfied customer. Business buyers may be out there some day. Right now, it's the home and school user that offers opportunity.
Lack of software?!?!?!?!?
Other than MS-Project ... tell me an application that does not exist for OSX or X11 that exists for a PC -- sorry -- "games" are not applications.
Posted by: Ron Blaisdell at February 20, 2003 08:57 AMBut what of Total Cost of Ownership?
If it truly is a matter of "money" that determines Apple's success in the marketplace then they'd actually be number one. Time and again, Macs have been shown to have a lower TCO than PCs not to mention a faster rate return on investment. EVEN when the cost of the actual computer is figured into the formula.
IT infrastructure is focused on the upfront costs to hide the dirty little secret that PCs cost much more to maintain, troubleshoot, and support than Macs do, if given the chance in an enterprise. The ratio of techs per box for Macs is much lower, even with Mac OS X than with PCs. They also give the end users greater productivity due to their increased uptime over PCs.
I still think that Macs have a chance in the business market. Maybe it will take a smaller company that sticks with their Macs and then grows into a Fortune 500 success story, maybe it will take a company that gets fed up with having their budgets raided by MS's Licensing schemes but some large company will step up and switch to Macs. It's only a matter of time.
Posted by: Bob McC at February 20, 2003 10:56 AMTCO and ROI can't be underestimated, The Gistics ROI report clearly shows that you can recover the cost of converting to macs very quickly while racking up lower support costs.
Our department is currently embroiled in the debate to switch to windows, but as we are all mac, they are having trouble justifying the fact that our current support costs on Macs are 2/3rds the costs of theirs for supporting PCs in the same environment.
Posted by: Dan at February 20, 2003 11:41 AMThe problem with getting Macs into the corporate environment is that those who specify what computers to use are non-Mac people. This means that they, by virtue of their familiarity with their existing platform, are naturally going to recommend keeping that platform. Job security is a strong motivator. Why put forth the effort to learn a new platform, if it may in the end result in the elimination of your position, as the Mac has long been shown to need less support and administration? When the owner or president of a large corporation (who is not an IT type), reviews recommendations for new systems, he/she relies on their IT chief as to what to purchase. That IT person has a vested interest in promoting a platform that's going to keep him/her employed. That's why it's hard to get Macs into corporate America, even though the return on investment is better on a Mac!
Posted by: Karl Groeger at February 20, 2003 11:57 AMI'm sure that Apple knows what they are up against in the business world. They seem content with simply a "hearts and minds" campaign for now. They know that in all actuality, whole-sale switch overs to Macs from Windows will never happen. Hence, they are focusing on making sure that Macs integrate well into Windows networks. Winning over individual users a little at a time seems to be working and working quite well. They are leveraging the superior advantage of the PowerPC chips for the mobile platform and really have laptops that are a better value. Unfortunately, the advantages of the PowerPC don't yet extend to the desktop. It is coming, but until it does, an all out assault on the desktop will have to wait. For now, they are getting huge amounts of positive press where the converse is true of Microsoft. They have nothing to fear from open source as OS X plays quite well with Linux and Apple really is a hardware as opposed to a software company. They have a nice upgrade path to 64 bit computing and IBM will in all liklihood deliver the 970 chip in a timely fashion. Add the iApps, Rendezvous, an open source underpinning with the superior chip architecture, and it is easy to understand how Apple is going to become much more of a major player. The x86 world is in disarray. Dell relentlessly undercuts everyone and stifles innovation with the price pressures that are brought to bear. Microsoft has Linux to worry about and how to compete with an essentially "free" OS. They now also have to support two different chip architectures (x86-64 and IA-64). It is also extremely doubtful that the Wintel manfufacturers can make a decent 64 bit mobile computing platform, no matter the cost. I am fairly certain that we will see a PowerPC 970 chip in a PowerBook. It is only a matter of time, barring an unforseen disaster. It would be nice to see Apple drop the price of their existing PowerMacs to better compete with Dell, Even if it means scaling back profits to the minimum. It will win over more new converts and have others get smitten by the experience. When the 970 chip comes out, they then can charge much higher prices for the privilege of getting the type of performance that the 970 promises. Windows on either AMD or Intel will simply be unable to compete. If I were a beige box manufacturer, I would seriously be looking at IBM's chip for running Linux at rock bottom Wal-Mart prices. But that is another story.
Posted by: Jeff at February 20, 2003 12:11 PMTechnically, it can happen one computer at a time. With OS X, Macs can be transparent players on most any network. Thus, it isn't an all or none switch, which is what the author of this message seems to think. Cubical one has a PC, cubical two has a Mac. They are sharing files on the same file server, they are IMing w/ the same software, they are accessing the same material on the net. They are sharing the same MS Office (Excel, PowerPoint, Word). What's the big deal? Cubical one prefers Cross pens, cubical two prefers a basic Bic. Who cares?
Many colleges and universities give their faculty a choice of platform b/c it's a no brainer to support both from a networking stand point (although Macs are far easier to support b/c of the lack of SUPPORT Mac users actaully need and are thus far cheaper to own in the long run)
Even if repairs for machines are needed most of the major most-often-replaced parts (mouse, monitor, drives, etc.) of machines are non-platorm considerations. Unlike if a motherboard bites it in the corporate world they buy a new machine.
I think the "Corporate world" needs to give their employees some choices and they will be better off in the in the long run.
I believe our UK friend is operating under a misguided paradigm of "compatability"; because, Macs are actually very compatible in any environment. In fact, I have yet to find an environment where I can't be a player. I'm a businessman (in a PC dominated world), a student (at two universities), and I'm a teacher at a public school that uses and supports both platforms. My Mac w/ OS X hasn't let me down yet.
Posted by: iCarus at February 20, 2003 03:52 PMDon't forget status.
It's true that Macs can't make it in large companies right now. But for small to medium sized companies that don't require a custom Oracle solution, the top execs can put Macs on their desks to differentiate themselves from the common folk.
Consider: the working stiffs all have black Dell boxes and black monitors and the Big Boys (and Girls) have stunning Mac cinema displays.
Kind of tells you who's who. Can't you just see the corporate Switcher ad, tailored for the top brass?
Posted by: Jeffff at February 20, 2003 05:19 PMThe PC market seems important because it's technology that "average" people can grasp, because of the fortunes it built and because it represents that a handful of people tinkering away can change the world but 25-30 years after the computer revolution, being the #1 PC maker is really like being #1 in watches. It means very little because the title just goes to the most efficient manufacturer/distributor. After the commodization of the marketplace (after IBM initial success), look at the roll call of #1 - Tandy, Zenith, Packard Bell, Gateway, Compaq, etc ... It's like being the fastest man in the 100 - your stay is brief and glorious but that's all it is - brief.
Unlike most other industries where generally being #1 allows you an advantage (besides just manufacturing costs) in distribution, marketing, sales, etc ... in PC's it means nothing. I'm not going to go into detail why this is but what other product in history has gone down so much in average price AND you get a breathtaking improvement in EVERY aspect of that product? Nothing. So, any set business rules goes out the window.
The corporate marketplace? It's a commodity - how many bulbs do I need to light this floor? How many desks are going in? I need the same number of staplers as I do PC's. So for Apple, the marketplace is gone because they are selling electric staplers that costs more so as one of the other reader pointed out, it's about the cost. The requirements are Does it run an Office suite, a browser, email and access to a DB? That's all a PC needs to do.
And we are at the cusp where companies are looking around and wondering where they can cut ... like perhaps the MS Office suite which is nearly the cost of a PC for something else - which is partially why MS created that viral logic licensing plan.
So, your other readers are right in that Apple will never get back to the forefront of the corporate marketplace but I also think it's a pointless battle for many reasons because it's the anthesis of what Apple stands for as a personal computer in today's marketplace anyway ... that's more than just a collection of silicon, plastic & metal.
The ideal goal for Apple is to convince people that you don't buy the company car to drive on the weekends ... or buy exactly the same lamp you have at work or drink the coffee they serve in the break room ... The Switcher campaign and others have touched upon that but there's no obvious parallel markets because the closest is the auto market but there are some major differences there as a comparison.
But in another aspect, this is the best time because we are now value driven for the things we cherish. We might clip coupons to buy toilet paper but we're driving there in a $60k SUV - and that's what Apple has to do without coming off as elitist ... one of the great selling ads of the imac was the internet in three steps and that what Apple has to pound home. We don't care if you have a Pc but here's how easy it is to bring in a video clip, photograph, etc... on a mac. Show bluetooth in action, etc ...
Is Apple going to be #1 ever again? No. But what's the point of selling a commodity? You're just angling to be knocked off when your costs rise a smidgen ...
So, Apple needs to convince people that market share means squat.
The current campaigns are fine but there should be more product demos because even though they are real people or celebrity real people, advertising is still advertising.
Apple is doing fine. They could be doing better profit wise so they don't have to raise bar much, they just have to move it a tad.
Posted by: jbelkin at February 21, 2003 01:59 AMWe have a 100% mac line up in our business. The business case for going for the mac platform was simple:
We run a network of 50+ computers, 4 printers, web servers, mail servers and print servers. Desktops are kitted out with MS Office + browser + mail client (business apps are all java web apps). Running windows 98 it took 1 x IT manager + 1 helper to keep everything in check (salary cost: £30k / annum). We switched everything to mac os x. We now have 1 x part-time IT person (salary cost: £6k / annum).
It's that simple. When we looked at the cost of upgrading to XP vs OSX there wasn't much difference (licensing, particularly on the server front, is evil in the MS world), but the sheer cost of maintinaing an MS network sold us the Mac.
Posted by: Simon at February 21, 2003 05:06 AMI blame the recession on PCs. If corporate America bought Macs productivity would go up, down time would decrease, and IT budgets could be cut by 90%. Many hardline PC users say that Macs are "not good" for office work, but I bring my personal PowerBook to work and it is the most productive machine in the building by a wide margine. The company PC on my desk e-mails and word processes, but that is about it. It really doesn't even do that well because e-mail will not display graphics or autofill addresses, jpegs won't open, and CD-R drives are "upgrades" so we don't have those for backups and moving data. Since my PowerBook has come to work with me it has been turning out webpages, maps, training DVDs, full color document page layouts, interactive CD presentations, and timely product images. The PowerBook has also become the company translator because the PCs can't read disks in other formats or open very many document types. There are often lines at my desk to use it, because the office PCs can't get the work done. Also, Office for Mac is much better than Office for Windows. It is difficult to explain why until you try it. I often get the claim that Macs are mostly good at graphics. However, the reason why graphics professional use it is not because it is the only thing it does, but because they don't have the time to fight with their computers. When a job needs to get done you can work with a Mac instead of working on it. I have not brought the PowerBook in to work for the past week, and the standards of quality have suffered greatly. As it has turned out many people in the office have gone out and bought their own Macs, and they have been springing up on desks like daisies with the company PCs left to collect dust. I work for a government agency, so people feel that bringing their own computers to work is helping out king and country instead of lining someones pockets. If it were a for-profit company it would be left to whither on the vine like other companies I have worked for. Unfortunately, it may take an act of congress to get government Macs in the office.
Posted by: Bill at February 22, 2003 09:12 PM"Macs are still too costly, when compared to comparably-equipped PC's."
Please name ONE comparably equipped PC that costs less than my 12" PowerBook G4.
FireWire,SuperDrive,Dual USB Eithernet, iLife, not to mention OS X. Out of the box less than $2000.00. I don't doubt it will happen sooner or later but for right now it's not possible.
seeya
dxtr
I'm sure the TCO for Macs would be vastly lower for large enterprises. I mean, I run a small network (in my house) with 4 PCs and 1 iMac. I've had the iMac about a year now, and it has been almost exactly no trouble; I haven't had a single problem of any kind with it that hasn't been cured by rebooting. I recently upgraded the OS on one of the PCs, and spent more time doing that than the total admin time for the iMac for the year (including the upgrade to Jaguar from 10.1, which may only be a point release but added more functionality than the average Windows upgrade).
In fact, the only issues I've had that have even been remotely tricky have been around networking with PCs. Funny, that. If we could afford to go Mac-only tomorrow I'm sure we would.
For most end users it's the difference between a system that can be coaxed into doing what you want with a bit of tinkering and knowing about the idiosyncracies, and a system that is beautiful and does what you expect it to.
Posted by: Alison Scott at February 24, 2003 01:02 PMI've just finish a contract in an advertising agency part of a worldwide group. Although they had mostly Mac, they did run several Windows servers. Four month ago they bought an XServe to replace the aging server, a month ago they bought 2 other Xserve to replace all the remaining servers.
