« eBay giving up user data to law enforcement without subpoena? | Main | Apple's new 12-inch laptop »

February 18, 2003

Apple's 12-inch PowerBook: The best laptop for me

This is a slightly edited and expanded version of the review that appeared in today's Detroit Free Press
My new 12-inch Apple PowerBook G4 is one hot laptop.
Literally.
Blame it on the slick and slim anodized-aluminum case which noticeably warms up when the machine has been in use for a half hour or so, but it does get toasty. On these cold Michigan days, it's like my own portable handwarmer. I'm not sure how I'll feel about it as I toil away in August out on the back deck.
The heat build up in the 12-inch machine has drawn its share of complaints from early users in some of the Mac chatrooms. I think they're just a bunch of whiny babies.
One of the posters on my mac-mike.com blog said he measured the heat on a 12-inch PowerBook that had been on for seven hours as part of a retail display and recorded 84 degrees - noticeable, but hardly uncomfortable.
The 12-inch PowerBook doesn't have a built in fan. That's another reason for the warmth. I think the silence that provides more than makes up for the heat issue.
Apple's Steve Jobs declared 2003 to be "the year of the laptop" and introduced the 12-inch model - Apple's smallest - last month, along with a new 17-inch version -the largest. Both computers are about an inch thick.
The 17-incher is expected to start showing up in Apple retail stores later this month, starting at $3299. The 12-inch machine is already shipping.
Overall, the 12-inch PowerBook G4 is the finest laptop I've ever used. I like it so much that I bought it. The price starts at $1,799. For that, you get an 867 MHz processor, 256 MB of memory, a 40 GB hard drive, a slot-loading combo drive (DVD-ROM/CD-RW), built-in wireless Bluetooth capabilities to connect to mobile phones, handhelds and printers, and a claimed 5 hours of battery life.
I get more like three hours. But I am also using Apple's new Airport Extreme wireless networking that connects me to the Internet and the other computers -Macs and PC's - in my home network system. The always-on radio transmitter and receiver that maintains the so-called Wi-Fi connection is the reason my battery drains faster.
The new PowerBooks use the faster 802.11g wireless protocol, which moves data at up to 54 megabits per second, compared to the 11 Mbps speeds of the older 802.11b Wi-Fi standard.
The extra speed of Airport Extreme isn't something people would notice, particularly if used only to share a home Internet connection. That's because the fastest home broadband is only about 1.5 mbps, something that never even stressed the slower 802.11b standard.
But for business and power users who move a lot of files around on your Wi-Fi network, crunching data, working with images or video, Airport Extreme's capabilities will be very welcome.
I chose to have my PowerBook installed with Apple's SuperDrive, instead of the standard combo. For $200 more, the SuperDrive records and plays back both CD's and DVD's, something unheard of in a super lightweight laptop. There's also a built-in 56k telephone modem and an Ethernet connection for hard-wired networks.
What won me over was the size. I want something easy to carry and full-featured but I don't need another desktop. That's what the 17-incher seems to be, a desktop replacement. The 12-incher measures 10.9 inches wide, 8.6 inches deep, 1.18 inches thin. Even the square, one-piece AC power adapter is small.
While the 12-inch unit is near perfect for my needs, there are some things Apple could do to improve it. It can't take more than 640 MB of memory and there's no L3 memory cache, a more efficient memory feature standard on many other laptops. There's no PC card slot, either.
Those are not, in my view, major shortcomings.
About the thing I'm disappointed with is that the 12-incher doesn't have the lighted keyboard feature that activates on the 17-inch model whenever the ambient light falls to a certain level.
That would be as cool as the 12-incher is hot.


in Hardware | TrackBack (0)

Comments

it lacks dvi out, quite important if you want to connect additional apple monitors...

Posted by: peter at February 18, 2003 08:31 AM

The 12 inch is clearly not meant as a desktop replacement... I do talks and PowerPoint (soon to be Keynote) presentations, show video out through projectors, even edit some video on this laptop. But if you want a desktop replacement or something to use with a monitor at home, get a 17 incher..As I said, this is a terrific laptop.
I have never needed to hook up a larget monitor to a laptop. Obviously, if someone does, they need something different.
For me - and the vast majority of users - I can't think of anything I'd recommend more.

Posted by: Mac Mike at February 18, 2003 09:05 AM

If I were to buy this laptop at an Apple store, what is their return policy if I determine that the heat is too much of a problem for me?

Posted by: Frank McPherson at February 18, 2003 09:49 AM

The reports of the temperature being measured at 84 degrees does not sound credible... your body is warmer than that so an 84 degree laptop would not feel warm/hot to the touch. I've seen claims of temperatures measured at around 100 degrees on the bottom and left-wrist rest area in other forums and this sounds more accurate. This is still cooler than some wintel machines which reportedly can reach up to 120 degrees.

Also, the 12" PowerBook DOES have a fan - it rarely comes on in mine though but it is audible (but not terribly loud) when it does. Perhaps all the heat being conducted/radiated to the exterior keeps the innards cool enough to avoid tripping the fan.

Finally, if you are experiencing excessive heat build-up be sure that your battery is charging properly - the power-plug ring should turn green once the battery is fully charged. If the plug stays amber forever this can cause the laptop to get unusually hot and should be corrected. Resetting the PMU and/or fully discharging and then re-charging the battery have corrected the issue for many users although some users have reported needing to have Apple replace their batteries and or power-adaptors before the problem disappeared.

Posted by: Christopher Wolf at February 18, 2003 10:45 AM

I have a the 11" iBook, and frankly, I can't see the point of a 12" PowerBook at all. If I'm going to spend that much money on a laptop, I'm going to get one with a bigger screen.