Even if they were not formed on the Mac and all the other worldwide associate use windows server they went with the Mac. It may be a small thing but if IT department begins to switch to OS X servers maybe they will be more incline to reevaluate the user platform as well.
They also fell in love with Apple Remote Desktop, the IT manager even got a 15" Powerbook to administer all the machine in the office, even from home.
Posted by: Stephane at February 24, 2003 01:13 PMI am a principal of a small architecture firm. Several years ago we converted our operations from Mac OS to Windows. However, the very last Mac purchase was a G3 Powerbook. Last year, after reading comments about OS X, I bought a copy of 10.1.5, loaded it onto the G3 and have been using it every day. When Jaguar came out, I upgraded the system immediately.
The result of this experiment is that I intend to convert our organization from a Windows based office to a Mac OS X based office. And the primary reason for this conversion is my experience with the stability of OS X.
If anyone evaluates productive time as a cost factor in IT expense, they would arrive at a similar decision. For this reason, I believe there is a place for the Mac in business.
Posted by: Greg at February 24, 2003 04:44 PMI work in an IT dept that supports about 400 macs with MS servers for every creative function at two daily newspapers. We also support about 300 PCs for administrative and business functions. (And we've been testing an X-Serve, by the way.)
Our Macs are largely G4 towers for demanding works and circa-1994/5 PowerMac 8100s for less-demanding work. Our photographers are equipped with professional digital cameras and iBooks and our reporters use iBooks and an assortment of aging Powerbooks.
The 8100s used to do the demanding work but devolved when we upgraded, replacing even older machines -- our usual practice.
Not only are these machines incredibly reliable and easily repairable, bu the great bulk of our Mac support involves supporting users with unfamiliar tasks, "I'm-a-JOURNALIST-dammit-not-a-computer-jockey" types who don't want to learn more than minimum technology. A very large percentage of our time is spent dealing with MS Exchange/Outlook issues.
In general, we could be better described as user analysts than systems analysts.
We craft and test standard configurations for our machines and simply replace the config if anything arises that is more serious than a corrupted preference file. Updates and changes, as well as a great deal of support, are delivered using Apple's Network Assistant and network user profiles are maintained using Apple's Mac Manager.
Why do we have Macs? Because our company, which publishes papers is most major Canadian cities, recognizes that our Macs have lower support costs and longer working lifetimes in our environment, resulting in a superior return on investment for the business.
Posted by: Craig Ferry at February 24, 2003 06:50 PMOur company cannot run Mac since we have too many applications developed. If your company's work revolve around using Office, then I don't see why you couldn't use Mac. However, the reality is that all companies use customized application that runs on Windows.
I completely agree with the IT manager, since I'm one myself, and have been struggling to bring Macs into our company. That's the reality folks.
Posted by: Joon at February 27, 2003 09:11 AMHaving spoken to many businesses, I have found that it is not "businesses" that always go for the lowest cost. It is the IT staff. In most other purchases businesses make the decision to buy a product or a service is a complicated mix of features, functionality, need, want and personal relationships (selling). IT costs in today's businesses represent only a fraction of the total costs. People represent by far the biggest cost item in most businesses. Next is buildings, cars etc. Note the businesses to not always buy or lease the cheapest cars, buildings, furniture or hire the cheapest people. PC's and infrastructure computers make people more efficient. Macs make people more efficient than PC's, thereby saving money. All businesses should buy Macs. Besides, the TCO of Macs is generally lower than for Windows, Linux or Unix systems. In reality, Macs are cheaper.
IT staff should stop looking at purchase price and comparing it to there monthly salary and then trying to find cheaper alternatives. IT staff should look at the real business arguments when they make purchasing recommendations to management. Saving a few thousand dollars in a purchase is irrelevant in a million-dollar business over the lifetime of the product, when compared to the savings in TCO, productivity and general satisfaction of the users.
Posted by: Maarten at March 20, 2003 05:07 AM
as enamored as i am with the Mac *lifestyle* and as impressed i (and many others are) am with the OS itself there is no way Mac will ever make serious gains in the business market. the lack of software, the price of the hardware and the overall tide of the market.
sadly, it won't happen in this lifetime.
Posted by: m. whyte at February 20, 2003 08:46 AM