Posted by: Natalie at February 18, 2003 12:18 PM

One can connect the news 12" PowerBook to an Apple LCD via a Gefen convertor box. It's not cheap, but it is possible.
http://www.gefen.com/kvm/product.jsp?prod_id=1301

Posted by: Karl Groeger at February 18, 2003 01:10 PM

Mike ---- I think your review is right on. This is a _wonderful_ little laptop, and a whole lot perkier than I expected it to be. Plays DVD movies without a stutter, burns CDs at a reasonable speed. The keyboard, as you and many others have noted, is outstanding. I am an extremely fast touch typist, and I don't think I've ever typed so fast on any other keyboard, standard or laptop. And, again as you point out, this is a truly QUIET computer. Very impressive little package.

PS I solved the heat problem by discharging - recharging the battery completely a second time.

Doffie

Posted by: Doffie Rotter at February 18, 2003 06:03 PM

Hey - was going to comment on the top heat recorded (122, on the apple boards) and the fact it has a fan, but someone beat me to it.

I will comment that if you want to squeeze about 4-5 hours out of the battery, turn your screen brightness down to as low as you can be happy with it, let the HD sleep, and turn the CPU down to "Reduced" capacity. You'll also less heat being produced. Cheers,

Randy

Posted by: Randy at February 18, 2003 08:35 PM

Hi,
I'm the person how measured the LittleAL in the retail setting, It was a totaly unscientific test using my Tripplett 9115 with the temperature probe taped to the left palm rest. Humm If you can't tell if something is warm that is cooler than skin temperature why does a room feel warm when the thermostat is set to 80 degrees? I picked up my LittleAL today and am in the process of calibrating the battery. I agree it is a HOT computer but not temperature wise for me so far.

seeya
dxtr

Posted by: dxtr at February 19, 2003 12:16 AM

i have the 12 inch also...its great..but the battery life is horrific...if i can get 2 hours im happy...going to pick up an extra battery but that seems silly, eh?

Posted by: steven at February 19, 2003 03:31 PM

Wanted to add that you can actually add more than 640 MB RAM to the unit. Right now you can only get a 512 MB SO-DIMM (144 pin). I would imagine in a couple of months you'll be able to get a 1 GB SO-DIMM (144 pin). Apple has stated in the knowledge base the 12-inch powerbook will support that newer memory when it comes out.

so hang in there!! Think about this: a 17" powerbook could have 2 GB RAM if and when this 1 GB SO-DIMM 144pin chip is released by memory manufactures. Now that's AWESOME.

Posted by: Anonymous at February 19, 2003 09:33 PM

Gefen announced that their VGA to ADC Converter works with the PowerBook 12.

The new 20 inch monitor requires an update in Gefen's box to accomodate the imaginative EDID that the 20 inch monitor is using for that resolution, but otherwise the PowerBook will work with that as well.

Posted by: cj flynn at February 20, 2003 10:31 AM

I have found that the temperature of my 12 inch Powerbook can be altered by either using the full length power cable or the short plug to power adaptor to connect, using the short cable I found that my power book went up to 36 degrees C, using the full (thicker) cable the temperature dropped, even though watching DVDs and playing itunes is hard drive intensive.
I actually sent my power book to apple.uk to check it out, they said it was acting normally.
now when i charge it i use the ling cable and it is actually cooler than my works laptop pc.

Posted by: Matthew B at February 21, 2003 12:34 PM

Just wanted to let you know I liked your column, and that I'm posting this from the comfort of my living room via AirPort Extreme. The 12-inch Powerbook is the laptop I've always wanted, and I'm extremely fortunate to have a husband who bought one for my birthday! Keep up the good work!

Posted by: Jen at February 22, 2003 04:51 PM

i called apple to ask about the heat issue - i burned my thigh accidentally with the machine - and was told by a very rude tech that basically i was misusing the machine, it was a compact notebook and NOT a laptop so never use it on my lap. I hope it doesn't discolor the finish on my maple desk.

Posted by: j. lurie at April 30, 2003 03:45 PM

When my 12" burns a DVD the heat really kicks up. My estimate is about 110-120 degrees at the back rear center area. However, I did find that placing 1.5mm self adhesive cork pads on the wrist rests tames the heat. Get them at arts & crafts supply stores. Dr. Bott sells the same thing pre-cut, too.

Posted by: John M at April 30, 2003 04:01 PM

has anyone else experienced keyboard "half-freezes?" I love my 12-inch, but occasionally about half the letter keys stop funcitoning, and I have to zap PRAM to get them back. I'm still running 10.2.3 -- when I stepped up to 10.2.4, my 'book froze on bootup and I had to reinstall from CD. Naturally, I'm hesitant to try any further upgrades...

Posted by: Daniel Clark at May 24, 2003 09:27 PM

If you keyboard half freezes, you might make sure the Num lock has not been activated. Do the keys work or do they type something they are not supposed to?

Posted by: Robert Holden at June 26, 2003 05:26 PM

I have noticed a few small problems with the 12" powerbook:

1. the battery drops from 100% to 70% overnight during sleep! and is empty after a few days. Apple support says this is normal, but the other powerbooks (15" tibook) and ibooks I have used never drop more than a few percent a day during sleep and can be left sleeping for a week.

2. the trackpad sometimes fails to change the insertion cursor while writing text, so the new text is inserted at the previous insertion point and you have to retype (the "ignore trackpad while typing" preference is switched off)

Posted by: borg at July 8, 2003 04:39 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits